Pope Leo XIV this week appointed a slate of seven new members to the Church’s highest court, the Supreme Tribunal of the Apostolic Signatura. The appointees include two Americans: Archbishop Salvatore Cordileone of San Francisco — who previously served as an assistant to the Signatura from 1995-2002 — and Bishop Edward Lohse of Kalamazoo, Michigan.

The Apostolic Signatura is the highest judicial body under the Church’s canon law. Its name refers to its original purpose as the body that received petitions made to the Holy See and prepared them for the Pope’s “signatura” — Latin for “signature.” It was established in its current form in 1908 by Pope Pius X.

In 2008, Pope Benedict XVI changed the law to allow non-bishops to serve on the tribunal, but Pope Leo’s recent appointments — which include three priests — mark the first time non-bishops will actually become members.

But what kinds of cases does the Church’s “final court of appeal” handle? And will their membership require the new American judges to give up their dioceses and move to Rome?

Here are three things to know about the Apostolic Signatura and its members.

1. It’s the highest-ranking of the three most important courts at the Vatican.

As part of the Roman Curia, the Apostolic Signatura is the Church’s highest court and is a central part of the Pope’s governance of the universal Church. (No court outranks the Pope who, as head of the Church on earth, has supreme authority to judge cases and definitively resolve juridical disputes). The Apostolic Signatura itself is led by a cardinal prefect, currently the Italian Cardinal Dominique Mamberti, who was appointed in 2014 by Pope Francis. Its members serve renewable five-year terms.

The Signatura oversees all other courts in the Church — known as tribunals — which adjudicate Church-related cases and disputes throughout the world. Every diocese in the world has a tribunal, and the Signatura has the exclusive competence to authorize and establish tribunals that operate across multiple jurisdictions such as regional, inter-diocesan, or even national.

There are two other “top” courts at the Vatican. The Tribunal of the Roman Rota ordinarily acts as an appellate court to lower tribunals, and mainly handles cases related to marriage annulment, though it has the jurisdiction to hear any case in any area of canon law.

The Apostolic Penitentiary, meanwhile, deals specifically with cases of very serious sins — such as the desecration of the Eucharist — the forgiveness of which is reserved to the Holy See. As part of this role, the Penitentiary can lift spiritual penalties associated with those serious sins, such as excommunication. The Penitentiary also deals specifically with the granting and use of indulgences, such as those offered to the faithful during a Jubilee Year.

Together, the Apostolic Signatura, the Roman Rota, and the Penitentiary are referred to as the Institutions of Justice. It’s worth noting, though, that the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith has its own Supreme Apostolic Tribunal, which adjudicates “grave delicts committed against morals and in the celebration of the sacraments,” including sexual abuse of minors.

2. The Apostolic Signatura reviews lower-level decisions — including parish closures

Central to the Signatura’s role is supervising the administration of justice throughout the Church, which includes reviewing decisions made by lower tribunals or by bishops.

The Signatura can oversee hundreds of cases in a given year. For instance, in 2024,it handled 763 cases, according to information released by the Vatican.

One function of the Apostolic Signatura that ordinary Catholics may have encountered is through an appeal to review an act of governance made by a diocesan bishop, such as the decision to close or merge a parish. An individual or group with canonically legal standing might appeal the bishop’s action to close their parish by first appealing to the relevant Vatican department, in this case the Dicastery for Clergy; following the dicastery’s decision, the case could then be appealed by either party to the Apostolic Signatura.

Much of the work of the Signatura is procedural, like reviewing requests to waive the requirement that all tribunal workers have canon law degrees.

The court also deals with more sensitive situations, although the details of most such cases are not shared publicly. Included would be its reviews of the processes that led to the dissolution of groups and associations within the Church, as well as cases involving the removal of pastors from their parishes.

The Apostolic Signatura can also review and overturn decisions made by the Roman Rota, although in these cases it functions as a court of cassation, meaning it only considers procedural questions, not the merits of each case. Give the Roman Rota’s focus, these cases typically involve marriage nullity.

The Apostolic Signatura is also the final court of cassation for Vatican City State, settling disputes related to the state’s civil governance. At the request of the

pope or other curial institutions, it also adjudicates other administrative controversies, including jurisdictional conflicts between Vatican dicasteries, and between dicasteries and the Secretariat of State.

3. Americans have featured on the Signatura before.

Archbishop Cordileone and Bishop Lohse are not the first U.S. prelates to serve on the Apostolic Signatura. The former archbishop of St. Louis, Cardinal Raymond Burke, was first appointed as a member by Pope Benedict in 2006, before being elevated to prefect of the Signatura in 2008. In 2014, Pope Francis removed him from the tribunal when he appointed him as patron to the Knights of Malta, but then re-appointed the American cardinal as an ordinary member in 2017. Cardinal Burke’s membership was renewed in 2022, and his current appointment lasts until 2027.

Cardinal James Harvey, another American and archpriest of the Basilica of St. Paul Outside the Walls in Rome, will continue in his current role at the Signatura until he turns 80 in roughly four years.

Two U.S. prelates who had been serving as members have concluded their tenure as of this year. Cardinal Joseph Tobin of Newark, New Jersey had been serving on the Signatura since 2021 appointment by Pope Francis, and has now completed his five-year term. Bishop Mark Leonard Bartchak of Altoona-Johnstown, Pennsylvania, has also now concluded his term. Pope Leo has not renewed either of their appointments.

The members of the Signatura are chosen by the Pope for their expertise in canon law and thus can span the spectrum of perceived ideological leanings. For example, Cardinal Burke is generally considered one of the more traditional voices in the Church. He has served alongside bishops with a reputation for being more progressive-minded, such as Cardinal Tobin and Cardinal Mario Grech, secretary-general of the Synod of Bishops.

Despite their new Vatican roles, Archbishop Cordileone and Bishop Lohse will not be relocating to Rome. Instead, the new members of the Signatura will retain their positions as heads of their dioceses. They will travel to the Eternal City “as often as we can,” Archbishop Cordileone told Raymond Arroyo in a recent interview, perhaps “three or four times a year.”

Members of the Signatura already located in Rome will meet more often. All members will convene at least once a year for plenary sessions of the Curia.