A barrage of litigation related to Trump’s tariffs is coinciding with an upheaval over federal courts’ power, creating uncertainty about how broadly US trade court decisions over refunds and the legality of new duties will apply.

In last year’s Trump v. CASA, the US Supreme Court limited district courts’ use of universal injunctions. An ongoing case will determine how that limit applies to the US Court of International Trade, which hears all new tariff challenges and is handling litigation around refunds from the struck-down International Emergency Economic Powers Act tariffs.

At issue is the trade court’s power to have a decision apply to all importers, not just ones that brought a suit. There’s a lot at stake, with an unprecedented tariff refund effort underway and hundreds of thousands of importers affected by ongoing and new tariffs imposed by President Donald Trump’s administration.

But there are alternatives to universal injunctions. Attorneys have argued for the court to adopt class action or administrative law approaches in tariff cases — both of which could bypass the CASA issue.

Class Action

In at least two cases, attorneys proposed class actions to cover importers who may not otherwise be eligible for IEEPA refunds without filing their own lawsuits.

“In the wake of Trump v. CASA, seeking certification of a class action is probably the safest way to ensure that refunds of illegally collected tariffs will actually get paid down the road,” said Mila Sohoni, a Stanford Law School professor and administrative law expert. “CASA did not disturb the ability of federal courts to resolve class action lawsuits.”

Trade court Judge Richard Eaton ordered the government to pay IEEPA refunds in March, shortly after the Supreme Court struck down Trump’s IEEPA tariffs. He issued the order on one plaintiff’s docket, but said it applied to all importers — not just those that filed suits.

Months later, the Trump administration appealed the order, pointing to CASA to say the trade court doesn’t have authority to order Customs to refund importers that aren’t in front of the court.

The practical implications of the government’s position land on companies with imports, or entries, that are past the point in the normal Customs timeline when the agency can still open an entry to refund the amount of duties owed. The government argues that those importers must file their own lawsuits to get money back. That outcome would be bad news for small importers, for whom legal costs are a heavier burden than for larger companies.

By sweeping all non-plaintiff importers into a class, the court could issue one order affecting all of them, and they wouldn’t each need to file their own suits. In other words, a class action could get money back to many importers that might otherwise miss out.

APA Remedy

The US Trade Representative in July enacted tariffs on more than 80 countries, based on their not banning imports made with forced labor. The government imposed the duties under Section 301 of the Trade Act of 1974.

Multiple suits quickly challenged the tariffs. The trade court consolidated them into one challenge seeking invalidation of the Section 301 tariffs as a violation of the Administrative Procedure Act, a 1946 law that gives courts oversight of agencies. The APA allows judges to “set aside” defective agency actions — a broad remedy that can have the same practical effect as the universal injunctions that CASA restricted.

Plaintiffs argued in an Aug. 17 joint brief prior to the consolidation of the cases that the APA’s default remedy — which would vacate the tariffs, essentially wiping them off the books — “would benefit all affected importers without requiring resolving issues related to class certification or injunctive relief.”

But the Trump administration is leveraging CASA to contest the general consensus among lower courts that the APA permits nullifying unlawful agency actions. The administration argued the law doesn’t allow that kind of remedy, and staying consistent with the limit on universal injunctions requires leaving the tariffs in place even if the court finds that they violated the law.

“Such narrowly tailored relief is consistent with the Supreme Court’s guidance in CASA and would minimize disruptions to USTR’s important efforts to eradicate forced labor from global supply chains,” the government said in a Sept. 4 brief.

Nevertheless, importers could see refunds if the court finds that the tariffs violate the APA and sets them aside, said Ronald Levin, an administrative law scholar at Washington University in St. Louis. It could order reimbursements through its inherent equitable authority to restore importers to the condition they were in before the unlawful action, or through a mechanism within the trade law itself, if one exists, Levin said.

That equitable power to correct mistakes — such as collecting tariffs that had no legal backing — also extends to agencies themselves, said Harvey Reiter, a regulatory and appellate attorney at Stinson LLP. The Supreme Court held in its 1965 decision in United Gas Improvement Co. v. Callery Properties Inc. that an agency had refund power when its unlawful order resulted in overcharges, he said.