With Japan rising in power and China rising in doubt, the Indo-Pacific is witnessing unforeseen strategic shifts

Japan, the land of the rising sun, is fast emerging as a geopolitical actor in the Indo-Pacific region. Long known for its pacifist constitution and renouncement of war as a State policy, the fast-shifting balance of power and geopolitical upheavals appear to have induced Japan to re-examine its defence and security policy.

Japan has been depending on the United States for its security since the end of the Second World War. The US has not only set up military bases in Japanese islands but also has promised to protect the country from any nuclear attack by adopting a doctrine of Extended Nuclear Deterrence (END).

But it appears that there is growing trust deficit in Japan and questions have been raised in recent years about the reliability of the END.

While Japan has been traditionally against nuclear weapons and has a policy of non-possession, non-development and non-introduction of nuclear weapons on its soil, nuclear proliferation around its borders have deeply affected Japan and encouraged its strategic community to re-examine its stand on nuclear weapons.

China refuses to be part of any arms control negotiations and has been rapidly modernising and expanding its nuclear and missile arsenal.

opinionMore from Opinion

Russia has frequently dangled its nuclear weapons amidst the Ukraine War. North Korea has not only built a nuclear and missile arsenals, it has been periodically testing missiles in close geographical proximity of Japan.

Significantly, Russia, China and North Korea, all three, have deep historical animosity and grievances against Japan. Russia was the first Western Power to have been defeated by the Japanese army in early 20th Century.

Subsequently, it was Russia that joined the Allied Powers during the Second World War and captured four islands of the Kurile Island chain, which still remain a serious territorial dispute between Russia and Japan.

China has deep historical grievances rooted in atrocities committed by Japanese military forces during the first and second Sino-Japanese Wars and World War II. Korea, which was a colony of Japan for about 35 years, continues to have grievances against issues such as “forced labour” and “comfort women”.

While South Korea and Japan have been taking steps to resolve old issues, North Korea’s hostility against Japan is not hidden. It may be underlined that vast majority of people in South Korea now support the idea of developing an independent nuclear deterrence.

More importantly, all these three countries are geopolitical partners today. North Korea does not exist peacefully with Japan. Japan fiercely opposes Russia’s War against Ukraine. And China aggressively challenges Japanese sovereignty over Senkaku Islands in East China Sea. The 2026 Defence White Paper of Japan clearly puts these three countries as the country’s core national security threats.

These developments coupled with US President Donald Trump’s pressure on Japan to spend more on defence and acquire the capability to defend itself, have deep impact on the strategic community in Japan.

It is widely believed that Trump would not protect Japan from any nuclear attack from North Korea, for instance, at the cost of potential North Korean attack on US territory.

When President Trump referred to the “Pearl Harbour” incident during a press conference with Japanese Prime Minister Sanae Takeichi, it was certainly not a joke.

Japan has already been taking incremental steps to bolster its defence capabilities.

It has crossed the constitutional limit of defence expenditure which was one percent of the GDP. It has decided to participate in “collective defence” activities, as and when required.

Tokyo is now developing a second-strike capability which is more than self-defence. Under President Trump’s pressure, Tokyo now is considering an expenditure of 3.5 per cent of GDP on defence.

Tokyo has plans to develop next generation naval assets, unmanned surveillance systems, cyber and space defence capabilities and many more. It has also embarked upon defence modernisation and even collaborating with the UK, and Italy to develop sixth generation stealth fighter jet.

Most consequential development is, however, the statement by Japanese Defence Minister Shinjiro Koizumi that it is crucial for Japan to debate the issue of nuclear weapons and nuclear-powered submarines “without taboos”. He has expressed the desire to discuss the need for revising the “three non-nuclear principles” and acquiring nuclear-powered submarines.

This call for a domestic debate on the country’s nuclear policy will certainly have wider ramifications in the Indo-Pacific. It is coming in the backdrop of majority of Japanese people now endorsing use of nuclear reactors for electricity generation, which had faced popular backlash after the Fukushima disaster of 2011.

The energy crisis created by the wars in Ukraine and Iran and the blockade of Strait of Hormuz and partial blockade of Red Sea has unsettled many energy-importing countries, including Japan.

While the repercussion of nuclear energy generation by Japan would have little adversarial impact internationally, revisiting the nuclear principles in Japan is bound to generate strategic stir in the Indo-Pacific and beyond.

Japan’s constitutional constraints, complex domestic politics and anti-nuclear sentiments of the common people in Japan will continue to be road blocks for emergence of Japan as a nuclear weapon power.

However, the geopolitical headwinds and the repercussions of wars in Europe and West Asia along with the perceived threats posed by three nuclear-neighbours of Japan may open the door for a metamorphosis of Japan’s post-Second World War strategic positions, policies and thoughts.

For long, “Japanophobia” in East and Southeast Asia discouraged Japan from playing an active role in the security and defence sectors in the Indo-Pacific. Japan, through its economic engagements, investments and developmental assistance has perhaps been able to remove the regional fears of a militarily strong Japan.

In the meantime, “Sinophobia” has taken root in certain parts of the Indo-Pacific.

An economically strong Japan intends to be a militarily powerful country and rise of a militarily powerful China has raised questions about consequences of its economic embrace with the Indo-Pacific countries. The region seems to be in for unforeseen strategic shifts.

(The writer is founder chairperson of Kalinga Institute of Indo-Pacific Studies and editor, ‘India Quarterly’. Views expressed in the above piece are personal and solely those of the author. They do not necessarily reflect Firstpost’s views.)