To be very polite… arrogant fools raised in ivory towers of privilege.
Communism sounds fine on paper, but implementing it in practice runs counter to human nature and attempting to force it onto a population has always resulted in bloodbaths.
“Why not communism” is the modern version of “let them eat cake”.
Dumb and ignorant people exist, no reason to lose sleep over it.
communist is virtue signaling
its always nice to share whats not yours
but this people wont shelter a homeless to save their lifes lmao
Like, idea of communism is kinda nice (or at least part of it), but the implementation had never been good for the people. I have an ambivalent attitude.
This hysteria is cheap and poorly argued.
I used to think that there is no reason to argue with stupidity. You go down to their level and still won’t change their point of view.
But then I realized that we must respond to that. Imagine if all those posts will remain unanswered? Young developing minds will think this is the only opinion.
So, thank you for doing your part!
Of course it’s American college kids who haven’t faced turmoil like that in generations, so there is no one around to explain how their views are luxury beliefs.
If America wouldn’t be the most influential country in the world, it would be funny to see another iteration of “that wasn’t real communism”, but ofc even then no lesson will be learned
They remind me of Lenin and his idea of “useful idiot”
That you’re naive and dangerous, with communism comes authoritarianism (read Animal Farm) basically there will always be a ruling class and to expect them to be equal to the working man is so naive.
Also it killed tens of millions of people, read about the great famine in Ukraine, horrible things and yet somehow you think it will be different. Well, look at Venezuela and how it worked out.
If you think it’s good, but don’t understand the people that broke out of it saying it’s horrible, you’re dangerous because reason doesn’t speak to you
Ignorants.
Saying that, please don’t mix social democratic systems with communism, some Americans do that, and it’s almost as stupid as claiming that communism worked.
Well, Soviets called them “shit-eaters”. They were not wrong lol
Send them to the gulag.
They are just stupid.
Communism was an utopia and while believing it 107 years ago was understandable – believing it after all their crimes and genocides is just mental ilness.
Communism was the worst thing that came to my country after 1945 so everybody who supports this ideology doesn’t understand how shitty life is under supporters of this ideology.
My Polish friend sent me an ACP meeting recording and said “lmao such idiots”
Tankies bad, everyone else is fine
Communism is an utopia. It goes against human nature. So people who believe it’s possible are very naive. Especially knowing a lot of real life attempts to build communism and where that led – repressions, genocides, totalitarianism, even bigger inequality, equality in misery, denying of freedoms and rights.
But I see where it might come from, especially for people living in countries such as USA where capitalism goes too far. In my opinion, the best model that we have at this moment is a mix of democracy, capitalism and socialism in Scandinavian countries.
Nothing good. The only thing I feel towards them is utter contempt.
Especially Americans. They see billionaires and corporations running amok in their country and seem to think the cure to it all is introducing the famously murderous and destructive political system.
What gets me is that they either don’t acknowledge its’ propensity towards mass murder and general failure, handwaving it away as the “CIA propaganda” or just plainly not caring. When you tell them how many ppl communism has killed, they always sneer “and capitalism doesn’t kill people?”.
They seem to think that communism only kills the rich or the nazis.
Thing is that most young people never had chance to see communism ( or whatever it was ) In my family in every generation I have had someone in prison or arretbevause we opposed it..I just look to this young supporters of communism especially lovers of murderer Che as potential dangerous idiots…I could imagine that they want to be cool had some info about Marx …and are looking for some nish …hope they will grow out of this ..
But they are to me irritating..
Most of them do not have normal work or are mentally unstable and thinking that this pose will be cool…they find some Soros organisations that pay them to spread this illusion..I know some people who were westeners ..moved during communism to Poland and soon regret that 🙂 most often if they because they started family in P … ended up being alcoholics and depressed:)
Capitalism ain’t perfect and it did at times kill millions due to prioritising profit over humanity. Irish potato famine springs to mind.
But soviet communism didn’t really get rid of the capitalist foundations nor did it really try to. In the end you still had go to work to make money and spend that money on stuff to live. Except thanks to central planning the quality of it was way worse and so was the availability. Worse quality in some products would lead to deaths, soviet aviation springs to mind. Neither were the working conditions any better, in the west the workers could go on strike to get concessions, while in the east non-state unions weren’t even allowed. Both of the aforementioned issues culminated in Chernobyl which is indefensible.
Supposedly communist China managed to get so far by combining the very worst of soviet totalitarianism with the very worst of the global capitalism creating a scarily efficient system. But it sure as fuck isn’t concerned about giving their citizens the best life possible.
Degenerates, plain and simple.
americans and west are dreaming about communism because they are exhausted of capitalism which have squeezed them like lemons… But communism will also mash those squized lemmons and rest of it throw to eat for pigs or etc. They only thinking about not to be wanted to be squizzed
Room temperature IQ (in celcius)
No point in discussing him.
As our lord and saviour Sci-Fun once said in context of flat earthers – some people just crossed that border when there is no return to sanity and no facts or arguments will convince them. Communists are like flat earthers.
That they don’t know shit about life or history, and are bunch of priviliged fools.
That they’re dumb.
Thank you for coming to my TED Talk.
Anyone who supports communism is entitled moron. There’s no point in discussing it further, topic closed.
It’s mostly just American leftists. Who make a joke out of actual leftists, same with american liberals
Edit: Oh, and yeah, I just noticed the flair and I was right it’s an American… who seemingly also thinks you’re an American
1. Polish people hate communism with a burning passion
2. Those aren’t even communist supporters but liberal rich fucks
Yeah it can only work in Star Trek. Think unlimited* energy, full automation, 3d printers and fabricators.
What I find funny is that even in places where communism was implemented, it basically works the same as most power systems,
you have leader and people working below him, getting more than any other person because they are important politicians
and you have people getting stuff only because of connections…
I heard stories of MANY older people from Poland talking about them getting a good fridge, toys or whatever because their neighbours, siblings, or friends were the ones making those things
Because none of y’all is actually communist, you’re just desperate for an alternative to your oppressive flavor of capitalism and your culture and education accepts only a binary worldview, where subtelty and compromises are vilified.
How’s your communist work going? Do you actively participate in you local community programs? Do you share wealth with the poorest? Do you participate in cooperatively owned enterprises? Do you help your neighbors with their house work or garden work? No. Work at the base is below such an enlightened comrade. You’re here to rule.
You want to build it from the top to bottom, because it not true that you wanna help those less fortunate, you wanna hurt those more fortunate. You’re not a communist, you’re an anticapitalist in a culture which won’t hear you unless your opinion is radical enough.
I’m sure you don’t imagine yourself working exactly the same job as you do right now under communism (which would probably happen), because in a true American fashion, deep down you see it as a ladder to improve your own personal position. Not position of your community.
Communists can go to Cuba, venezuela or north Korea to live their dream.
Everyone who lived under sovietunion rule and is not retarted knows communism didnt work,milions were celebrating its fall and rise of democracy and capitalism in former republics
When Berlin wall has fallen which side the people run to?
Modern China learned their lesson on communism too just read how many people starved to death or died due to repreaions. While China ruling party is still communists by name its not “real communism” they walked back on many ideology Dogmas or they would totally ruin their country
The short version is that so called “tankies” are people from the West who have spent their entire lives in a liberal democracy and therefore cannot even imagine what an authoritarian regime entails, thinking that the lack of personal freedoms in those regimes was just propaganda (because it couldnt possibly be true).
Add to that what I would call “reverse american exceptionalism”: usa = bad, therefore anything that opposes usa must be good. And that’s pretty much the full genesis of a tankie world view
Morons raised in privilege, to put it kindly.
Supporting communism is the same as supporting nazism. Both ideologies are responsible for deaths of millions people around the world (communism has WAY more higher death count). Both ideologies should be permanently wiped out.
I’m old enough to remember some parts of life under communist rule. Anyone who supports it is a fucking idiot.
At best, misinformed.
At worst, idiots.
Praising communism when you didn’t live it to see its flaws is Hella cringe
Praising capitalism when you’re actively living it and seeing its flaws is also cringe
38 comments
To be very polite… arrogant fools raised in ivory towers of privilege.
Communism sounds fine on paper, but implementing it in practice runs counter to human nature and attempting to force it onto a population has always resulted in bloodbaths.
“Why not communism” is the modern version of “let them eat cake”.
Dumb and ignorant people exist, no reason to lose sleep over it.
communist is virtue signaling
its always nice to share whats not yours
but this people wont shelter a homeless to save their lifes lmao
Like, idea of communism is kinda nice (or at least part of it), but the implementation had never been good for the people. I have an ambivalent attitude.
This hysteria is cheap and poorly argued.
I used to think that there is no reason to argue with stupidity. You go down to their level and still won’t change their point of view.
But then I realized that we must respond to that. Imagine if all those posts will remain unanswered? Young developing minds will think this is the only opinion.
So, thank you for doing your part!
Of course it’s American college kids who haven’t faced turmoil like that in generations, so there is no one around to explain how their views are luxury beliefs.
If America wouldn’t be the most influential country in the world, it would be funny to see another iteration of “that wasn’t real communism”, but ofc even then no lesson will be learned
They remind me of Lenin and his idea of “useful idiot”
That you’re naive and dangerous, with communism comes authoritarianism (read Animal Farm) basically there will always be a ruling class and to expect them to be equal to the working man is so naive.
Also it killed tens of millions of people, read about the great famine in Ukraine, horrible things and yet somehow you think it will be different. Well, look at Venezuela and how it worked out.
If you think it’s good, but don’t understand the people that broke out of it saying it’s horrible, you’re dangerous because reason doesn’t speak to you
Ignorants.
Saying that, please don’t mix social democratic systems with communism, some Americans do that, and it’s almost as stupid as claiming that communism worked.
Well, Soviets called them “shit-eaters”. They were not wrong lol
Send them to the gulag.
They are just stupid.
Communism was an utopia and while believing it 107 years ago was understandable – believing it after all their crimes and genocides is just mental ilness.
Communism was the worst thing that came to my country after 1945 so everybody who supports this ideology doesn’t understand how shitty life is under supporters of this ideology.
My Polish friend sent me an ACP meeting recording and said “lmao such idiots”
Tankies bad, everyone else is fine
Communism is an utopia. It goes against human nature. So people who believe it’s possible are very naive. Especially knowing a lot of real life attempts to build communism and where that led – repressions, genocides, totalitarianism, even bigger inequality, equality in misery, denying of freedoms and rights.
But I see where it might come from, especially for people living in countries such as USA where capitalism goes too far. In my opinion, the best model that we have at this moment is a mix of democracy, capitalism and socialism in Scandinavian countries.
Nothing good. The only thing I feel towards them is utter contempt.
Especially Americans. They see billionaires and corporations running amok in their country and seem to think the cure to it all is introducing the famously murderous and destructive political system.
What gets me is that they either don’t acknowledge its’ propensity towards mass murder and general failure, handwaving it away as the “CIA propaganda” or just plainly not caring. When you tell them how many ppl communism has killed, they always sneer “and capitalism doesn’t kill people?”.
They seem to think that communism only kills the rich or the nazis.
Thing is that most young people never had chance to see communism ( or whatever it was ) In my family in every generation I have had someone in prison or arretbevause we opposed it..I just look to this young supporters of communism especially lovers of murderer Che as potential dangerous idiots…I could imagine that they want to be cool had some info about Marx …and are looking for some nish …hope they will grow out of this ..
But they are to me irritating..
Most of them do not have normal work or are mentally unstable and thinking that this pose will be cool…they find some Soros organisations that pay them to spread this illusion..I know some people who were westeners ..moved during communism to Poland and soon regret that 🙂 most often if they because they started family in P … ended up being alcoholics and depressed:)
Capitalism ain’t perfect and it did at times kill millions due to prioritising profit over humanity. Irish potato famine springs to mind.
But soviet communism didn’t really get rid of the capitalist foundations nor did it really try to. In the end you still had go to work to make money and spend that money on stuff to live. Except thanks to central planning the quality of it was way worse and so was the availability. Worse quality in some products would lead to deaths, soviet aviation springs to mind. Neither were the working conditions any better, in the west the workers could go on strike to get concessions, while in the east non-state unions weren’t even allowed. Both of the aforementioned issues culminated in Chernobyl which is indefensible.
Supposedly communist China managed to get so far by combining the very worst of soviet totalitarianism with the very worst of the global capitalism creating a scarily efficient system. But it sure as fuck isn’t concerned about giving their citizens the best life possible.
Degenerates, plain and simple.
americans and west are dreaming about communism because they are exhausted of capitalism which have squeezed them like lemons… But communism will also mash those squized lemmons and rest of it throw to eat for pigs or etc. They only thinking about not to be wanted to be squizzed
Room temperature IQ (in celcius)
No point in discussing him.
As our lord and saviour Sci-Fun once said in context of flat earthers – some people just crossed that border when there is no return to sanity and no facts or arguments will convince them. Communists are like flat earthers.
That they don’t know shit about life or history, and are bunch of priviliged fools.
That they’re dumb.
Thank you for coming to my TED Talk.
Anyone who supports communism is entitled moron. There’s no point in discussing it further, topic closed.
It’s mostly just American leftists. Who make a joke out of actual leftists, same with american liberals
Edit: Oh, and yeah, I just noticed the flair and I was right it’s an American… who seemingly also thinks you’re an American
1. Polish people hate communism with a burning passion
2. Those aren’t even communist supporters but liberal rich fucks
Yeah it can only work in Star Trek. Think unlimited* energy, full automation, 3d printers and fabricators.
What I find funny is that even in places where communism was implemented, it basically works the same as most power systems,
you have leader and people working below him, getting more than any other person because they are important politicians
and you have people getting stuff only because of connections…
I heard stories of MANY older people from Poland talking about them getting a good fridge, toys or whatever because their neighbours, siblings, or friends were the ones making those things
Because none of y’all is actually communist, you’re just desperate for an alternative to your oppressive flavor of capitalism and your culture and education accepts only a binary worldview, where subtelty and compromises are vilified.
How’s your communist work going? Do you actively participate in you local community programs? Do you share wealth with the poorest? Do you participate in cooperatively owned enterprises? Do you help your neighbors with their house work or garden work? No. Work at the base is below such an enlightened comrade. You’re here to rule.
You want to build it from the top to bottom, because it not true that you wanna help those less fortunate, you wanna hurt those more fortunate. You’re not a communist, you’re an anticapitalist in a culture which won’t hear you unless your opinion is radical enough.
I’m sure you don’t imagine yourself working exactly the same job as you do right now under communism (which would probably happen), because in a true American fashion, deep down you see it as a ladder to improve your own personal position. Not position of your community.
Communists can go to Cuba, venezuela or north Korea to live their dream.
Everyone who lived under sovietunion rule and is not retarted knows communism didnt work,milions were celebrating its fall and rise of democracy and capitalism in former republics
When Berlin wall has fallen which side the people run to?
Modern China learned their lesson on communism too just read how many people starved to death or died due to repreaions. While China ruling party is still communists by name its not “real communism” they walked back on many ideology Dogmas or they would totally ruin their country
The short version is that so called “tankies” are people from the West who have spent their entire lives in a liberal democracy and therefore cannot even imagine what an authoritarian regime entails, thinking that the lack of personal freedoms in those regimes was just propaganda (because it couldnt possibly be true).
Add to that what I would call “reverse american exceptionalism”: usa = bad, therefore anything that opposes usa must be good. And that’s pretty much the full genesis of a tankie world view
Morons raised in privilege, to put it kindly.
Supporting communism is the same as supporting nazism. Both ideologies are responsible for deaths of millions people around the world (communism has WAY more higher death count). Both ideologies should be permanently wiped out.
I’m old enough to remember some parts of life under communist rule. Anyone who supports it is a fucking idiot.
At best, misinformed.
At worst, idiots.
Praising communism when you didn’t live it to see its flaws is Hella cringe
Praising capitalism when you’re actively living it and seeing its flaws is also cringe
Comments are closed.