(Bild) Bayern’s sale list: Gnabry, Coman, Kimmich, Goretzka, Upamecano, Davies and Mazraoui. As soon as the new coach is in place, Bayern want to work intensively on the squad for the new season. If the club wants a breath of fresh air through new additions, players must also be sold urgently
by pewpewlasersandshit
44 comments
This list and the one from last week with our transfer targets (Simons, Onana, etc) is absolutely on point so far (I‘d keep Kimmich though). Don’t want to get my hopes up too much but this offseason could end up being great
No objections except Kimmich. To sell Kimmich I have to be convinced with new players that are or fit actually better.
Why Kimmich? I understand if he want to leave or not re-sign but why give up a versatile player?
Kimmich is probably the least appreciated player of the last 2 decades. Yes his form wasnt good the last 2 seasons but to make him responsible for everything thay is wrong with the squad is such a Tuchel thing to do.
Who knows how real this Bild-report is anyways. I just cant see Eberl selling a worldclass player just because Tuchel didnt like him.
Selling Kimmich would be a HUGE mistake. Not gonna happen.
Gnabry, Coman and Sané should go. Wages too high, not consisten enough and too often injured.
I call bullshit on selling Kimmich and Maz. This is defitnetly Bild making shit up.
Half of this list won’t be sold just because their ability doesn’t match their wages demands.
Selling Kimmich would be insane, I’m torn on Maz, everything else is perfectly fine.
We need fresh air and i hope Eberl can pull some strings, Theo, Onana and Xavi would be incredible. Maybe a young playmaking CB, preferably left footed and we’re good to go.
Of course I still hope we’ll sign Gruda but i doubt it’ll happen.
I was never fully on board with the idea of selling Kimmich but now I’m really against it.
For me, his attitude was his biggest detractor but in the last few months he looks to be a changed man. Performing well at right back, he is also an exceptional midfielder (in the right set up) – I get the idea of cashing in while you can but I think there are often factors that outweigh the financial upsides. Outside of Neuer and Muller, I couldn’t tell you who the most senior player in the squad is if Kimmich gets sold. With both of them rapidly approaching retirement, keeping Kimmich is now more important than ever.
No Kimmich pls. 😔
Damn. Cleaning house
Kimmich one of the best RB as long as he is ok with that position we have to keep him.
Is this Bild saying this or people in management? Because we seem to be in agreement with this news, which hopefully means we’re agreeing with the club and not with Bild. Does management know we need to sell these guys?
Yeah I dont agree with selling Kimmich at all.
Kimmich and Maz need to stay
All the players listed are very good and should not be sold. I believe next year, under the right coach, Upamecano can have a career year
Selling Kimmich and mazraoui is a foolish move, in my eyes at least. Personally, I still like Coman, I just wish he’d stay in shape.
Classic bild article all just made up for clicks
Why do I have a feeling that if Flick rumors to Barca are true, he’ll definitely try to poach Kimmich.
I spent more than half of the season hating Mazraoui but the improvement he showed for the last third was noticeable enough to make me reconsider.
Also, please don’t sell Kimmich, he’s Bayern DNA (figuratively).
Keep Mazraoui and Kimmich. Mazroui is 26, why sell him now??
Everyone else in the list, out. I would rather include Coman than sane, but considering Coman is injury prone, it’s best to sell both.
This Board is certified INSANE. Selling Kimmich, Goretzka and Davies is fucking crazy, same is True for Gnabry and Coman, sure they are Injurie prone but always perform immediately after coming back.
Who are the supposed replacements that have better statistics, are available and want to come to Bayern?
We still reached the CL Semifinal and beat Arsenal on our way there. With less injuries and more luck we would have had a very good chance to beat Madrid.
The other Big Clubs are just waiting for Opportunities like Kimmich.
Insane and unbelievable.
Imagine having fullbacks
If they sell kimmich im gonna personally slap everyone in office in the face
si multi altii, pai de aia nu a venit niciun antrenor, de ce ar accepta sa se compromita, pai tu ditai Eberl venit cu surle si trambite nu esti in stare sa gassati un antrenor decent, nu esti in stare sa-l convingi pe Davies sa-si prelungeasca contractul, pai de ce ai mai venit, pentru mine e clara treaba, astia vor sa vanda toti jucatorii cu contracte mari pentru ca au ajuns la fundul sacului si se pare ca e din ce in ce mai greu sa pastram jucatorii de valoare. Urmeaza Musiala ca i se termina si lui contractul si o sa vrea bani mai multi pe care la Bayern sigur nu-i va obtine.
Been downvoted for weeks for saying the squad is a mess and needs a large scale overhaul…
The roster needs, at the very minimum:
2 good, class wingbacks. Davies (im on record saying Bayern should jump on any offer of 60m+ and never look back, back when Bayern won the CL) isnt it and Mazraoui is also not good enough. Probably need a backup option as well, unless youre planning with Boey/Stanisic.
Good CDMs, at least one who is defensively sound and one who brings creativity.
Wingers!
Backup striker.
GK who can be built up as future nr 1.
Also id add a young CB (eg Ouedraogo) for the future.
Selling Kimmich would be a mistake
Shouldn’t they wait for the new coach to decide? Maybe he wants those players
I’d like to see Upa grow under a manager who’s been a successful defender himself. I just can’t bring myself to give up on him just yet…
I’d rather sell Boey than Maz. I don’t even know what the board saw in Boey in the first place, Maz has been pretty consistent with us, he should be starting RB.
These old guard players need to be told, “either get on board or GTFO, no more player revolt”
This is the coach and if they have a problem with it or his tactics, get to stepping sooner than later.
Insane so many people wanna keep Coman, but sell Upa, Maz, and Goretzka😂. Just a case of grass is always greener. New players can come, but people will start trashing them real quick.
Gnabry, Coman, Davies, and Maz I can see, though I kinda wanna keep Maz. Selling Kimmich, Goretzka, and Upa is dumb asf. Kimmich has really started to grow back into that great RB we knew. Goretzka has had some meh and bad performances, but good overall. Same with Upa, plus Upa is by far our best ball playing CB and still in the youngish side as far as CBs go. Couple bad games, but good overall, especially since he got rushed back from injury and run into the ground first half of the season
Man I understand why but seeing Upa here breaks my heart. I think he does need a fresh start somewhere with a blank slate because imo he’s a top CB. If he didn’t have those little lapses he would be an ideal player for us. He’s so strong, fast, wins 1v1 duels well, last ditch tackles, great in the air, good distribution…
Kimmich being sold I just don’t believe. I don’t believe that we’re looking to sell him at all. He’s a better CM than every one we have and he’s done great at RB. Unless we buy a star CM / fullback I don’t see it happening. I still don’t even seeing it happen if we do buy even both of those positions. Just seems like BS.
I’m glad everyone else agrees selling Kimmich is a boneheaded decision
Nobody wants to sell kimmich no more 😂. I’ve been saying to put him back on Lahm’s throne, like he was born to be, since winning the last champions league in 2020. Why would anyone think it’s a good idea to change positions of a guy who JUST won Europe’s defender of the year??
If keep Upamecano (due to his young age) and Davies (due to his immense potential). The others I’m not even slightly sad about seeing them leave.
I‘d say keep Mazraoui as a contender for Leftback, Kimmich should also stay as he‘s our best rightback, can play the 8 and works as a leader. The others should be replaced
It’s a good sign that we are at least willing to clean house if need be and nobody is untouchable. Underachieving players have been a massive problem for the last couple of years. Although some players on the list I wouldn’t want to be sold.
Even on football manager I don’t make choices as dumb as this. Let’s go through this –
Gnabry – reasonable to sell (sadly)
Coman – reasonable to sell (sadly, but injury prone)
Kimmich – no way sell. Elite footballer. German. Vital to the core team and leadership
Upa- sell (not a big game player, mistake prone)
Goretzka- sell (sadly, but we need something else in his position)
Davies – sell or make him sign new deal this summer
Maz- sell only if Davies stays
Come on we need some good wingers since it’s our identity, Maz and Kimmich are out of question since they can play in several positions. Also we need a lot of work on talents’ subject with loan moves, we don’t want to lose another Kenan.
Kimmich should stay but yeah the rest can definitely go. Sometimes change is needed and these players have been mediocre for way too long.
if they sell kimmich we should genuinely riot…he is by far my favourite player on the current team
Hell no, keep Kimmich, Mazraoui, and Coman.
I’m ok with all of this. I hear you all about kimmich, and agree he’s the best player on this list but also think there’s legit reasons to sell him. Let’s try to actually have the discussion:
He seems to be shall we say opinionated? – he butted heads hard with Tuchel and only once Tuchel was out on his feet did we see Kimmich get sent to RB which makes me think doing so would’ve been too disruptive until TT just didn’t care anymore. I get he has a great mentality but he also has some rough edges that cause problems. I remember nagelsman was afraid to rest him for fear of how disruptive he would be in the locker room if he did so.
His value will only decline as he gets older, and after the last 2 seasons I’m sure it already has just a little.
He hasn’t played to his own standards in a while. I personally think he’s got another great season or two to show us but you can’t blame someone for thinking “look he’s not improving and actually slid back a tiny bit from 27-29 years old which is supposed to be a midfielders absolute prime. He’s a very good player, but it doesn’t look like he’s going to be that ‘arguably best CM in the world’ that he was a few years ago again.”
His game is not irreplaceable. Again, he’s very good. He’s just not irreplaceable. Liamer replaced him at CM and in those last 4-5 games especially in the champs he was terrific. Mazraoi or someone new could potentially do the same at RB. No one is saying this guy sucks let’s chuck him. I’m just saying there are a suitable replacements to be found.