Absolutely horrible idea. It will institutionalise something that is not only against principles of church state separation but it is also against principles of tax collection. And it happens to coincide with mass exodus of people from Catholic Church, which blatantly revels who will be benefit from it the most.
Small religious movements (like Protestant denominations) will actually be hurt the most with this.
It is the best thing that could happen to Poland. Seriously, and the 2% is just a catch for the main church.
If they reject, it will be obvious they don’t want to be open for financial and statistical information and trying to keep hiding all data staying in the gray zone.
If they accept, it is over. Where less than 50% will pay. And people will understand how much it cost.
Cannot wait! 🤣
Nie podpisze
So can I make up my own religion and church and get someone’s 2%?
Can someone explain to me how this reform accomplishes both:
– saves money in a budget
– increases church income up to 5 times
If people donate 2% of their tax, this money don’t go to the budget as they normally would. If Church ends up with 5 times more money it means that less many went to the budget, right?
How is this neutral? It’s neutral only if the same amount of money is transferred.
The income from PIT is almost 100 billion, if 10% people donates 2% it’s 0,2% ~200 millions so roughly the same it’s now. Help it make sense. Practically if more than 10% of population does it the Church wins, the budget loses. With 50% donating its 5 times more, budget loses 400% more than now.
8 comments
Good, no special status for Churches.
can’t wait to never hear about that again
Absolutely horrible idea. It will institutionalise something that is not only against principles of church state separation but it is also against principles of tax collection. And it happens to coincide with mass exodus of people from Catholic Church, which blatantly revels who will be benefit from it the most.
Small religious movements (like Protestant denominations) will actually be hurt the most with this.
It is the best thing that could happen to Poland. Seriously, and the 2% is just a catch for the main church.
If they reject, it will be obvious they don’t want to be open for financial and statistical information and trying to keep hiding all data staying in the gray zone.
If they accept, it is over. Where less than 50% will pay. And people will understand how much it cost.
Cannot wait! 🤣
Nie podpisze
So can I make up my own religion and church and get someone’s 2%?
Can someone explain to me how this reform accomplishes both:
– saves money in a budget
– increases church income up to 5 times
If people donate 2% of their tax, this money don’t go to the budget as they normally would. If Church ends up with 5 times more money it means that less many went to the budget, right?
How is this neutral? It’s neutral only if the same amount of money is transferred.
The income from PIT is almost 100 billion, if 10% people donates 2% it’s 0,2% ~200 millions so roughly the same it’s now. Help it make sense. Practically if more than 10% of population does it the Church wins, the budget loses. With 50% donating its 5 times more, budget loses 400% more than now.
Comments are closed.