For most of its modern history, Canada has known that geography is destiny. Its economy, security, and international influence have all been shaped by proximity to the United States. With about 72 per cent of exports going across the southern border in 2025, the economic relationship between the two countries has always been one of the world’s biggest. But Prime Minister Mark Carney seems determined to change that assumption now. According to The Wall Street Journal, the prime minister is pursuing an ambitious realignment with Europe—arrangements for more Canadian companies to access the European Union’s $21 trillion single market in energy, critical minerals, artificial intelligence, defense and scientific research.
Discussions have even explored whether Canadians could live and work in Europe without visas. This is not a trade initiative; it’s an effort to reduce Canada’s dependence on the U.S. by rebuilding economic and strategic ties across the Atlantic. Carney’s gamble makes sense after President Trump’s threats to make Canada the 51st American state, along with trade-war rhetoric, broke an alliance Canadians thought was virtually permanent. Carney has said the rupture in relations is more than a disagreement—he warns that political changes unleashed by his American counterpart may last beyond his presidency.
The question is whether Canada can turn that rupture into a durable alternative.
A Divorce That May Become Permanent
The U.S. and Canada have always been intertwined societies: their industries, energy networks, transportation systems, universities, and defense establishments were all built on the assumption that the border would stay open economically and politically. The North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA)—replaced by the United States–Mexico–Canada Agreement during the first Trump administration in 2020—only consolidated that integration. Canadian businesses became more oriented toward the American consumer; economic ties with Europe withered.
‘Carney’s gamble makes sense after President Trump’s threats to make Canada the 51st American state’
Carney’s strategy is not just about trade diversification—it is about reversing the continental transformation that occurred after World War II. Before 1939, Europe (not the United States) was Canada’s main external commercial and cultural reference point. English-speaking Canadians were tightly bound to Britain; French Canadians had their own historical and cultural ties to Europe. The war and its aftermath put Canada into an American-led economic and security order, with the U.S. as its dominant market and strategic partner.
President Richard Nixon’s 1971 decision to impose a temporary import surcharge forced then prime minister Pierre Trudeau to push harder for ties with Europe—but little came of it. When Brian Mulroney was elected in 1984, he reignited interest in North American integration, and eventually NAFTA was signed. Carney is now trying to revive an option previous leaders could not.
Europe Offers Opportunity—and Constraints
The EU has obvious attractions for Canada. It is a huge market, with sophisticated regulatory institutions, research capabilities, and governments that share many of Canada’s political and social assumptions. Europeans also have reasons to want a closer relationship with a stable, resource-rich democracy in the Arctic, with military and technological potential.
The partnership Carney is flirting with could be especially useful in strategic supply chains. Canada has critical minerals, energy resources, agricultural production and an educated workforce; the EU has industrial capacity, capital, and technological expertise, in addition to an urgent need to strengthen its vulnerable defense capabilities. Possible cooperation could also give Canadians and Europeans alternatives to U.S. and Chinese supplies. Undersea cables between Europe and Canada are reportedly being discussed, along with data centers and cloud storage facilities built together; satellite networks and pipelines redirecting Canadian natural gas toward European markets.
Canada is also pursuing closer defense cooperation by seeking to buy European military equipment, even though it would face enormous economic hurdles.
The EU, however, is not an ‘anyone-can-join’ club; Brussels would need to modify the Treaty on European Union, which governs the 27 Member States, in order to admit Canada, even as an associate member. Its membership process shows what political and legal demands are involved (Ukraine has seen this). Canada would have to concede sovereignty, accept the EU regulatory system, follow common rules, pay into the common pot, and allow workers to move around, etc. The danger is that the negotiations could produce a politically catchy slogan but not an economically transformative agreement.
The Limits of Substitution
Carney’s strategy has a substantial weakness: geography. Europe may be a good business partner, but it cannot replace the U.S. as Canada’s main economic partner because Americans are next door—their products are in Canadian supply chains, and infrastructure has been built over generations to connect them. EU markets are farther away; shipping costs, regulatory differences, and commercial habits then create barriers that no diplomatic agreement can overcome.
The problem is most acute in manufacturing—Canadian factories depend on American components, investment, and customers. Moving production toward Europe would be more than signing agreements—it would require costly economic restructuring, something Europe is not ready for. In fact, European economies have their own structural problems (slow growth, high energy costs, demographic pressures, and political disagreements over industrial policy). The economic situation Carney faces is clear: Canada can diversify its trade, but it cannot replace the American market.
The U.S. continues to be the world’s ultimate consumer, and neither Canada nor Europe possesses a market that is even close to being large enough to accommodate the production that presently relies on American demand.
The Strategic Dimension
The political case for a European pivot may be stronger than the economic one. Trump’s treatment of Canada has created a crisis of confidence. Tariffs will come down eventually, but the annexation threat and economic pressure against a close ally have changed how Canadians view the U.S.
For decades, Canadian leaders thought American power was always a stabilizing force. Carney’s government seems to be preparing for a future in which American power may not be predictable—or even benevolent. European governments feel disillusioned with Washington too. Trump’s pressure on Greenland, his attitude toward NATO, and the war in Iran have made some European leaders ask how much strategic autonomy they need. Canada and Europe therefore have an interest in reducing dependence on one American-centered system.
Cooperation could go beyond trade to defense procurement, intelligence, technology and Arctic security. The question is whether this emerging alignment can be more than a reaction to Trump’s polemics. Carney may be able to convince Canadians that closer ties with Europe are needed, but it will be harder to convince them that the obligations that flow from those ties will not undermine the independence he is trying to protect.
Related articles:
At a time when public debate is increasingly polarized and superficial, Hungarian Conservative remains committed to depth, intellectual honesty, and independent conservative thought.
Producing high-quality journalism requires resources. Your contribution helps us expand our coverage, reach new audiences, and keep our content accessible.
Please consider supporting our mission.