A shrine erected to remember those who died at Manzanar is one of the few structures that remain at the historic site, with the Eastern Sierra range in background. 

A shrine erected to remember those who died at Manzanar is one of the few structures that remain at the historic site, with the Eastern Sierra range in background. 

BRANT WARD

Now, as the federal government continues its unprecedented campaign of mass deportation and migrant detention, our patriotic state faces another housing crisis.

The Trump administration wants desperately to detain hundreds of thousands more of our undocumented neighbors and legal immigrants whose status it has lawlessly canceled. But it keeps tripping itself up.

Existing migration detention centers are overcrowded, can’t find staff, and offer conditions so poor (lack of bathrooms and health care, dangerous temperatures, unhealthy food) that courts and localities try to shut them down. Using old jails, near downtowns, makes detention centers easy targets for protestors. Attempts to convert old warehouse sites or build new prisons, as in Gilroy, violate zoning codes and various state and local laws.

Article continues below this ad

Even more expensive is the latest Trump strategy — having the federal government buy private detention facilities so that it has more control. The Department of Homeland Security’s recent purchase of the Otay Mesa Detention Center in San Diego and the California City Detention Facility in the Mojave Desert from the private prison company CoreCivic cost $1.5 billion, more than four times the assessed value of these properties.

Why does the U.S. government use failed strategies, when the simplest solution is staring us in the face?

The Trump administration should reopen California’s incarceration camps, used to warehouse Japanese Americans during World War II.

This very modest proposal might sound shocking. But it is merely an exercise in pragmatism.

Article continues below this ad

From a managerial perspective, the advantages are overwhelming. Places like Manzanar in Inyo County and Tule Lake in Modoc County are already under federal jurisdiction — preserved as historical monuments, waiting to be adapted for our new golden era of racist fearmongering.

Furthermore, let us be honest: Modern migrant detention centers operating across the United States are, in scale and function, the logical evolution of 1940s relocation centers.

Why spend billions of taxpayers’ dollars on brand-new detention centers when the blueprints — and the actual foundations — already exist?

Plus, the aesthetics are better. Where mid-century camps were visually open about their carceral nature, today’s facilities masquerade as bland, windowless concrete logistics parks. They are Amazon fulfillment centers where the inventory is human beings.

If we examine the historical record objectively, a return to the wartime camp model would represent a significant humanitarian upgrade. California’s Japanese incarceration camps were godawful. But compared to ICE detention centers, they possessed a robust civic infrastructure! At Manzanar and at Tule Lake, incarcerated populations had schools, churches, Buddhist temples, newspapers, community councils, agricultural cooperatives, even sports leagues. If the federal government insists on mass confinement for millions of people who have committed no crimes, it should at least do so with the dignity of a baseball diamond.

Article continues below this ad

The geography of wartime incarceration also supports this path. Today’s migrant detention system favors cheaper facilities in California’s Central Valley, and deserts. ICE and its private contractors are in Adelanto, California City, McFarland, Bakersfield and Calexico; World War II incarceration often began in assembly centers in Fresno, Merced or Tulare, not so far away. Manzanar sits in the Owens Valley, in the Eastern Sierra. Tule Lake is just below the Oregon border on a dry lakebed.

Placing newly detained populations in these remote places would let the federal government achieve its goal: out of sight, out of mind. Coastal progressives, who hold candlelight vigils outside urban ICE offices, wouldn’t drive six hours into the high desert. It’s much easier to hold more “No Kings” rallies in charming downtowns with good coffee options.

Some will object on moral grounds, or invoking the dark stains of our past. But this ignores how Americans view their own misdeeds — we don’t. Yes, the government offered reparations for the World War II camps in the 1980s. But, as a nation, we never truly recognized these places as the concentration camps they actually were.

Hence the moral barrier to reusing them today is remarkably low. If the American public didn’t rise up in rebellion when their fellow citizens were locked away in the desert in 1942, why would they do so for non-citizens today? We long ago normalized barbed-wire containment. We’ve just changed the demographic target to fit MAGA prejudices.

Guest opinions in Open Forum and Insight are produced by writers with expertise, personal experience or original insights on a subject of interest to our readers. Their views do not necessarily reflect the opinion of The Chronicle editorial board, which is committed to providing a diversity of ideas to our readership.

Read more about our transparency and ethics policies

Sure, some critics argue for a different approach. National immigrant protection coalitions seek to close detention centers, end private detention contracts, and defund ICE. But those strategies will struggle for years to win bipartisan support, while migrants suffer.  A few radicals — activists, antifa, a rogue California columnist — dream of mass action by everyday Americans to take over such facilities, and help the people inside escape. But that’s just a scene from “One Battle After Another,” right?

Article continues below this ad

Since we obviously lack the courage to close these concentration camps, why not reopen Manzanar and stop pretending we are better than our past?

Joe Mathews writes the Connecting California column for Zócalo Public Square.