Trump and MAGA crowd overestimate the power of tariffs. Apart from Canada & Mexico, nobody depends much on exports to the US. The US exports to GDP ratio is 6% for Korea, 3.8% for Germany, 2.8% for China, and 2.1% for India

13 comments

1. Doing a quick search, other sources put Chinese exports to the US much higher.

2. No we know that’s the point

3. [deleted]

4. While that’s true, the percentage of Canadian exports going to the US is substantially higher

   > In 2024, the United States was the destination for 75.9% of Canada’s total exports

   https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/n1/daily-quotidien/250205/dq250205a-eng.htm

   This figure includes services as well, which wouldn’t be captured under the proposed tariffs. But Canada’s highly concentrated export market means that US tariffs would have a huge impact.

5. The question may not be for regular trade of products but rather aid and products sales of luxury items that the elites in these other countries rely on. Most of these countries could care less about their population, especially the Eastern ones with a population that out ranks their country’s area but they do care about military aid, guns, certain brands found in the states and luxury items. 🤷‍♀️

6. 2023?

7. Which shows why Trump chose to pick on Mexico and Canada.

8. US is just one of their many customers. They’re building for BRICS now, which represents the global majority.

9. Ireland is not in the G20 but it’s another country alongside Mexico and Canada with a high reliance on US exports. Being over 10% of GDP.

10. this is silly – As US is the highest deficit country its role in international trade is of utmost importance. You can’t have a transaction with Only sellers. As US is the largest buyer all countries depend on US. Also comparing export to GDP is silly. The important factor would be to compare US as a portion of that countries exports.

11. Knowledge is power and clearly someone out there has overestimated their power. 

    

    

12. This could also be interpreted as liberals overestimating the impact of tariffs on their daily lives😂

13. I keep seeing posts claiming that Trump’s tariffs won’t have much impact because most countries don’t rely heavily on U.S. exports relative to their GDP. People love to cite numbers like **China’s exports to the U.S. being only 2.85% of its GDP** to argue that tariffs are pointless. But that’s a huge misunderstanding of how tariffs work.

    # This Is a Cherry-Picked Stat

    This is one of those classic **“percent vs. absolute number” tricks** people use when it fits their agenda. When they want something to seem small, In this case, 2.85% sounds tiny, but in reality, **China exported $427 billion worth of goods to the U.S. in 2023**. Even a **10% tariff** would cost China **$42.7 billion**, and a **25% tariff would be over $100 billion** in lost revenue. That’s not small no matter how you try to frame it.

    It’s like saying, *“Losing 3% of your income isn’t a big deal,”* but that depends on the actual amount. If you make **$1 million a year**, 3% is **$30,000**—which is still a huge hit. The same applies to trade. **China losing even 2.85% of its GDP in exports to the U.S. is worth hundreds of billions of dollars.** The mistake people make is **framing it as a percentage to make it seem small**, when in reality, the **total dollar loss is massive**.

    # Absolute Export Value Matters More Than % of GDP

    Even though exports to the U.S. might be a small percentage of GDP, the total dollar amount is massive. **China exported $427 billion** to the U.S., **Germany $146.6 billion, South Korea $116.2 billion, and India $83.7 billion**. A **10% tariff** on just these four countries alone would generate **$77.35 billion** in additional U.S. revenue. If tariffs go up to **25%**, that’s nearly **$200 billion in tariff revenue** from these four alone. That’s not small.

    # Tariffs Hurt Specific Industries, Not Just GDP

    A country’s entire GDP might not depend on U.S. exports, but certain **industries absolutely do**. China’s manufacturing & tech sector (phones, semiconductors, machinery) is highly reliant on the U.S. market. Germany’s auto industry (BMW, Mercedes, Volkswagen) makes billions off of American consumers. South Korea’s electronics & auto exports (Samsung, Hyundai, Kia) would suffer. India’s pharmaceuticals & IT services depend on U.S. demand. When tariffs increase, these industries take a hit—leading to job losses, factory shutdowns, and supply chain disruptions. That’s why China, Germany, and others hate tariffs.

    # Tariffs Force Supply Chain Shifts

    People forget that tariffs force companies to move production elsewhere. U.S. companies already **shifted manufacturing from China to Vietnam, India, and Mexico** because of tariffs. Once businesses relocate, **they rarely return**, making this a long-term loss for China. Germany, South Korea, and Japan face **competition from U.S. domestic production** as tariffs make imports less competitive.

    # Tariffs Create Leverage in Trade Deals

    Trump’s 2018-2019 tariffs **forced China into the Phase 1 trade deal** to increase U.S. imports. Countries that rely on U.S. exports can’t just ignore tariffs. The **U.S. is the largest single consumer market**—no country wants to lose access.

Comments are closed.