WTF is wrong with the judicial system? How can this sentence be justified?
This guy should never be free again
Should be a minimum sentence per image/video found, multiplied by the number of people they can prove it was shared with. No remission or sentence reduction. Should easily add up to a full life sentence for these predators.
133 previous convictions to boot. Burglary, violent disorder . On his previous alone he should be gone forever. On this case alone, he should be put down . That poor boy .
This fucking country.
At least it’s not Judge Nolan but that’s still an astonishingly lenient sentence
I’ll wait for the regular bleeding hearts to pop in and explain how this will be the sentence that rehabilitates him once and for all.
‘’was facing a maximum life sentence for the defilement charge, a maximum sentence of five years for the possession charge, and up to 14 years on each of the other three charges.’’
The guy also had 133 previous convictions!
But only got 4 years ?? He probably be out in 2 years, what a joke of a system!
What the fuck. 4 years. I hope he is eaten alive in prison and it’s 4 years of hell for that vile piece of shit
He should be castrated then sentenced to life.
Children and victims of abuse don’t matter to this country
Absolute NONCE he’ll be torn apart in prison. Rightly so
Fucking hell, just throw the cunt into a volcano.
The state can challenge this sentence, can’t it? Constant, predictable leniency in these cases will have our country seen as a pariah at this rate. All the hand-wringing over the years about protecting the unborn and the very young, and we really can’t shove all this disgrace on the Catholic Church any more. 35-year old coke twats without a single redeeming characteristic are all our own work. (What’s also grim about this is the way it makes quite pacifist types like moi want to hear of condign justice meted out in prison, as though these men’s moral gangrene has infected *us* too)
How anyone with a record like his can be swanning about free to just carry on offending is incredible. Maybe those expert sniffer pooches/ hash puppies the Gardai use for their daily drug busts could be retrained to bite the ankles of egregious scrotes.
[He signed a bond agreeing to keep the peace and not reoffend for a period of two years after his release.]
Oh, that’s OK then.
Free to reoffend, but not for 2 whole years.
Such lenient sentencing – the only positive to take from this is that Martin Nolan wasn’t the presiding judge
If it was Nolan he probably would have said “Ah no, your a good lad don’t let it happen again off you go”
How does the money thing work? He offers 3,000€ is that not sort of a bribe? Like the more money you offer the less your sentence? I don’t really understand this
No matter how good your local TD is, remember these cases come election time.
I don’t usually get riled up about the short sentences stuff, but what the absolute fuck is this? The title leaves out that he filmed and shared the abuse…so abusing a small child, creating and distributing CP…4 years.
I understand you need to incentivise criminals to co-operate with Gardaí and the courts, so you might knock a few years off for that, but I would have thought it’d be more like getting 12-15 years instead of 20, not FOUR. This is one of the worst things a human can do….yet he’ll be out and about before 2028 probably
Same guy….
‘Fast cars are my heroin’: Man pleads guilty to reckless endangerment
Four years? Is that how life sentences are spelled these days?
What a sick joke.
What a rotten scumbag piece of shit. Four years??? That poor defenceless infant didn’t get enough justice.
Lads this country is broken beyond repair until someone comes in and actually knows how to run a country and fix the systems, processes and Governance structures. In this case tackle these rogue judges.
Young people dying after being dismissed in A&E, predators walking the streets with impunity, badly needed housing being objected to all over the place.
No one will tell me otherwise.
We are not a mature serious country. We may have money in our pockets and an abundance of job opportunities but that is not everything. I don’t think that will last for ever and we will need to have our shit sorted out when we reach that point.
I’m glad the judge was able to remove his anonymity while keeping the child from being named.
But I’m horrified the judge gave him such a short sentence. How us four years acceptable for sexually abusing a child and filming it to share with others.
> Marshall filmed himself abusing the boy and uploaded the material to social media platform Kik, which alerted the US-based National Centre for Missing and Exploited Children, which in turn contacted gardaí.
I’m glad somebody is monitoring these places and taking action.
Four fucking years !!!!!!!!! No, we’re not having that.
Immediately getting on to TDs.
If you guys offer me a free holiday, nothing fancy, I’ll make sure he never does this again, permanently
New rule –
If you catch someone like this, do thing you can’t say on this sub without getting banned
Because the courts won’t serve justice
My stomach does massive flip flops reading stuff like this. I was a juror before and a fella raped a child and blamed cocaine. Having done it quite a bit myself, I can safely and confidently say it didn’t turn me into a disgusting Paedo!!
Death penalty
I’m against the D penalty in general but this particular type of crime combined with validated photographic evidence, makes me seriously wish we had it.
“defilement of a child”
Nice way to say “**Raped a fucking Baby**” And he’s raped a number of other children too!
“Marshall had denied in interviews with gardaí that he had a sexual predilection for children” so that’s why he likes to watch child porn and rape little children?
“and he is deeply ashamed of his behaviour” so much so that he’s posted numerous videos of him fucking kids?
TLDR for anyone who doesn’t want to read the entire article:
He’s plead guilty to owning child-porn, posting child-porn, filming child-porn and raping a baby. He claims not to have a sexual preference for children. And he has also uploaded **fifteen other videos** of him raping a number of different children. He is getting better treatment for “co-operating” with the Gardaí, despite refusing to identify an accomplice. He also blamed his behaviour on cocaine.
Imagine leaving your child with that scaldie looking toe rag.
[removed]
I’ve said this before, if you put 100 Irish people in a room of different backgrounds, I absolutely gurantee you 97 of the 100 would agree this sentence is scandalously lenient. This isn’t democracy and the judge is as much a danger to Irish society as the rapist
Suggest people write to their local TD, DPP and Minister for Justice. We can all moan on reddit but politicians need to feel the heat too.
Make it so the DPP just has to appeal.
Horrifying.
People should be out in the streets over this. What in the actual fuck.
Tbf, he only had 133 convictions, nobody could have seen this coming.
41 comments
Videod and shared it with others too !! Fuckin hell what a sick cunt but he gets credit for pleading guilty early.
That footage is out there forever absolutely disgusting
One sick individual, delighted he got caught, but repulsed at how short the sentence is. [https://www.independent.ie/irish-news/courts/man-who-filmed-himself-sexually-abusing-infant-boy-and-shared-footage-on-social-media-jailed-for-four-years/a594788962.html](https://www.independent.ie/irish-news/courts/man-who-filmed-himself-sexually-abusing-infant-boy-and-shared-footage-on-social-media-jailed-for-four-years/a594788962.html) picture of the scum bag
WTF is wrong with the judicial system? How can this sentence be justified?
This guy should never be free again
Should be a minimum sentence per image/video found, multiplied by the number of people they can prove it was shared with. No remission or sentence reduction. Should easily add up to a full life sentence for these predators.
133 previous convictions to boot. Burglary, violent disorder . On his previous alone he should be gone forever. On this case alone, he should be put down . That poor boy .
This fucking country.
At least it’s not Judge Nolan but that’s still an astonishingly lenient sentence
Edit: [He doesn’t seem the remorseful type](https://www.limerickleader.ie/resizer/640/-1/true/2024_04_12/8277035-1712921036817_1712921065.jpg–man_who_defiled_baby_called__dirty__ugly__horrible__smelly_scumbag__by_boy_s_mum_in_court.jpg?1712921065793)
What was the name of that party advocating forcible castration for convicted sex offenders again?
Four years for one of the most depraved, inhuman acts you can possibly commit.
I’m so fucking sick of this country. It’s criminal paradise.
Same guy who had [54 previous convictions](https://www.limerickleader.ie/news/local-news/88549/Man-gets-10-year-road-ban.html) a decade ago and who [only just got out of prison for his last sentence for burglary](https://www.irishtimes.com/news/crime-and-law/courts/circuit-court/dangerous-driver-addicted-to-fast-cars-gets-four-year-sentence-1.3070049).
I’ll wait for the regular bleeding hearts to pop in and explain how this will be the sentence that rehabilitates him once and for all.
‘’was facing a maximum life sentence for the defilement charge, a maximum sentence of five years for the possession charge, and up to 14 years on each of the other three charges.’’
The guy also had 133 previous convictions!
But only got 4 years ?? He probably be out in 2 years, what a joke of a system!
What the fuck. 4 years. I hope he is eaten alive in prison and it’s 4 years of hell for that vile piece of shit
He should be castrated then sentenced to life.
Children and victims of abuse don’t matter to this country
Absolute NONCE he’ll be torn apart in prison. Rightly so
Fucking hell, just throw the cunt into a volcano.
The state can challenge this sentence, can’t it? Constant, predictable leniency in these cases will have our country seen as a pariah at this rate. All the hand-wringing over the years about protecting the unborn and the very young, and we really can’t shove all this disgrace on the Catholic Church any more. 35-year old coke twats without a single redeeming characteristic are all our own work. (What’s also grim about this is the way it makes quite pacifist types like moi want to hear of condign justice meted out in prison, as though these men’s moral gangrene has infected *us* too)
How anyone with a record like his can be swanning about free to just carry on offending is incredible. Maybe those expert sniffer pooches/ hash puppies the Gardai use for their daily drug busts could be retrained to bite the ankles of egregious scrotes.
[He signed a bond agreeing to keep the peace and not reoffend for a period of two years after his release.]
Oh, that’s OK then.
Free to reoffend, but not for 2 whole years.
Such lenient sentencing – the only positive to take from this is that Martin Nolan wasn’t the presiding judge
If it was Nolan he probably would have said “Ah no, your a good lad don’t let it happen again off you go”
How does the money thing work? He offers 3,000€ is that not sort of a bribe? Like the more money you offer the less your sentence? I don’t really understand this
No matter how good your local TD is, remember these cases come election time.
I don’t usually get riled up about the short sentences stuff, but what the absolute fuck is this? The title leaves out that he filmed and shared the abuse…so abusing a small child, creating and distributing CP…4 years.
I understand you need to incentivise criminals to co-operate with Gardaí and the courts, so you might knock a few years off for that, but I would have thought it’d be more like getting 12-15 years instead of 20, not FOUR. This is one of the worst things a human can do….yet he’ll be out and about before 2028 probably
Same guy….
‘Fast cars are my heroin’: Man pleads guilty to reckless endangerment
https://www.irishtimes.com/news/crime-and-law/fast-cars-are-my-heroin-man-pleads-guilty-to-reckless-endangerment-1.3063284
Dangerous driver ‘addicted to fast cars’ gets four year sentence
https://www.irishtimes.com/news/crime-and-law/courts/circuit-court/dangerous-driver-addicted-to-fast-cars-gets-four-year-sentence-1.3070049
19-year-old critical after car crashes into wall
https://www.irishtimes.com/news/19-year-old-critical-after-car-crashes-into-wall-1.932880
Four years? Is that how life sentences are spelled these days?
What a sick joke.
What a rotten scumbag piece of shit. Four years??? That poor defenceless infant didn’t get enough justice.
Lads this country is broken beyond repair until someone comes in and actually knows how to run a country and fix the systems, processes and Governance structures. In this case tackle these rogue judges.
Young people dying after being dismissed in A&E, predators walking the streets with impunity, badly needed housing being objected to all over the place.
No one will tell me otherwise.
We are not a mature serious country. We may have money in our pockets and an abundance of job opportunities but that is not everything. I don’t think that will last for ever and we will need to have our shit sorted out when we reach that point.
I’m glad the judge was able to remove his anonymity while keeping the child from being named.
But I’m horrified the judge gave him such a short sentence. How us four years acceptable for sexually abusing a child and filming it to share with others.
> Marshall filmed himself abusing the boy and uploaded the material to social media platform Kik, which alerted the US-based National Centre for Missing and Exploited Children, which in turn contacted gardaí.
I’m glad somebody is monitoring these places and taking action.
Four fucking years !!!!!!!!! No, we’re not having that.
Immediately getting on to TDs.
If you guys offer me a free holiday, nothing fancy, I’ll make sure he never does this again, permanently
New rule –
If you catch someone like this, do thing you can’t say on this sub without getting banned
Because the courts won’t serve justice
My stomach does massive flip flops reading stuff like this. I was a juror before and a fella raped a child and blamed cocaine. Having done it quite a bit myself, I can safely and confidently say it didn’t turn me into a disgusting Paedo!!
Death penalty
I’m against the D penalty in general but this particular type of crime combined with validated photographic evidence, makes me seriously wish we had it.
“defilement of a child”
Nice way to say “**Raped a fucking Baby**” And he’s raped a number of other children too!
“Marshall had denied in interviews with gardaí that he had a sexual predilection for children” so that’s why he likes to watch child porn and rape little children?
“and he is deeply ashamed of his behaviour” so much so that he’s posted numerous videos of him fucking kids?
TLDR for anyone who doesn’t want to read the entire article:
He’s plead guilty to owning child-porn, posting child-porn, filming child-porn and raping a baby. He claims not to have a sexual preference for children. And he has also uploaded **fifteen other videos** of him raping a number of different children. He is getting better treatment for “co-operating” with the Gardaí, despite refusing to identify an accomplice. He also blamed his behaviour on cocaine.
Imagine leaving your child with that scaldie looking toe rag.
[removed]
I’ve said this before, if you put 100 Irish people in a room of different backgrounds, I absolutely gurantee you 97 of the 100 would agree this sentence is scandalously lenient. This isn’t democracy and the judge is as much a danger to Irish society as the rapist
Suggest people write to their local TD, DPP and Minister for Justice. We can all moan on reddit but politicians need to feel the heat too.
Make it so the DPP just has to appeal.
Horrifying.
People should be out in the streets over this. What in the actual fuck.
Tbf, he only had 133 convictions, nobody could have seen this coming.