Republicans are betting on cultural and security debates, but polling points to a concern that could reshape the midterm campaign.
Republicans want to make crime, immigration and transgender rights key issues in the U.S. midterm election campaign. But the economy remains more important to voters, and the Republican Party’s advantage on other issues is often small.
As stated by CNN
This week, former Florida congressman Matt Gaetz responded on X to a man who wrote that he would be voting for Democrats for the first time:
I hate war too. But Democrats want your kids to become transgender.
– Matt Gaetz
Transgender rights were a prominent issue in the 2024 presidential campaign. Republicans continue to bring it up in their ads, but a CNN poll found the party has only a slight edge among registered voters: 37% to 32%. Just 25% of respondents said the issue was extremely important to their vote – the lowest share among 11 issues.
Immigration and crime don’t outrank the economy
Half of voters say immigration is extremely important to their vote. At the same time, the gap between Republicans and Democrats on this measure has narrowed. In 2022, 65% of Republicans and 30% of Democrats said immigration was important; now the figures are 60% and 50%, respectively.
In the CNN poll, Republicans lead Democrats on immigration, 41% to 36%. Other polls, however, show Democrats in the lead.
The authors suggest that Donald Trump’s aggressive deportation measures may have drawn more Democrats’ attention to immigration. At the same time, the decline in illegal border crossings, which Trump claims as an achievement, may make voters feel that the issue is less urgent. The decline began under Joe Biden’s administration.
Republicans have their biggest advantage on crime among the issues considered: 40% to 29%. But only 41% of registered voters say it is extremely important. Trump also points to falling crime as an argument, although the decline began under the previous administration.
The economy is voters’ top priority
Sixty-eight percent of voters say the economy is extremely important to their vote. That figure is close to the highest level recorded before the 2022 midterms. In most other election campaigns this century, it has remained below 50%.
According to CNN, 73% of respondents disapprove of Donald Trump’s handling of the economy, and 80% disapprove of his handling of inflation. Against this backdrop, Democrats lead Republicans on the economy by seven percentage points, even though the issue has traditionally favored Republicans.
Republicans are also criticizing Democrats over streamer Hasan Piker. He has been mentioned, in particular, in a campaign against Abdul El-Sayed, a Michigan Senate candidate who appeared with Piker during the primary. Meanwhile, a New York Times and Siena College poll found that six in ten likely Michigan voters had no formed opinion of Piker, and 54% had never heard of him. Among independent voters, only 13% expressed an opinion.
Polls suggest that Republicans’ efforts to focus the campaign on cultural and public-safety issues have not yet pushed the economy into the background. Voters’ views on the cost of living and inflation remain among the party’s biggest challenges heading into the midterms.