Tucker Carlson: “Why doesn’t Poland go to war with Russia?”



by depava

41 comments
  1. … somebody doesn’t understand how NATO rules work. Without a legitimate attack by Russia, Poland attacking first would remove any obligation to honor NATO Article 5 by our allies.

  2. If some Jew would ask him about Hamas he would be first to defend Israel.

    Remember , USians are not our friends!

  3. Urgh, this piece of shit. MAGAt propagandists are a league of their own when it comes to absolute filth they spew out.

  4. Someone please play the clip from Toby Maguire’s Spider Man “I miss the part where that’s my problem” and include what that set in motion for Uncle Ben.

    America is controlled by the selfish… they care not for sacrificing for others, and they don’t care to think further than their own fleeting life.

    May we hope that nobody figures out mortality and so people like this will always die at some point and the hope of good remains.

  5. Tucker is a grifter plain and simple. He was just over in Russia getting interviewed by Putin and wetting himself about how “modern” the Russian grocery stores are.

  6. he is paid by Russia and is catering to an audience of deranged Americans for profit.

  7. Trying to win an argument with someone smart is difficult. Trying to win an argument with someone who is stupid is impossible.

  8. Tucker Carlson is a right wing tool and a terrible representative of what America is about. Anything associated with him or Turning Point USA should be regarded as ultra conservative garbage.

  9. We will tell you the same when another 9/11 happens and you ask us for help again.

  10. Cool, I wonder if he would say the same thing about Israel

  11. Maybe because you American fuckers disarmed Ukraine off nukes with Russia (and UK) in 1994-1996 for guarantee of border protection. That’s why it’s your bloody responsibility to fight for Ukraine.

  12. There is a 0% chance that the guy isnt paid or blackmailed by Russia. It couldnt be more obvious if you watch his interviews or when he travelled to Russia to show off their supermarkets and stuff.

  13. America can’t be trusted, especially now when they have a president who’s in the same league with Russians

  14. It would be funnier if the public guy asked sarcastically “yeah I agree, why should we die for Gdańsk”, but his actual reply was better, calm and on point.

  15. Kind of ‘off topic’, but in case of attack on one of the NATO countries, if US does not commit highly, whole pact will crumble, and we will see many countries rushing for nuclear weapons, probably with ‘death hand’ system, as the only viable deterrent.

  16. Why then USA needed polish soldiers in Afghanistan? It wasn’t “our concern”…

  17. They deserve every consequence of their actions, so maybe we should form an alliance with China Tucker? And buy things from them? If you don’t want to defend us why we should let your companies invest? Maybe we just tax the fuck out of your big techs and give better deal to China? How about that?

  18. Mmmh.. maybe because the US promised to uphold Ukrainian sovereignty when they signed the Budapest memorandum?

  19. If America wants to stay being a global leader or whatever, they should pay for it, if they don’t want to that’s fine for me, honestly, but then Europe should start looking for more deals with China who is eager to take that place from US and maybe start to treat American business worse then our own.

  20. It’s honestly wild how someone who’s spent years talking about global politics still doesn’t grasp how NATO works. The U.S. isn’t in NATO out of generosity; it’s the backbone of the alliance because it has the largest military and global reach. That’s literally the role America plays in exchange for having influence over the world’s most powerful security bloc.

    Saying Poland should “go to war” instead of the U.S. completely misses the point. NATO’s entire foundation is collective defense, an attack on one is an attack on all. There’s no “you handle it, we’ll sit this one out” clause.

    And pretending it’s just a “regional issue” shows zero understanding of why the U.S. built this system in the first place. America benefits massively from a stable, secure Europe. That stability keeps trade open, allies strong, and adversaries contained.

    It’s actually kind of amazing that someone with a national platform can still sound this ignorant about the very basics of global security.

    I’m generally against deplatforming people, but guys like him make me question that stance. He has reach, he has influence, and he carries a reputation as someone who’s supposed to be informed yet he somehow manages to spit out some of the most disingenuous, uninformed, and dangerous nonsense imaginable. It’s the kind of reckless stupidity that would be embarrassing coming from a middle schooler, let alone a national commentator.

    People in media and politics should stop treating this level of ignorance as just “another opinion.” It deserves open ridicule. Journalists, politicians, and commentators should call him out and mock this kind of unserious thinking for what it is, reckless, lazy, and utterly detached from reality.

  21. The one time NATO article 5 was invoked was when the USA was attacked, and US allies sent their soldiers to die.

  22. Because Poland doesn’t want to go to war with Russia. Poland wants security of the NATO as it was agreed, in an event of Russia starting war with any country that is a part of the alliance. Cuckson knows damn well what’s going on but he’s playing dumb as always. This whole panel is pointless and a public stunt to support their propaganda points.

  23. Poles fought for Americans in wars that they started (Afghanistan, Iraq). Now, that’s how you want to repay us, Tucker Carlson? Yeah… thanks for confirming you’re Putin’s bitch.

  24. Article 5 of NATO has been invoked only once – by the United States.

  25. So why the hell we (Polish people) pay for fucking NATO then? If it dosen’t matter anything, we don’t need to pay for this shit.

    America is nothing without NATO. They are rich, but not THAT rich.

  26. And most of the Poles in Chicago vote for this and support the right wing nuts. Good luck…

  27. Oh wow, with such good allies we don’t need enemies…. Gaplinski is right, pat these self-confident idiots on the back, buy gold, gold and even more gold. Join the BRICS currency coalition and make the currency backed by gold again, then Clarson and others like him will be able to wipe their asses with their prices green dollars at most.

  28. I am happy people like Tucker say the quiet part out loud; if they keep it on maybe Polish politicians will stop kneeling for America someday and start cooperating with European allies.

  29. I get this point on a surface level. But then why did the USA insert itself into – or directly and indirectly caused – so many conflicts around the globe since WW2? It’s Americans that wanted all this influence, to be able to control what’s happening on every continent to control trade and resources. It’s them who built the strongest economy on the world order they built.

    If they want to chill then why did they built the most powerful expeditionary force in human history?

    Now they play dumb.

    I think Europe should redirect away from America and build better relations with China and as a result create a multipolar world order, and leave the USA to fight their wars alone.

  30. Why EU soldiers were involved in the middle east invasion?

  31. “Why?”

    Because they already promised, in Budapest Memorandum, 5th December 1994.

    Keep your fucking word

  32. Because we’re not a military powerhouse and economic superpower.

    Conscripts/reservists shaved forcefully as cannon-fodder led by Soviet-minded officers, logistical mess of equipment from different nations, under-equipped, under-manned, under-trained, under-gunned, poor logistical system and outdated doctrine, with some under-produced serial vehicles and just a few prototypes to hold the line.

    Not to mention decades of neglect from past governments, military purchases by Right-wingers for mostly political reasons and no strategic considerations without negotiating for offset and logistics then leaving next government to fix it which fails to do so, our military still functioning in peacetime which is seen in how we conduct exercises and how procedures work, most of the military going for staff roles (which means there’s no one to train pilots, tank crew, artillerymen, engineers, supply truck drivers, etc. to keep it all working) and having only 30,000 active troops to deploy at any given time.

    My theory why Błaszczak and his friends did this was because Right-wingers expected and feared a swift Russian invasion and that Ukraine would fall in a matter of days, and that Poland’s next, so they gave away all our modernized T-72’s and other equipment that the mechanized infantry was still using and needed for itself, to Ukraine, and then went on a reckless purchasing spree in South Korea and America, to get Poland as much cheap stuff as quickly as possible to make us end up like Belka from Ace Combat: Zero, with 7 nuclear warheads on the Vistula, once the fight turns into a desperate conscription-squad style defensive war, politicians and rich flee the country just like in 1939, the infrastructure gets razed by relentless bombardment from drones, cruise missiles, artillery and close air support with ammunition for just 5 days of combat, and Polish forces set fire to buildings and facilities during their retreat, with only local authorities and officers left to surrender.

    In short, the Right-wing politicians wanted for the world to end quickly, so that they could abandon us to die for it, paint this image of sacrifice for propaganda, but in actuality, their intention was just turning Poland into a battlefield for NATO and Russia, if nothing more than a little speed bump.

    Last time during a military exercise with Americans, Poland managed to pull out just enough ammunition to last us only for hours of fighting, to give you the idea how screwed we are.

    [https://www.pap.pl/aktualnosci/minister-blaszczak-oglaszal-wielkie-zakupy-sprzetu-dla-armii-co-z-tym-sprzetem](https://www.pap.pl/aktualnosci/minister-blaszczak-oglaszal-wielkie-zakupy-sprzetu-dla-armii-co-z-tym-sprzetem)
    (Link temporarily down, so here’s archive: https://archive.ph/irLkH)

  33. Why doesnt USA take all their immigrants from the middle east that flood europe? Afterall its the US that destabilized the middle east waging wars there for the past 30 years. Same with Africa. Why doesnt the US pay for war in Ukraine if it was “Bidens fault” that it started – he was a US president as far as i remember, no?

    See Carlson, 2 can play that game – so better just sh*t the f*ck up.

Comments are closed.