Ohio Supreme Court blocks citizen-led Wilmington data center referendum from appearing on ballot
COLUMBUS, Ohio —
A ballot initiative that would have allowed Wilmington residents to potentially weigh in on new regulations for data centers will not be appearing before voters this fall.
This comes as the Ohio Supreme Court ruled on Friday that the Clinton County Board of Elections was legally justified this summer in blocking the referendum.
The final ruling was 6-1, with the majority maintaining that the referendum would have allowed citizens to sue data centers over zoning violations, which is not permitted under Ohio law.
“While (the Ohio Revised Code) provides ‘municipal corporations’ independent power to ‘abate any nuisance and prosecute’ any person responsible therefor, it does not authorize a municipal corporation to essentially delegate that power to its citizens by way of a civil action,” the justices wrote in their majority opinion. “The proposed ordinance at issue here purports to create a new cause of action and therefore is not within the municipality’s power to enact; consequently, relators have not established a clear legal right to compel the board to certify relators’ proposed ordinance for placement on the November 3, 2026 general-election ballot.”
The majority went on to add that complainants failed to provide sufficient legal rationale that the referendum would create “a new cause of action” that did not fall under the existing precedent, as those backing the ballot initiative had previously argued before the court.
However, in his lone dissent, Justice Patrick Fischer said that the decision should not be left up to individual election boards to determine which citizen referendums make the ballot, and that such a decision should be determined solely by a judge.
“Even if the proposed ordinance is outside the municipality’s authority to enact, that is a legal determination that must be made by the judiciary in the postenactment process,” wrote Fischer in his dissenting opinion. “We have long held that courts lack the authority to judge the legality of proposed legislation. See Pfeifer v. Graves, 88 Ohio St. 473 (1913), paragraph five of the syllabus. ‘Just as we cannot stop the General Assembly from considering a proposed law, we cannot allow an elections board to interfere in the legislative process initiated by the people.'”
Justice Jennifer Brunner, the court’s lone Democrat, concurred with the majority while also noting that she was sympathetic to the arguments made by Fischer. However, Brunner noted that “there is public expense for elections that will ultimately be invalidated” at a later date, leading to her to side with the majority. Brunner added that courts should continue to retain their existing power to serve as checks on local election boards if they overstep their authority.
The proposed regulations come as Amazon is seeking to build a massive new data center within Wilmington, a project that has been marred by repeated legal setbacks and intense resident backlash over the past year.