My work as a belief psychologist and parapsychologist often puts me in situations where I encounter people who hold unusual and sometimes dangerous beliefs. I started noticing something in the town where I live: People who identified as spiritual seemed unusually susceptible to conspiracy beliefs.

This got me thinking about the New Age wellness movement, which, according to the Global Wellness Institute, is now a $6.8 trillion global industry that includes brands like Gwyneth Paltrow’s GOOP. It’s also visible in individual figures like Russell Brand, whose own political and religious views have shifted markedly rightward in recent years. I wanted to look at this connection between spirituality and conspiracy belief a bit further, and after some research, I realised somebody had beaten me to the punch and already come up with a term: conspirituality.

Canadian Hip Hop

Charlotte Ward and David Voas looked at spirituality and its relationship with conspiracy beliefs in their 2011 study titled The Emergence of Conspirituality. They used the term “conspirituality” in an academic sense. Ward and Voas saw conspirituality as a reflection of spiritual people’s dissatisfaction with the political system, which kind of backed up my thoughts on the subject.

I also wanted to include another aspect: the idea of moral purity, in this context, a gut sense that something is unnatural or contaminated. But when I did the study, I hadn’t realised that Ward framed conspirituality as part of a hopeful spiritual awakening, rather than something that needed scrutinising. The term itself is actually credited to a Canadian hip hop group, Conspirituality, back in 2004, fused conspiracy theory with spiritual and esoteric themes as part of the music, rather than Ward and Voas’s later psychological concept.

The Paper Behind the Paper

While researching further for this post, I found there was some controversy surrounding the original 2011 paper. According to Hannah Dick (2026), the paper was mainly written by Ward, and Voas, an eminent sociologist in the area, was brought on to give it academic clout. It turned out that Ward might actually be involved in conspiritualist-type behaviours herself. Ward and Voas refer to believers as “clients” in their paper, and don’t scrutinise the antisemitic tropes underpinning some of the conspiracy theories they cite, including Icke’s “lizard people” theory.

Dick’s article, published that April, flagged this problem. Beres, Remski, and Walker had actually got there first, uncovering Ward’s insider status on their Conspirituality podcast back in 2022, and again in their 2023 book. I hadn’t picked up on any of it, and with hindsight, I really should have. But just because the term conspirituality has been contested doesn’t mean it’s any less valid. In fact, it probably makes it all the more interesting.

It’s Not Just Spirituality Causing the Problem

To explore this more, I did a study with my colleagues Chris Howard and Stu Rimmer, published in the Journal of Scientific Exploration. We used a number of scales to ask 240 people how spiritual they were, how strongly they believed in COVID-19 and other conspiracy theories, how much they valued purity, and where they sat politically. Spirituality, purity, and right-wing political views together were strong predictors of COVID-19 conspiracy belief. But we also tested whether purity and political orientation explained that relationship. The answer was partly yes: Political orientation explained it for COVID-specific beliefs, but not for general conspiracy belief. Purity, though, explained it in both: the one factor that mattered no matter which conspiracy belief we were looking at.

How It Connects

The variables could also be working serially, rather than in parallel: spirituality seems to nudge people toward valuing purity, which pushes their politics further right, which in turn predicts conspiracy belief. As far as I know, this is the first study to test that mechanism empirically, though it’s worth remembering our design was correlational, so we can’t say for certain it’s actually causal; that would need experimental work to confirm.

Why This Matters

These findings have implications for public health messaging, for example, around cholesterol-lowering statins. Recently, false information has been making the rounds, claiming that statins cause dementia. A recent meta-analysis (Westphal Filho et al., 2025, pooling 55 studies and 7 million patients) showed that statins reduce dementia risk rather than causing it. So where does this belief come from? Not the evidence, clearly.

Part of it is that gut sense of purity itself isn’t purely innate; wellness marketing spends a lot of energy selling the idea that certain foods, medicines, or interventions are “unnatural” or “contaminated,” priming exactly that response. Same story with the mRNA-vaccine-causes-autism claim, which a February 2026 study also found no evidence for.

Spirituality Essential Reads

It’s not just an issue in wellness circles either; Dick’s study looked at a very different, more religious group (the Church of God Restoration) and found that believers in this group who are driven by purity beliefs refuse the vaccine, too, matching our study.

Isn’t It Ironic, Don’t You Think?

It would appear that Ward wasn’t studying conspirituality from the outside; she was living it. A term that came from a Canadian hip hop group is now being used to examine the world she was part of, whether that’s investigative podcasters using it to dismantle wellness grifters or empirical studies like mine looking at it from a psychologist’s point of view.

But it was Beres, Remski, and Walker’s podcast, the very people who use the term “conspirituality” regularly, who did the digging that uncovered Ward’s insider status in the first place. Another level of irony? Thanks to Alanis Morissette, I never know what irony is anymore.

I went into this study without realising how tangled the term’s own history was, and in hindsight, I probably should have caught it. But that doesn’t change what the data actually showed: It’s purity and politics, not spirituality alone, driving conspiracy belief.