Investors say robust oversight will be crucial following the Financial Conduct Authority’s (FCA) move to implement the UK Sustainability Reporting Standards (UK SRS) on a comply-or-explain basis. 

The regulator announced its decision on Wednesday to drop mandatory reporting for climate-related S2 disclosures, citing market feedback that suggested smaller firms might struggle to comply, while retaining comply-and-explain for non-climate-related disclosures and Scope 3.

The UK SRS, and reporting made against the framework, is aligned to the International Sustainability Standards Board (ISSB). A permanent comply-or-explain approach exceeds the reporting reliefs provided by the ISSB. 

Several investors voiced frustration with the move to Responsible Investor, adding that the new regime should be sufficiently robust to ensure ‘explaining’ companies do not get a free pass to not disclose.

“Disclosure on material issues is not a burden on companies,” said Edward Mason, head of public markets engagement at Generation Investment Management.

“It protects investors and enables them to properly assess a company’s value creation model. Mandatory ISSB reporting would make the UK market a more attractive destination for capital in a world of growing sustainability challenges.” 

Aegon Asset Management is also “obviously disappointed with the outcome”, said Miranda Beacham, head of UK responsible investment.

“However, the momentum behind this reporting is good and we will maintain our engagement with companies to ensure we are still getting information we need to make decisions regarding the climate risks,” she added.

Investors pointed to the regulator’s newly launched consultation on an additional technical note, which sets out expectations for applying the comply-or-explain approach.

“The FCA now needs to put guardrails in place so that ‘explain’ is not a free pass,” said Lucas Penfold, head of sustainability reporting at Impax Asset Management.  

“Companies should give a clear rationale for not reporting and say when and how disclosure will follow, so investors can prioritise stewardship activity. We’d also like the regulator to monitor closely how the ‘explain’ option is used.”  

Similarly, Jo Walker, group director of responsible business at Royal London, said “success of the FCA’s approach will depend on the quality of the disclosures and, crucially, the level of challenge from the FCA on explanations provided where companies do not comply”.

The ISSB has declined to comment on the FCA decision. 

Quality of reporting

James Alexander, CEO of the UK Sustainable Investment and Finance Association (UKSIF), said the shift away from mandatory climate reporting was “disappointing” but he still hopes to see high-quality reporting under the regime.

“This will depend on several factors, including the signals sent by the regulator’s upcoming technical guidance, which is anticipated to set further expectations for issuers’ disclosures,” he said.

“Going forward, the regulator should assess the quality of disclosures by listed issuers under the UK SRS, and if needed, review its approach.”

Others, however, welcomed aspects of the finalised regime. 

Richard Manley, chief sustainability officer at Canada’s CPP Investments, said he supported the FCA “maintaining the ambition of the medium-term destination”. 

Manley added that the use temporary transitional reliefs for Scope 3 and non-climate-related S1 disclosures, rather than permanent carve-outs, “is a pragmatic way to give preparers time to build the systems, data and capabilities needed to deliver high-quality, decision-useful disclosures”.

Impax’s Penfold also welcomed the FCA’s commitment to review the sustainability reporting framework for asset managers, adding that clarity will be essential on how the UK SRS fits within that.