The recently disclosed information that MOL and the Ukrainian company Naftogaz had signed a memorandum of understanding caused quite a stir: they intend to examine whether a fuel storage facility for Ukrainian energy supplies could be built on Hungarian territory near the Hungarian-Ukrainian border. Magyar Nemzet has investigated the matter.

The prime minister spearheaded government opposition once the news broke. In parliament, Péter Magyar stated that the negotiations had already begun under the previous government, and criticized MOL for failing to inform the cabinet. On the very same day, Minister for Economy and Energy István Kapitány declared in his speech that “this will not be built under the TISZA government.”

István Kapitány, Minister for Economy and Energy (left), and Zsolt Hernádi, CEO of MOL. Photo: MTI/János Vajda

Based on a telephone conversation with Zsolt Hernádi, MOL’s chairman and CEO, Prime Minister Péter Magyar told parliament that MOL had already begun negotiations on the fuel storage project with the approval of the Orbán government. It was not made clear during which parliamentary term this alleged agreement had taken place—it may even have been before the Russian-Ukrainian war—but the prime minister also published the text of an SMS message that, according to his account, he sent to Hernádi following their telephone conversation, which continued late into the night:

What MOL has done is completely unacceptable, and from now on I expect MOL to treat the Hungarian State as a 25% shareholder.”

At this point, however, it is worth pausing for a moment, because the political debate and the corporate law issue are not the same thing. The state is not a 25% shareholder in MOL, but holds only 15.24%. According to data from the Budapest Stock Exchange updated on September 2, this corresponds to 124.9 million shares. The picture is somewhat more complex, however, as the Hungarian State also holds a single Series B share with preferential voting rights, which grants it special rights as stipulated in the articles of incorporation. This does not mean, however, that the state could veto every single MOL investment project.

As a publicly traded corporation, MOL’s business decisions are made in accordance with corporate governance rules by the authorized bodies; furthermore, the general meeting of shareholders also has certain powers. According to the documents from MOL’s general meeting of shareholders, the special state rights associated with the Series B shares are tied to specific issues. However, a preliminary review of a fuel storage facility in Hungary does not automatically fall under these rights.

Photo: MTI/Purger Tamás

The Hungarian State is a major shareholder, but this stake alone does not make MOL a state-owned enterprise. Its representative may participate in the General Meeting, vote, exercise the special rights granted to it, and even influence corporate governance. However, it is another matter entirely whether the state can dictate to MOL’s management whether it may conduct certain business negotiations.

Furthermore, according to MOL’s articles of incorporation, a single shareholder or group of shareholders may exercise no more than 10% of the voting rights.

Against this backdrop, it is unclear why MOL would have had to consult with the FIDESZ or TISZA government at all regarding the investment proposal.

Should MOL actually decide in a few years to build the fuel storage facility, various regulatory procedures, permits, and reviews may be required, depending on the scope of the investment and the exact technical details. MOL itself points out that the review of regulatory requirements is still pending. Although the state can already act as a regulatory authority at this stage, this does not yet mean that the government’s political position is being enforced. The fact that the government does not support an investment project does not automatically mean that a required regulatory approval can be lawfully denied, but there is an even more important unresolved question.

There is one aspect that cannot be classified as a shareholder right: national security, which was mentioned immediately after the news broke. Hungarian legislation treats certain actors and institutions involved in the strategic stockpiling of crude oil, gasoline, diesel, and kerosene as critical organizations and infrastructure.

Bálint Ruff. Photo: MTI/Szigetváry Zsolt

The review of foreign investments with regard to national security is conducted by the Constitution Protection Office, which informs the minister responsible for overseeing the civilian national security services of the outcome. This minister is currently Bálint Ruff, who may also issue a negative decision if the investment violates Hungary’s security interests.

However, this does not imply a blanket veto on any investment project on grounds of national security.

The law on the review of foreign investments applies to specific legal transactions and foreign investors. Therefore, it is important to clearly understand Naftogaz’s exact role: it matters whether the Ukrainian company is merely involved in the project as a business partner or acquires ownership, operational, or any other rights that fall within the scope of the law. Magyar Nemzet asked MOL about the business structure but received no response yet.

In other words, if MOL, as a Hungarian company, were to build a fuel storage facility as part of its own investment, the state would not automatically have the right to prohibit the investment on grounds of national security. This is because the mere fact that Ukraine is at war with Russia does not automatically make it a prohibited business partner. However, if the project also involves legal transactions that qualify as foreign investment, the security review can already have a de facto blocking effect.

Related article

MOL Takeover Talks for Serbian Oil Company Reportedly Enter Final Stage

MOL Takeover Talks for Serbian Oil Company Reportedly Enter Final Stage

The parties have until September 30 to resolve the ownership and sanctions issues surrounding NIS.Continue reading

Via Magyar Nemzet, Featured image: Naftohaz Ukrajini/Wikimedia Commons