Pay Dirt is Slate’s money advice column. Have a question? Send it to Kristin and Ilyce here. (It’s anonymous!)

Dear Pay Dirt,

I just learned that I’m inheriting a significant amount of property from the last person I would have expected this from.

I had a brief marriage to a much older man when I was in my 20s. He basically started cheating on me with his ex as soon as our honeymoon was over. He tried to play off their continued relationship as mere friendship and said I was just paranoid about being forced into continuous close quarters with her. Eventually I walked in on them together. The divorce was quick but very painful and it took me several years to learn how to trust again.

I am now happily married with two beautiful children and I thought this would remain an ugly memory. Only my ex unexpectedly died and bizarrely left me a significant amount of property that has been his family for decades. His parents and brother both are deceased as well.

Frankly, taking the land and selling it makes me feel icky. But my husband thinks it is basically the least of what my first husband owes me after all this time. We could put our kids through college without a care with this money.

I don’t know what could possibly warranted this, except as another mind screw for me and his ex. They had a significant on and off again relationship, including two broken engagements. His ex has reached out saying she wants to “clear the air.” I have zero desire to engage with this woman. I don’t know if she wants an explanation or absolution, but I don’t want to open that door.

What should I do here?

—Blast From the Past

Dear Blast From the Past,

I Worked Hard to Befriend Our New Neighbors. My Trespassing Sister-in-Law Ruined the Relationship in One Afternoon.

Help! My Parents Retired and Became Unrecognizable Divas.


This Content is Available for Slate Plus members only

I Somehow Ended Up in Bed With Two of My Guy Friends. Then Things Took an Unexpected Turn.

Help! I Was Written Up for Violating an Office Rule. The Only Way They Could’ve Known Is a Total Invasion of Privacy.

You said it yourself: You have no desire to open that door. And you don’t have to. You don’t owe your ex’s ex anything. Best case scenario, “clear the air” means she wants to clear her conscience, apologize, and ask you to forgive her. But even if you’ve moved on, her guilt isn’t your responsibility. Maybe I’m being too cynical about this, but the timing is suspicious, and I think a more likely scenario is that she wants to clear the air so she can inquire about that inheritance. It doesn’t sound like you’re interested in that, either.  Trust your instincts and leave it alone.

Your ex left the property to you for a reason. Maybe he felt he owed it to you—who knows? It sounds like you’ve spent enough time trying to figure out that relationship. I get that it might feel weird to accept an inheritance from someone you no longer care about— or worse, someone who really hurt you—and I don’t want to nudge you away from your gut feelings, but guilt is not always a reliable compass. You’ve made your peace with the past. If you feel like keeping this money might disrupt that peace, that might be the only reason to do something else with it. Maybe consider donating even just a small portion of the sale to an organization that’s important to you.

But ultimately, you get to decide what to do with this money. My two cents: Take the money, use it to support your family, and think of this as the final chapter in that story. You’ve earned your peace.

—Kristin

More Money Advice From Slate

My spouse is an amazing, justice-seeking, do-good-in-the world professional who makes a surprisingly decent living considering the good she does. And she is absolutely murder on our finances. So much of my life consists of asking her to put her earnings in our joint account (she has a private practice, so it’s not a direct deposit situation), asking her to do her billing, begging her not to use the credit card we agreed not to use (or at least to tell me if she’s using it), paying parking tickets she’s incurred—the list goes on. All this is part of a broader struggle she has getting certain important things in their life and mine done that has financially torpedoed us at regular intervals. I can’t remember the last time she saw a doctor. Years ago, she forgot to sign up for her free university health insurance, and only realized it after our first baby was on the way. It was a mess.

The latest sex, parenting, and money advice from our columnists delivered to your inbox three times a week.