Robinhood name-dropped its prediction market exchange 18 times during a July 29 second-quarter earnings presentation and 10 times in a subsequent call with analysts. Robinhood co-owns the entity, named Rothera, alongside Susquehanna International Group and Miami International Holdings through a purchase that closed earlier this year.

Rothera earned Robinhood’s praise by rapidly onboarding volume during the World Cup with few public hiccups just months after relaunching post-acquisition. For a time, Rothera eclipsed Crypto.com’s exchange subsidiary, then known as Nadex/CDNA, for third place in betting volume among all U.S. prediction market exchanges during the World Cup’s knockout rounds.

Not even two months later, Robinhood has bought into another shiny prediction market toy: the very exchange Rothera briefly surpassed in July.

By taking an equity stake in both Crypto.com and Crypto.com’s new prediction market spin-off OG, Robinhood gained a tie to the underlying exchange, which became an OG subsidiary in the corporate restructuring.

Robinhood, led by CEO Vlad Tenev, has framed its investment in OG as a product expansion rather than a move to supplant the exchange it spoke so glowingly about with investors in July. Robinhood will continue to route many bets through Rothera even as OG’s exchange gives it another option.

“I view it as purely additive,” JB Mackenzie, Robinhood’s vice president and general manager of futures and prediction markets, said in a video interview.

The agreement offered a look at the direction of the industry as the number of federally approved prediction market exchanges balloons.

Robinhood’s rationale

Robinhood has not disclosed how much of Crypto.com or OG it has acquired, nor the percentage of prediction market wagers it will now broker for OG’s exchange to execute.

OG was recently valued at $5 billion in a Citadel Securities investment—a figure that includes a prediction market app and the underlying exchange. Crypto.com, which maintains a relationship with the exchange after the spinoff, was valued at $15 billion.

Robinhood could have viewed OG as another prediction market competitor and sought to crush it. Rothera’s World Cup performance offered a promising look at how the exchange might stack up with OG long term.

Alternatively, Robinhood could have merely brokered some bets through OG’s exchange without an equity component. This is what Robinhood has done for more than a year with Kalshi and ForecastEx; in fact, before closing its deal for a 45% stake in Rothera, Robinhood only brokered for exchanges it didn’t own.

There are potential advantages that accompany Robinhood’s decision to grab a stake in OG.

Mackenzie said the tie-up enables Robinhood to offer lower fees to customers for bets on OG’s exchange than it would when routing to unaffiliated exchanges. Through those better rates, OG’s exchange presents a similar setup to Rothera, at least from the customer’s perspective.

Even though Robinhood doesn’t control OG’s exchange, its equity relationship promotes communication between entities so they can align over logistics, such as standards for how bets are resolved. Just last weekend, Robinhood was burned when it brokered college football bets through Kalshi, as the third-party exchange prematurely resolved the Western Michigan at Michigan game as a victory for the road team before referees added a second on the clock and the Wolverines completed a game-winning Hail Mary pass.

While that kind of flub could still happen with an affiliated exchange, there’s some extra comfort for Robinhood when working with Rothera and now OG’s exchange given the ongoing dialogue between companies.

“That allows you to have a little bit more input into what they’re trying to do,” Mackenzie said. “They listen to you a little bit more than if you don’t have that strategic relationship.”

OG’s exchange offers wagers that Rothera’s team has chosen not to get involved with, such as prop bets on player stats. That means if Robinhood routes bets on Buffalo Bills quarterback Josh Allen to throw for at least 300 passing yards through OG’s exchange, the brokerage app wouldn’t be taking anything away from Rothera, which has never offered that type of wager.

Exchanges initially built for prediction markets are also evolving to incorporate other products like perpetual futures. As they diversify, OG’s exchange and Rothera could develop specialties that complement each other.

Crypto.com CEO Kris Marszalek touched on that type of give-and-take when asked why two competitors that aspire to create financial everything apps would join forces. “They are strong in some things,” he told Sportico. “We are strong in other things. I think it’s very complementary in the end.”

The list of companies wanting to be all-in-one financial hubs is long, with Coinbase, Webull and Gemini also in the mix to varying degrees. By working together, Robinhood, Crypto.com and OG can aim to box out the others.

“And the teams like each other,” Marszalek said, “so that helps.”

Should Rothera and its co-owners be concerned?

Whereas some exchanges receive trading flow from multiple brokers, Rothera is reliant on Robinhood’s sizable user base to generate its volume.

But Robinhood’s assurances about where the OG deal leaves Rothera are being taken at face value. A Rothera official told Sportico the exchange does not feel threatened by Robinhood’s OG announcement, echoing Mackenzie in describing the move as additive and not meant to chip away at Rothera’s volume.

Susquehanna, which owns 45% of Rothera and acts as a market maker on the platform, signaled it is similarly unperturbed by Robinhood’s FCM (a technical term for brokers) investing in another DCM (exchange).

“Robinhood sending flow to Crypto.com was not a surprise and is not a concern as it is standard for FCMs to work with multiple DCM partners and has been Robinhood’s consistent practice,” Susquehanna head of strategic planning David Pollard wrote in a statement. “We’re very excited to have partnered with Robinhood to create Rothera which has been a great success in its first few months of operation as evidenced by its volumes and market share during World Cup. We’re extremely confident in its long-term ability to attract additional distribution partners and be an industry-leading DCM for overall customer experience as its product offering continues to expand in the coming months.”

Susquehanna is also active on unaffiliated exchanges, including Kalshi. The finance giant was one of the first institutional liquidity providers to embrace prediction markets.

Miami International Holdings held onto 10% of Rothera after selling the rest to Robinhood and Susquehanna. Miami International Holdings did not respond to a request for comment.

OG’s optimistic valuation

Prediction market company valuations are difficult to compare because some firms are pure prediction market plays, while others use exchange betting as a small part of their product portfolio.

At this stage, OG is close to a pure prediction market play, though like others in the same boat, it intends to branch out to more federally regulated products, including perpetual futures.

OG’s $5 billion places it third among its most comparable firms, behind Kalshi ($22 billion and reportedly seeking funding at a $40 billion valuation) and Polymarket ($20 billion pre-money), and ahead of Novig ($500 million).

Considering OG’s app is still in its infancy, the underlying exchange likely drives a significant portion of its current valuation. Despite substantial executive turnover at OG’s exchange, Marszalek described it as best in class, pointing to a string of B2B agreements as proof of its reputation.

In addition to Robinhood, OG’s exchange powers sports bets for FanDuel Predicts, expanding that relationship as FanDuel’s partnership with CME Group appeared to fray. It has worked with several of the other traditional sportsbook and daily fantasy firms getting into prediction markets as they transition onto their own exchanges.

Marszalek said Underdog has quietly initiated an uptick in routing bets through OG’s exchange, even though Underdog had been ramping up Aristotle Exchange, which it purchased this year.

Crypto.com pays Underdog for order flow. An Underdog spokesperson said Crypto.com is “a really good partner and they made us a very good offer.”

Start of something new?

While Marszalek declined to specifically address why Underdog has shifted more of its wager executions back to OG’s exchange, he used a question about the change to make an industry prediction.

Marszalek said the trend of companies buying or building their own prediction market exchanges—which is what Underdog did—is going to reverse as firms realize any benefits from having full control of infrastructure are outweighed by technical challenges.

Instead, he said, many organizations will switch back to solely being brokers for the biggest exchanges, because “operating an exchange is actually a lot of work, and you need to aggregate a lot of volume for it to actually economically make sense.”

“There’s this rush for all the players to go and say, ‘OK, I’m going to get my own [full stack of infrastructure],’” Marszalek said. “But in the end, it just doesn’t make economic sense. … So I think you will see maybe 24 to 36 months from now, only a few venues still focusing on [their own exchanges].”

Rothera, of course, will hope Marszalek’s forecast only applies elsewhere. And it’s worth noting that Marszalek’s view is beneficial to his own interests—if there’s exchange consolidation, OG’s exchange could greatly benefit from more volume and potentially additional outside investments.

But there’s no question that the young business of prediction markets is primed to change rapidly. Sports exchange betting under the watch of the federal government only began in December 2024.

“I don’t think that all the cards have been dealt here,” Marszalek said.