Most Americans are trying to make sense of President Donald Trump’s trade war against Canada, America’s second-largest trading partner, not to mention his verbal insults directed at Canada and its leaders. A recent Quinnipiac poll found that only 28% of Americans believe that Trump’s attitude toward Canada was “about right.”
Why pick a fight with a neighbor nation that buys more than $333 billion worth of U.S. goods, provides 60% of our aluminum, as well as about 90% of the potash U.S. farmers use to fertilize their crops? And that’s just the beginning.
In 2025, the United States and Canada engaged in about $716 billion worth of trade. Canada bought about $334 billion of U.S. goods, while the U.S. bought about $382 billion of Canadian goods. That resulted in a $48 billion U.S. trade deficit with Canada.
But those numbers need some perspective. The United States has a population of about 342 million people compared with roughly 41 million in Canada. Given that enormous population difference, it should not be surprising that the United States imports more from Canada than Canada imports from the United States.
In fact, on a per-capita basis, Canadians buy far more from the United States than Americans buy from Canada. The average Canadian purchased roughly $9,300 worth of U.S. goods in 2025, while the average American purchased about $1,100 worth of Canadian goods. In other words, on a per-capita basis, Canadians purchased roughly eight to nine times more from the United States than Americans purchased from Canada.
Americans should find no comfort in the fact that the Tariff Act of 1930, commonly known as the Smoot-Hawley Tariff Act, is once again being used to impose tariffs. Smoot-Hawley helped trigger a wave of retaliatory tariffs during the Great Depression and remains one of the most frequently cited examples of the dangers of protectionist trade policies.
As Spanish-American philosopher George Santayana wrote in 1905, “Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it.”
We frequently hear about Section 338 of the Tariff Act of 1930, which gives the president authority to impose tariffs of up to 50% when a foreign country discriminates against U.S. commerce. Trump has now invoked that provision against Canada, making this the first time a president has actually used Section 338 to impose trade restrictions.
The Trump administration argues that Canada has discriminated against American products, particularly in areas such as dairy, alcoholic beverages and automobiles. Whether those policies justify such sweeping tariffs is a matter of considerable debate. What is clear is that Canada is a major customer for American businesses, farmers and manufacturers.
Many Americans may also be surprised to learn how important Canada is to the U.S. economy. Canada is not simply another foreign trading partner. It is a deeply integrated economic partner whose resources and products are woven into American manufacturing, agriculture, energy and defense.
Then there is tourism.
Millions of Canadians visit the United States each year, spending billions of dollars and supporting American businesses and jobs. But the growing political and economic conflict is encouraging more Canadians to spend their money elsewhere. Recent reporting shows that Canadian consumers are increasingly choosing Canadian products and that retailers are changing their supply chains in response.
Canada has also responded to Trump’s tariffs with tariffs of its own. This month, Canada imposed new retaliatory tariffs on about $20 billion worth of U.S. exports, affecting products including steel, dairy and agricultural equipment.
That hurts American exporters, including farmers and manufacturers. American businesses sell billions of dollars of goods to Canada every year, making Canada one of the most important markets for U.S. products. For many American states, companies and farmers, Canada is their best customer.
Canada has also made clear that it intends to diversify its trade relationships and reduce its dependence on the United States. Other nations are happy to sell their products to Canada.
The same is true in defense. Canada has historically purchased a majority of its defense equipment from American companies. But that relationship is changing. In July, Canada selected Germany’s ThyssenKrupp Marine Systems to build up to 12 new submarines for the Canadian Navy. The contract is expected to be one of Canada’s largest-ever military procurements, possibly up to $100 billion.
That’s $100 billion that otherwise might have been spent with American defense contractors.
Trump’s tariffs on Canada are a prime example of how his policies are affecting the American economy and potentially raising prices for ordinary Americans. Consider four important resources the United States gets from Canada: uranium, aluminum, critical minerals and potash.
Canada is a major supplier of uranium to the United States, including uranium used to fuel America’s nuclear power plants. About one-third of the uranium used in the United States comes from Canada. Finding replacement supplies would take time and could be more expensive.
The same is true of Canadian aluminum. American automakers, aircraft and aerospace manufacturers, construction companies, electrical-grid operators and manufacturers all depend on aluminum. Canada supplies roughly 60% of U.S. aluminum imports. Tariffs increase the cost of that aluminum, which can ultimately increase the cost of cars, aircraft, construction materials, appliances, and other products.
The United States also depends on Canada for critical minerals, such as zinc, tellurium and nickel. These materials are essential to American manufacturing, electricity production, agriculture, defense and technology. Replacing this source would be difficult and expensive.
Lastly, the United States depends heavily on Canada for potash, an important fertilizer for American farmers. Canada supplied about 90% of U.S. net potash imports in 2023. Potash is particularly important for crops such as corn, soybeans and wheat. When tariffs increase the cost of imported fertilizer, American farmers ultimately have to absorb those higher costs or pass them along through higher food prices.
These resources don’t even tell the entire story.
The largest Canadian import into the United States is crude oil and other petroleum products. Canada is also an important supplier of electricity to several northern U.S. states. Which, of course, brings us to the price of gasoline.
Trump’s tariffs may create short-term economic difficulties for Canada, but Canada is already looking for other buyers for its exports and other sources for products it traditionally purchased from the United States. Recent reporting shows that Canadian consumers and businesses are already shifting some purchases away from American suppliers.
Meanwhile, American consumers and businesses face higher costs when tariffs are imposed on goods and materials they need.
The United States and Canada have spent decades building one of the world’s most integrated economic relationships. Our economies, supply chains, energy systems, manufacturing and agricultural markets are deeply connected.
Destroying or weakening that relationship comes with a cost — to Canadians and Americans.
So why pick a trade war with a neighbor, ally and one of America’s most important economic partners? A neighbor who sent their children to war in Afghanistan to fight and die with U.S. soldiers, a neighbor who sends volunteers every year to help us extinguish our forest fires and a neighbor who welcomed dozens of stranded U.S. airliners to land in Canada on Sept. 11, 2001.
None of this makes sense.
Tom Zirpoli is a retired educator and professor (tzirpoli@mcdaniel.edu). He writes from Westminster. His column appears on the third Wednesday of each month.