Ukraine and Russia draw up neutrality plan to end war: Fifteen-point draft deal would involve Kyiv renouncing Nato ambitions in return for security guarantees

23 comments

  1. Ukraine and Russia have made significant progress on a tentative 15-point peace plan including a ceasefire and Russian withdrawal if Kyiv declares neutrality and accepts limits on its armed forces, according to three people involved in the talks.

    The proposed deal, which Ukrainian and Russian negotiators discussed in full for the first time on Monday, would involve Kyiv renouncing its ambitions to join Nato and promising not to host foreign military bases or weaponry in exchange for protection from allies such as the US, UK and Turkey, the people said.

    The nature of western guarantees for Ukrainian security — and their acceptability to Moscow — could yet prove to be a big obstacle to any deal, as could the status of Ukrainian territories seized by Russia and its proxies in 2014. A 1994 agreement underpinning Ukrainian security failed to prevent Russian aggression against its neighbour.

    Although Moscow and Kyiv both said on Wednesday that they had made progress on the terms of a deal, Ukrainian officials remain sceptical Russian President Vladimir Putin is fully committed to peace and worry that Moscow could be buying time to regroup its forces and resume its offensive.

    Mykhailo Podolyak, a senior adviser to Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky, told the Financial Times that any deal would involve “the troops of the Russian Federation in any case leaving the territory of Ukraine” captured since the invasion began on February 24 — namely southern regions along the Azov and Black Seas, as well as territory to the east and north of Kyiv.

    Ukraine would maintain its armed forces but would be obliged to stay outside military alliances such as Nato and refrain from hosting foreign military bases on its territory.

    Putin’s press secretary Dmitry Peskov told reporters on Wednesday that neutrality for Ukraine based on the status of Austria or Sweden was a possibility.

    “This option is really being discussed now, and is one that can be considered neutral,” said Peskov.

    Sergei Lavrov, Russia’s foreign minister, said that “absolutely specific wordings” were “close to being agreed” in the negotiations.

    Despite the progress in peace talks, Ukrainian cities came under heavy shelling for a third consecutive night while Kyiv said it was launching a counter-offensive against Russian invaders.

    In a virtual address to members of Congress on Wednesday, Zelensky pleaded for the US to enforce a no-fly zone or provide fighter jets or other means to fend off Russia’s attack on his country, and impose harsher economic sanctions on Moscow.

    In a dramatic appeal, Zelensky said Ukraine needed America’s support after Russia had launched a “brutal offensive against our values”. He called on Americans to remember the attacks on Pearl Harbor and of September 2001 and showed a searing video of the missile attacks and shelling destroying Ukrainian cities.

    Though Ukraine’s constitution commits it to seeking membership of Nato, Zelensky and his aides have increasingly played down Ukraine’s chances of joining the transatlantic military alliance, a prospect that Russia sees as a provocation.

    “There is no effective system of European security now, which would be moderated by Nato. As soon as a serious war began in Europe, Nato quickly stepped aside,” Podolyak said.

    “We propose a ‘Ukrainian model of security guarantees,’ which implies the immediate and legally verified participation of a number of guarantor countries in the conflict on the side of Ukraine, if someone again encroaches on its territorial integrity,” he added.

    Ukraine, Podolyak added, would as part of any deal “definitely retain its own army”. He also played down the significance of a ban on foreign bases in Ukraine, saying that was already precluded by Ukrainian law.

    Two of the people said the putative deal also included provisions on enshrining rights for the Russian language in Ukraine, where it is widely spoken though Ukrainian is the only official language. Russia has framed its invasion as an attempt to protect Russian speakers in Ukraine from what it claims is “genocide” by “neo-Nazis”.

    Podolyak said “humanitarian issues, including language issues, are discussed only through the prism of Ukraine’s exclusive interests”.

    The biggest sticking point remains Russia’s demand that Ukraine recognise its 2014 annexation of Crimea and the independence of two separatist statelets in the eastern Donbas border region.

    Ukraine has so far refused but is willing to compartmentalise the issue, Podolyak said.

    “Disputed and conflict territories [are] in a separate case. So far, we are talking about a guaranteed withdrawal from the territories that have been occupied since the start of the military operation on February 24,” when Russia’s invasion began, he said.

  2. I’d make this deal without Crimea&Donbass recognition. Hand them back to Ukraine, Ukraine remains neutral. That’s a proper deal imo

  4. Ukraine should take the deal. Gaining Neutrality is a great outcome to profit of all sides investments.

    Don’t fight for Donbas or Crimea, the people are Russians and the region has been developed by Russia, but bombed by Ukraine.

    Please take the deal and end the war.

  5. Take the deal then join NATO anyway. What’s Russia gonna do, go after all of NATO? It’s not like Russia can claim unfairness with their long history of lies

  7. idk about that, we need protection against Russia ASAP.

    This war has proved that Russia can never be trusted. & it is also shown to us that Russia is a threat. & if we are not prepared Russia will attack us again.

  9. Step 1: Renounce NATO ambitions

    Step 2: Join EU

    Step 3: Remind Putin that Art 42 (7) TEU establishes defensive pact among member states, which includes many NATO members

    Step 4: Profit

  11. This will probably get buried but one of the lead negotiators from the Ukrainian side just tweeted out confirming that this article is an accurate summary of the Russian position in negotiations and does not contain or represent the Ukrainian position.

    If that is true, that is fucking crazy. Russia is scared and desperate and fucked. No way they would be offering something like this if they had any hope at all of making further military gains in Ukraine or any way of countering western sanctions.

    This is essentially Russia offering to surrender and go back to how it was before and Ukraine saying no, you will surrender and pay us back for all the hell you have caused.

    Edit: Link to tweet in question: https://twitter.com/Podolyak_M/status/1504136862277017607?cxt=HHwWjoC9mbmg4t8pAAAA

  14. Riiiiiiight. Security guarantee like the Budapest Memorandum?

    That worked out well. /s

    The Russian government is not to be trusted.

  15. Haven’t they already had a security guarantee for giving up their nuclear weapons back in 1994?

  16. The only thing Russia reassured everyone (that hadn’t known it already) is that they lie, deceive, ignore promises and deny anything they want. Fuck their promises. Fuck them

  17. How can Ukrainian just go to peace where their loved ones got murdered by Putin… there will be hate and bitterness for a while in their heart.

  22. Kiev confirmed that their goals do not align with the draft in ft.com

    Why would anyone trust Russia at this point?

  23. Ukraine won’t join NATO but will definitely get in the EU eventually, before Europeans could be reluctant but now the opinion of its entrance has changed dramatically, so after the war and the sanctions, Russia won’t step in Ukraine ever again. Putin’s plan really backfired.

Leave a Reply