There is a White House website built like a 1990s conspiracy thriller.
Across the top, one word: DECLASSIFIED. Below it, in larger letters: THEY WALK AMONG US. There is a scroll-to-continue prompt, a live arrest map and a button inviting visitors to report suspicious aliens through an ICE tip line. Beneath the map, the page tells visitors: “If you’ve witnessed an Alien abduction, do not be alarmed. The Alien is in good hands.”
Launched on May 28, the page has been engineered, frame by frame, to make the visitor feel as though they have stumbled onto something secret.
The aesthetic has a recent federal antecedent. Earlier this month, the administration began releasing declassified government records relating to unidentified anomalous phenomena, the material once commonly called UFOs, describing the effort as one of “unprecedented transparency” and telling the public it could “decide for themselves” what the files showed. Aliens.gov applies a similar visual grammar of classification, secrecy and revelation to immigration enforcement. The subject has changed. The invitation to the visitor has not. You are being asked to look behind a curtain and see what the government says it has uncovered.
It is easy to treat the page principally as provocation: theatrical, conspicuous and built to command attention. But that reading overlooks the mechanism. The White House page is a case study in how institutional language can move an audience from receiving a message to participating in its frame.
Aliens.gov is not simply striking messaging. It shows how language can turn suspicion into participation, and how soft power can be placed in service of hard power.
The spectacle is not separate from the strategy. The spectacle is the strategy.
Soft Power Is Not Always Trying To Persuade You
We tend to talk about soft power as though it belongs only to the subtle. Joseph Nye defined it as the ability to shape outcomes through attraction rather than coercion, and over the years that idea has become associated with credibility, cultural appeal and the patient accumulation of trust.
But soft power does not have to be subtle or benevolent. And it is not always directed at changing the minds of skeptics.
Sometimes its immediate function is to turn a receptive audience into a participating audience.
That is the part leaders consistently miss. They assume the purpose of a frame is to change minds. Often its first work is to authorize behavior among people it has already reached. A frame does not need everyone to accept it. It needs enough people willing to step inside it and begin acting from within it.
When A Legal Term Becomes A Cultural Script
“Alien” is not a new word in American immigration policy. It is written into federal law. Under the Immigration and Nationality Act, it means a person who is not a citizen or national of the United States.
Its statutory status has allowed the word to be treated as technical or administrative language. But its neutrality has long been contested. In 2021, California removed the term from its state code, describing it as outdated and derogatory and replacing it with language such as “noncitizen” or “immigrant.” That same year, federal immigration agencies were directed to move away from “alien” and “illegal alien” in their own work.
Aliens.gov makes a different communications choice. It places the statutory term inside a science-fiction frame: THEY WALK AMONG US, an “Alien abduction,” and a prompt to report “suspicious aliens.” In a single experience, the legal classification and the extraterrestrial metaphor are presented side by side.
That matters because language from an institution with the power to detain or remove is never merely descriptive. A word can signal the kind of relationship the public is invited to have with the people it names: recognition, distance, vigilance or participation.
Soft Power In The Service Of Hard Power
There is a clean line to draw here. Immigration enforcement is not soft power. Detention and removal are exercises of state authority backed by law and force.
But soft power can be placed in service of hard power.
A website cannot detain or remove anyone. It can shape how detention and removal are understood. It can place an enforcement map inside an interactive narrative, position a tip line inside that experience and give visitors a role within the frame.
This page does not ask visitors only to receive information. It invites them to observe encounters, study a map and report people the page characterizes as suspicious.
That is why the page’s volume is not evidence that it has failed to persuade. Passing unnoticed may not be its purpose. Its function may be less to convert opponents than to activate people already inclined to accept its premise.
That is not conventional persuasion. It is participation by design.
The Audience Is Part Of The Message
Most leaders treat communication as the wrapper around a decision: first the policy, then the words used to explain it.
But language is not packaging. Language assigns people a role.
Aliens.gov does not address its visitors as passive recipients of a policy. It casts them as watchers of encounters, readers of an arrest map and potential reporters of the suspicious. The visitor is not simply receiving a message. The visitor is being placed inside a worldview.
That is the deeper function of a frame. It shapes not only what people think, but what they notice, what they fear and what they feel entitled to do next.
And a frame does not stay on a screen. People carry it into rooms: into who appears out of place at a school gate, who sounds out of place in an office, who seems not to belong in a neighborhood.
The Leadership Question Is Not Whether The Language Works
Nothing in ordinary institutional life is morally or legally equivalent to a government deciding how to describe people it has the power to deport. But the strategic principle travels, which is exactly why it is worth naming.
Leaders in every sector choose language that sorts people: “resources,” “low performers,” “culture fits,” “legacy employees,” “nonessential,” “high potential,” “at risk.” Each term can appear procedural. Each one teaches an organization how to see.
And the test most leaders apply is the wrong one. They ask whether the language is effective. Effective language is easy to find. Plenty of words generate compliance, urgency or fear with great efficiency.
The harder question is what the language makes permissible.
What action does it authorize? What distance does it open between the person choosing the word and the person who must live inside it?
Soft power is usually described as attraction rather than command. That distinction remains useful. But it can conceal a responsibility: attraction is not inherently virtuous. The same architecture of belonging that draws people toward a shared purpose can also orient them against those defined as outside it.
So before leaders reach for the word, the metaphor or the spectacle, the question is not only whether it will land. It is what the language gives people permission to do once it has.
Because once a frame teaches an audience to read a category of people as a problem they have a role in identifying, the language has already done more than communicate a position.
It has changed the terms on which people are invited to see one another.
This article was originally published on Forbes.com