Amazing that the allegations of endangering patients that Dr Upton only “remembered” when they were challenged by Sandor Peggie for being in the women’s changing rooms all turned out to be false.
Would could have guessed?
While there are aspects of her case I sympathise with, Sandie Peggie and her family are racist bigots and their agenda here is clear. I can’t get behind her being touted by some as some women’s rights champion. She is a bigot, regardless of the strengths in her case.
I’m so sick of seeing her, she will inevitably make the grifter move to being GB News’ healthcare correspondent or something.
The tribunal decision really leaves Dr Upton exposed with finding that Nurse Peggie didn’t endanger patients. So that means there’s likely to be a professional misconduct hearing for the false and malicious endangerment complaints.
There’s definitely no doubt something was said between both women, to the point that one has gone ahead and made a malicious complaint that wasn’t upheld, but this now looks to have destroyed the career of Dr Upton and set back the rights and safety of trans people even further.
I think the other consideration here is that HR have let everyone down as well. Because to get to this point, they’ve very clearly fucked up to the point that there was a tribunal and a court case, which is still ongoing in the latter.
So, having had HR experience of over a decade as part of the military, that HR section needs to have their own performance scrutinised to within an inch of their lives, because if they’ve fucked this situation up so badly, who and what else have they seriously fucked over? There are really serious concerns about them too which just aren’t getting covered or scrutinised.
>Sandie Peggie received confirmation from Fife Health Board that, following a disciplinary hearing, none of the gross misconduct allegations against her were upheld.
>“This follows a disciplinary hearing on June 25, which considered four gross misconduct allegations: two relating to patient care failures, one of ‘misgendering’ Dr Upton, and one relating to her encounter with Dr Upton in the workplace female-only changing room on Christmas Eve 2023.
I wonder if the usual suspects will stop claiming the nurse endangered patients now that we know these were lies made up by Dr Upton.
Lies that have cost the taxpayer hundreds of grand.
You can tell how absolutely toxic our society has become by the size of the media circus around what amounts to a fucking work tribunal, everybody involved needs to have a fucking day off man
This is an interesting development.
This nurse seems like a truly unpleasant character.
Will be interesting if she tries to go on using her now enhanced media profile to push her views.
Presumably those, like Safety Hair, who slander her under every post are going to apologise.
It also means NHS Fife will have to settle. It will be very difficult for them to argue that their investigation/disciplinary procedure was legitimate when they couldn’t prove a single allegation.
Now there also will have to be a GMC referral re Dr Upton- a Dr cannot fabricate serious allegations like that about a colleague.
She’ll be retiring off the compensation.
The worst of it is, you can just tell the nurse is a thick, bigoted arsehole with dodgy views.
Should never have got this far, she deserves a grovelling apology and all her back pay if any.
I hate this timeline
Some interesting attempts on here to paint Sandie Peggie as some evil character.
The UK Supreme Court ruling earlier this year is certainly rowing back some of the measures that were previously put in place. It’s certainly helped the nurse.
>NHS Fife and the doctor are defending their actions at a cost to the public purse so far of at least £220,000
That is a shocking amount of money, almost a quarter of a million up in smoke because of a work dispute that never should have happened.
People with penises and testicles should not be getting changed in female dressing room, if they had respected that fact from the start then there would be no trouble.
16 comments
Amazing that the allegations of endangering patients that Dr Upton only “remembered” when they were challenged by Sandor Peggie for being in the women’s changing rooms all turned out to be false.
Would could have guessed?
While there are aspects of her case I sympathise with, Sandie Peggie and her family are racist bigots and their agenda here is clear. I can’t get behind her being touted by some as some women’s rights champion. She is a bigot, regardless of the strengths in her case.
I’m so sick of seeing her, she will inevitably make the grifter move to being GB News’ healthcare correspondent or something.
The tribunal decision really leaves Dr Upton exposed with finding that Nurse Peggie didn’t endanger patients. So that means there’s likely to be a professional misconduct hearing for the false and malicious endangerment complaints.
There’s definitely no doubt something was said between both women, to the point that one has gone ahead and made a malicious complaint that wasn’t upheld, but this now looks to have destroyed the career of Dr Upton and set back the rights and safety of trans people even further.
I think the other consideration here is that HR have let everyone down as well. Because to get to this point, they’ve very clearly fucked up to the point that there was a tribunal and a court case, which is still ongoing in the latter.
So, having had HR experience of over a decade as part of the military, that HR section needs to have their own performance scrutinised to within an inch of their lives, because if they’ve fucked this situation up so badly, who and what else have they seriously fucked over? There are really serious concerns about them too which just aren’t getting covered or scrutinised.
>Sandie Peggie received confirmation from Fife Health Board that, following a disciplinary hearing, none of the gross misconduct allegations against her were upheld.
>“This follows a disciplinary hearing on June 25, which considered four gross misconduct allegations: two relating to patient care failures, one of ‘misgendering’ Dr Upton, and one relating to her encounter with Dr Upton in the workplace female-only changing room on Christmas Eve 2023.
I wonder if the usual suspects will stop claiming the nurse endangered patients now that we know these were lies made up by Dr Upton.
Lies that have cost the taxpayer hundreds of grand.
You can tell how absolutely toxic our society has become by the size of the media circus around what amounts to a fucking work tribunal, everybody involved needs to have a fucking day off man
This is an interesting development.
This nurse seems like a truly unpleasant character.
Will be interesting if she tries to go on using her now enhanced media profile to push her views.
Presumably those, like Safety Hair, who slander her under every post are going to apologise.
It also means NHS Fife will have to settle. It will be very difficult for them to argue that their investigation/disciplinary procedure was legitimate when they couldn’t prove a single allegation.
Now there also will have to be a GMC referral re Dr Upton- a Dr cannot fabricate serious allegations like that about a colleague.
She’ll be retiring off the compensation.
The worst of it is, you can just tell the nurse is a thick, bigoted arsehole with dodgy views.
Should never have got this far, she deserves a grovelling apology and all her back pay if any.
I hate this timeline
Some interesting attempts on here to paint Sandie Peggie as some evil character.
The UK Supreme Court ruling earlier this year is certainly rowing back some of the measures that were previously put in place. It’s certainly helped the nurse.
>NHS Fife and the doctor are defending their actions at a cost to the public purse so far of at least £220,000
That is a shocking amount of money, almost a quarter of a million up in smoke because of a work dispute that never should have happened.
People with penises and testicles should not be getting changed in female dressing room, if they had respected that fact from the start then there would be no trouble.
Comments are closed.