Israeli politicians have abandoned past diplomatic fictions, and are now fully embracing far-right alliances amid their collapsing levels of public support from the West, argues John Clarke 

The readiness of Israel’s political leaders to cultivate working relationships with far-right parties in other countries has been gathering attention for several years. These forms of cooperation have included parties that are associated with virulent antisemitism. 

Given the Zionist claim to represent Jewish self-determination, links with such vile political movements are jarringly ironic and deeply disturbing. This ugly meeting of minds has now reached the level of friendly relations with an Austrian party with a decidedly Nazi past. 

As reported by El País, Israel’s foreign minister, Gideon Sa’ar, has declared his government seeks ‘a substantive, open and sincere dialogue’ with Austria’s far-right Freedom Party (FPÖ). This party has existed since 1956 and former SS soldiers were among its founding members. Jewish community leaders in Austria have pointed out that it ‘still includes numerous supporters of the ideology behind the extermination of six million Jews between 1933 and 1945.’ 

Sa’ar’s announcement was no casual observation. He announced this budding relationship following a meeting he attended at the European Parliament headquarters. This had been organised by Patriots for Europe, an alliance of far-right parties. Benjamin Netanyahu’s Likud party participates in this coalition with observer status and does so at the request of the notorious Spanish Vox party. 

The single-minded nature of the pursuit of links with European far-right forces is striking and it is clear that it represents a political priority that the Israeli leadership is ready to pursue in the face of significant opposition. We learn that ‘Saar’s remarks now point to a likely normalization with the FPÖ, despite Austria’s Jewish community’s outright rejection of the party.’ 

Alliance of the right 

As Israel moves along a harshly right-wing trajectory, jettisoning the trappings of liberal democracy as it works to complete its colonial project, it is entirely understandable that its political leadership should seek a place in an international alliance of the right. 

In August, The New Yorker took note of the degree to which Israel’s leaders are reevaluating their priorities when it comes to international support. Right-wing parties ‘which espouse virulently Islamophobic platforms’ are ready to conceal their antisemitic roots and forge alliances with Israel as a garrison state and a line of defence for Western interests. 

The Israeli leaders are well aware that such allies further their alienation from liberal allies and traditional bases of support among Jewish communities in other countries. Indeed, ‘the country’s diaspora minister, Amichai Chikli, lamented the ‘post-national’ cosmopolitanism of Jewish communities in the West, arguing that it was better for Israel to court far-right activists in Europe, who are supposedly closer to ‘ordinary people’ and who may find common cause with Israel in their animus toward Muslim immigration and political Islam. 

That right-wing parties in Europe and in other parts of the world are natural allies of Israel is quite obvious but the Netanyahu government is obviously ready to bet that these forces can form an effective base of support for it and sustain its assault on the Palestinians and its role as a regional aggressor. 

As Israeli representatives cultivate their relationship with Patriots for Europe, they can only be aware that the Trump administration seeks to strengthen the very political forces with which they are allying. A string of Trump officials has railed against the supposed moral decay of a liberal-dominated Europe. As Carnegie Europe has put it ‘this U.S. administration’s aim toward the EU is clear: weaken it, or even break it, by seeking regime change in favor of the far right.’ 

The US State Department, moreover, is doing all it can to promote the growth of the European far right, even handing out grants to NGOs, universities, and businesses that promote what is described, with very little subtlety, as ‘common Western civilisational heritage.’  

Israel’s leaders see themselves, with considerable justification, as a part of that ‘heritage’ and they calculate that the alliances they are forging will provide them with the support and protection they need. 

It must also be acknowledged that, while the base of support for far-right parties in Europe is very considerable, the right-wing course that Israel is on enjoys truly massive support within its population. Israel’s move to the right reflects the development of a society that has been shaped by the settler-colonial project that is integral to it. 

The spectacular role of Itamar Ben Gvir and Bezalel Smotrich within Israel’s political life is well-known internationally. The best claim to political restraint and moderation that the former can point to is his advice to his followers to stop chanting ‘Death to Arabs’ in favour of ‘Death to terrorists.’ However, this dreadful pair only reflect something that goes much deeper in Israeli society. 

Writing in The Palestine Chronicle, Ilan Pappé charts the course that Israel is on. He points to an earlier time when ‘the self-declared “only democracy in the Middle East”, branded itself a generous peacemaker who is willing to resolve the problem by offering “concessions” over its supposed right to the whole of historical Palestine.’ 

From this false posture, Israel has gone over to the open pursuit of ‘a more theocratic, nationalist, racist and even fascist Jewish state; one that stretches all over historical Palestine, including the West Bank and the Gaza Strip.’ Unsurprisingly, the present Israeli leaders are ‘highly impressed by Israel’s new allies in the world, be they the leaders of the far-right parties in the West or far-right movements in countries like India.’ 

Countering isolation 

The days when the fiction of a peace-seeking liberal democracy could be advanced with any level of credibility are gone. The horrors of the Gaza genocide, the ethnic cleansing of the West Bank and the brutal assaults on Lebanon, Syria and Iran have made such subterfuge impossible. Israel is increasingly turning to its natural allies on the right to enable its crimes and counter its growing isolation. 

The Israeli leadership knows that popular sentiment has shifted against it, even within the Western countries that have functioned as its sponsors. It is aware that a major base of support within the populations of those countries is becoming less and less sustainable. Even within Jewish communities outside of Israel, the loss of support has been enormous and it is likely to get even worse. 

Yet the hard-right political leadership of Israel has little time for compromise or appeasement. It knows that its readiness to support parties that are rooted in Nazi genocide can only intensify the alienation dramatically. In the case of the FPÖ, Israel is moving ahead with its alliance building even though it will send shock waves through the Austrian Jewish community. 

As recently as 2023, ‘the board of directors of the Jewish Community of Vienna, the Kultusvorstand, unanimously reaffirmed its cordon sanitaire towards the Freedom Party (FPÖ) and refused to have any political contact with its representatives, even if they held public office.’ The open embrace of this pariah by the Netanyahu government can only inflame the deeply held feelings that prompted the refusal to deal with the party. 

For its part, the FPÖ engaged in a minimal display of soul searching and contrition. It’s leader, Herbert Kickl, issued an apology, not for the party’s Nazi roots, but for ‘Austria’s role in the Holocaust and [he] sought a new relationship with Jewish communities.’ This farce was enough for Gideon Sa’ar, who promptly declared that ‘Israel views these statements as an important and positive development [that] make it possible to open a substantive, open and sincere dialogue aimed at deepening our understanding of his positions and commitments.’  

The utter political cynicism at play here is mind-boggling and it confirms the place that Israel holds within the rising right-wing international alliance. Though the Zionist project has always been an exercise in colonial dispossession and a component of a broader imperialist drive to dominate the entire region, it used to present itself in terms of liberal democracy and a pretended commitment to a ‘peace process’ with the Palestinians. 

Those days are now well and truly over and Israel has discarded the polite fictions of the past. Racist fanatics like Ben-Gvir and Smotrich aren’t rogue elements but authentic expressions of Zionism’s political trajectory. From earlier democratic pretences, the Israel of today has evolved into a society that embraces the ideas of the international far right with gusto. 

This move to the right has now gone so far that mainstream Israeli politicians openly embrace political forces that have clear and obvious links to the Nazi past. However much this alienates and offends and, despite the ugly historical baggage it carries, this emerging alliance is fully understandable. Genocidal Israel and the racist ideology that sustains it have found their natural home on the far right. 

Before you go

The ongoing genocide in Gaza, Starmer’s austerity and the danger of a resurgent far right demonstrate the urgent need for socialist organisation and ideas. Counterfire has been central to the Palestine revolt and we are committed to building mass, united movements of resistance. Become a member today and join the fightback.