Day #1 Who’s the best City GK of all time

by mrchicken345

37 comments

  2. Hart. But Eddie is very 2nd close.

    Edit. In my opinion obviously. I can see why people would pick Eddie with the treb.

  3. Bert Trautmann. Played on with a broken neck in the cup final.

  5. Joe Hart was a better shot stopper than Ederson. However if we factor in EVERYTHING then obviously Ederson wins.

  6. Joe Hart currently holds the joint record for most golden gloves at 4, so I think it has to be him.

  13. Has to Bert Trautman

    500+ appearances

    Broke his neck in FA Cup final

  17. Bert Trautmann. He did so much for the club, modern goalkeeping, influential to Gordan Banks.

    Over 500 appearances, OBE, played with a broken neck.

    Prisoner of war, to club legend.

    There is literally no question of this outcome.

    And my Dad was the first person to shake his hand at his testimonial match after the whistle.

  19. I’m the biggest Ederson Defender yes he might not be the greatest shot stopper in the world but god is he good on the ball and sweeping. I love Ederson and he really set the benchmark for how good GK have to be with the ball at their feet.

  21. Can we all agree to stop supporting a Nazi as the clubs best keeper of all time?

  22. Bert Trautmann, but honourable mention to Frank Swift who also played for England and died in the Munich Air Disaster as he was covering the match as a journalist for the News of the World.

  26. This is the second one of these where 12 positions are listed

  32. Trautmann was the best goalkeeper *for* city.

    The best goalkeeper to ever play for city would be schmiechel or hart.

    Ederson close 2nd behind Joe

  33. Nicky Weaver. For real though I am a huge fan of Joe Hart

  35. Ederson. Trautmann is a legend but he didn’t win 6 Premier Leagues, 2 FA Cups, 4 League Cups, and a CL.

  37. Bert Trautmann is the answer.
    Then probably Corrigan, Ederson and Hart.
    I once met Joe Corrigan at my local pub and he’s about 6’6” and I’m 5’5”
    I said ‘Hey Big Joe can I get a picture?’
    ‘Sure!’ He said ‘Can you stand up?’
    I was standing… the picture was awesome!

Leave a Reply