Inside the European Central Bank (ECB), a rare and intense internal conflict has emerged as staff representatives have publicly accused the bank’s leadership of undermining the rule of law. The ECB Staff Committee, led by Carlos Bowles, has expressed concerns that the institution is failing to uphold the legal and democratic principles it publicly champions. These allegations, which include accusations of anti-democratic behavior and a lack of transparency and accountability, have sparked significant controversy and raised questions about the ECB’s governance structure [1].
The criticism centers on President Christine Lagarde, who has previously emphasized the importance of legal accountability and institutional integrity. Bowles, representing staff interests, noted that the principles the ECB leadership espouses externally appear to be undervalued internally by its power structure. Staff have reported “widespread complaints” regarding favoritism in hiring and promotion, further fueling concerns over the fairness and objectivity of decision-making processes within the ECB [2].
This dispute marks one of the few instances in recent history where ECB staff have publicly challenged the institution’s leadership. While the ECB has not issued a formal response to the specific allegations, the controversy reflects broader concerns about the rule of law in public institutions. According to a recent analysis, failing to uphold judicial discipline and legal norms can lead to inconsistent enforcement and a decline in public trust—risks that the ECB, as a key economic authority, must address [3].
Despite the internal tensions, the controversy has not yet translated into noticeable market impacts. Eurozone assets and cryptocurrency markets remain stable, with no immediate policy changes linked to the dispute. The ECB has not announced any alterations to its regulatory or monetary policy framework in response to the staff’s concerns [4].
The ongoing situation highlights the need for increased transparency and institutional accountability within the ECB. While the ECB maintains its independence, as emphasized by Lagarde in a recent blog statement, the allegations suggest a growing disconnect between the institution’s public messaging and internal practices. If left unaddressed, these governance concerns could erode public confidence and complicate the ECB’s role in steering the eurozone’s economic stability.
As the debate continues, the ECB faces mounting pressure to clarify its internal processes and reaffirm its commitment to legal and democratic principles. Any failure to do so may not only affect its institutional credibility but also influence broader perceptions of governance within the European Union.
—
Sources:
[1] Tensions are mounting inside the European Central Bank (url: https://www.instagram.com/p/DMsOINQJjyR/)
[2] The European Central Bank is facing rare internal backlash (url: https://www.instagram.com/p/DMsHSzEg2Vj/)
[3] Staff at the ECB claimed a lack of checks and balances (url: https://www.facebook.com/groups/bruges.group/posts/10163251928244936/)
[4] TMI Tax Updates e-Newsletter Jul 31,2025 (url: https://www.taxtmi.com/newsletter?id=07/31/2025)