AI ethics – the thoughts of CEO Zuckerberg
There’s no show without Mr Punch. After the furore over Anthropic’s call for the AI sector to slow down and pace itself while it wrestles with ethical and safety issues, it was only a matter of time before Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg chimed in with his two cents worth. His view:
Every lab has the responsibility and incentive to move at the pace required to train its models safely, and the ability to take its own actions to ensure that happens…There is a lot of debate about slowing progress on capabilities until alignment catches up. My view is that trust and alignment are quickly becoming the most important capabilities that will differentiate agents and models.
He went on:
The reality is people won’t want to use agents that are mis-aligned with them and that don’t do what they ask, so labs have a strong natural incentive to make their models more aligned…Any lab that doesn’t focus on alignment will fall behind.
As for the need for fresh regulatory intervention, AI firms already face significant liability if their models cause harm, so they have a strong incentive to prevent this as well, he argued. Take responsibility for your own tech, he said:
Meta delayed shipping Muse for several months to focus on safety and security. We didn’t call for everyone else to do this before we would. We just did it as part of our day-to-day work because it was clearly the right thing for people and for us.
Amodie’s idea for independent evaluators and advisors to work alongside the AI firms is just industry best practice, reckons Zuck:
[Meta] already does this today in several areas because it helps produce better work. Other labs can just do this too.
. But he concedes:
In general, it would be helpful for there to be a larger and more diverse ecosystem of evaluators.
He concluded:
Committing the significant majority of compute towards serving people rather than racing towards recursive self-improvement is one of the best ways to ensure we develop this technology safely. Meta has made this commitment and other labs can do this as well. I believe the key to building a positive future for everyone is maintaining the right balance of power. This is within our power to do.
My take – that’d be no, then?
He said what?!?
I would rather they make fun of me than to wake up one day and discover that someone used Claude to kill a bunch of people.
Dario Amodei, CEO, Anthropic.
The wait for digital success at WeightWatchers
The ongoing saga of digital transformation at WeightWatchers has been a sorry tale over the years, one of bold ambition and thwarted delivery time and again.
The firm managed to survive the pandemic and lockdowns which wiped out its traditional in-person meetings operating model. Its latest unwelcome model disruptor has come with the rise of medial fat reduction pills and injections. If you can lose weight with the prick of a needle, who needs Weightwatchers?
It’s an unhelpful thesis, insists the firm’s Chief Operating Officer Jon Volkmann:
We really feel like there is a bit of a false narrative out there that you can just give someone these medications and send them on their way and have them have a successful journey. I think that shows up most prominently in the adherence data that you hear from big pharma, that people on average are staying on these medications for about six months. And within those averages, there’s people that are coming on and stopping right away because they’re experiencing side effects. There’s people who can’t afford to stay on the medication or experience a work disruption and no longer have insurance coverage.
What Weightwatchers is providing is “really high touch, high quality obesity focused care within a clinical setting”, he says:
Our members have unlimited access to their clinician to do video telehealth appointments that they need to do that are solely focused on weight care and then able to follow up with them. They’re able to log side effects. They’re able to meet with registered dietitician to get someone a prescription and send them on their way…It is, I would say, a more nuanced message than a lot of people are competing on price right now. If you’re trying to reach people through D2C and they’re scrolling through a social platform, price is obviously an easy thing to communicate, to try to get people interested in your platform.
But what we’re really trying to do is let people know that we are the place. We’ve been in business for over 60 years, solely focused on weight care, and that we are the place to come if you want to have a successful and supportive clinical weight care journey.
Of course there’s an AI angle here, but not necessarily a good one as CFO Felicia DellaFortuna admits:
AI is a competitor. There is a lot of places for people to get information about their nutrition.
But WeightWatchers has focused on updating its tech foundations:
One of the ways for us to kind of stem that bleed…is we have up-leveled our technology. One of the hard parts of having a debt burden like we had at WeightWatchers for so long is that we weren’t able to invest in the tech and so the tools became dated. And if you have like a new app (AI) that is immediately giving you all of this information, it’s like, ‘Why WeightWatchers?’ Well, the program works, right? That is fantastic and check on that. But we did need to make a lot of the tools more easily usable. So we have introduced quite a bit in terms of AI in our app. So now if you take a photo of your food, we are able to give you the points value just in one click…Our AI is pretty amazing and it can figure that out and give you the points.
We’ve also introduced voice tracking so you can just talk into your phone and that is available to you. We have barcode scanning now. So if you are at Trader Joe’s and you just want to scan a product, that immediately tells you the points intake. And so all of these tools, we do think are going to be very impactful in getting folks then able to track right and then getting the best on their weight loss journey.
My take – the saga rumbles on like an empty stomach.
He said what?!?
We told you all along this moment might happen.
Sam Altman has bad news for the greedy on Wall Street – the IPO’s off for now!
Why data center builders are hugely mis-understood…
Stuart Thompson, Head of Global Real Estate at Equinox, has seen a change in his life:
No-one really knew what I did before. I would tell them ‘data centers’ and they look at me confused. I would say, ‘It’s Internet infrastructure’, try to come at it a different way.
But now:
Everyone knows what the data center is today, or at least they think they know what a data center is today… there’s a lot of misinformation out there.
A lot of that is related to the drive for data center expansion to meet demand that is proving hugely controversial when it’s announced that a vendor is about to dump a ruddy great data center in your neighborhood. Thompson reckons that Equinox has a good reputation for managing community relations well:
Fortunately, we’ve got 30 years of a track record of doing what we said we would do relative to the communities that we’re in, relative to the power providers that have trusted us with that critical capacity. So we’re leveraging that experience to make sure that we’ve got a healthy pipeline of development going forward.
That’s not to say that Equinox is immune to the impact of the protests around data center expansion:
Is it an issue? For sure…But before we ever put a shovel on the ground, we are in that community, talking to local authorities, talking to the community, and talking to the power providers to make sure that we’ve got a strong relationship. We know what the community needs and that we are being a good partner. We’ve set up really local infrastructure businesses, where we’ve got local managing directors who speak the language, who have really good ties to the community.
And we are really running critical applications inside of our four walls. We’re not just cranking out massive data centers with one or two customers in it. There’s really, really critical applications that are running people’s critical apps that help them live their daily lives.
Overall, there is still a major messaging problem for the data center builders, he concedes:
The industry as a whole really needs to do a better job of telling the story. Again, I think there is a lot of misinformation out there. We need to do a much, much better job of getting our story out there. And we fully recognize that. And we’ve got a really good strategy of doing that, both on the ground in the communities we work in and nationally.
My take – I still wouldn’t want a data center in my backyard.
He said what?!?
We were warned again of existential risk to the human species and what fills us with dread is the crushing weakness of our politics against the massive stakes of our times. Tech titans dig bunkers while warning us the new intelligence they’re creating risks human extinction.
Jon Ossoff, Georgia Senator and potential Democrat Presidential candidate.