However, supporters of the AJHS bid argued families needed greater choice, with some parents saying the senior school’s model did not suit every student.
Others fiercely defended ASHS, saying its flexible approach and individualised support had helped their children thrive, particularly those who had struggled in more traditional school environments.
In a letter to the school community, AJHS said it had been informed by the Ministry of Education that a full review of the Albany school pathway would be undertaken.
As a result, its application to extend through to Year 13 would not progress “at this stage”.
The school described the decision as a “positive outcome” and an opportunity to consider the future of education across the Albany area.
“We look forward to supporting the ministry as it undertakes this review and considers how the network can best meet the future needs of students, families, and our wider community,” the school said.
In a statement included in the letter, Ministry of Education deputy secretary for education services Geoff Short said AJHS’ application was “not yet ready” to proceed to public consultation because further work and information were required.
Short said public discussion prompted by the proposal had generated feedback about schooling options and choice in the area.
The ministry would now undertake a wider review and community engagement process during 2027 and 2028 to help determine future schooling provision.
In an email to the school community, Claire Amos said she was “really pleased” with the decision.
It means ASHS will continue catering for Years 11 to 13, while AJHS remains a Year 7 to 10 school.
“This means Albany Senior High School will continue to do what we were established to do: provide outstanding Years 11–13 education for the rangatahi [youth] of Albany and our wider community,” Amos said.
She said the decision meant ASHS could now look ahead with “confidence and certainty”.
The school’s focus remained on ensuring students were supported, challenged and prepared for what came next, Amos said.
She said ASHS also looked forward to working “seamlessly” alongside AJHS.
Rachel Maher is the education correspondent for the New Zealand Herald. She also covers other topics such as Auckland issues, crime and local government. She started at the Herald as a breaking news journalist in 2022, before joining the Auckland team this year.
Sign up to The Daily H, a free newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.