One question guides David Gundale, principal of Open World Learning Community in St. Paul, through the new world of generative artificial intelligence: “How do we make sure that we are creating an environment where kids are getting smarter and more creative?”
There are some guidelines that St. Paul Public Schools shares with families and staff around responsible use of AI. They direct students to think of AI tools “like a really smart study buddy” and provide educators with a practical framework for leveraging AI tools in the classroom while maintaining high standards of privacy and ethics.
But in practice, educators often are the ones leading the charge of creating healthy relationships between AI and their students.
“As a society, teachers are sort of one of the first lines in it, just like parents are,” said Tom Totushek, who’s been a teacher at Open World, a sixth- through 12th-grade public school, for 25 years. Open World is a magnet school within the St. Paul district with about 450 students.
When it comes to guidance, “districts are slow to act, policymakers are even slower,” Totushek said.
Conversations on AI
In the past few years, there have been district-level work groups, digital information nights for parents and PTA meetings co-hosted by students, where community members shared their thoughts, feelings and experiences.
The district board will adopt an “Artificial Intelligence Governance Policy” by the end of the 2027-28 school year, according to the district’s “Board Initiated Goals Governance” model. It will address “the safe, ethical, human-centered, equitable, environmentally responsible, and instructionally meaningful use of AI across teaching, learning, critical thinking, workforce readiness, accessibility, data privacy, academic integrity, staff support, and district operations,” the model says.
District officials say they want the policy to cover a lot of bases.
“We’re thrilled that the board has invited us to engage with students, staff, families, and the community to design what we want that AI blueprint to look like for all of our students,” said Rachel Larson, SPPS’s executive director of teaching and learning. “We will design how we ensure the highest levels of safety and precautions for students using AI, while simultaneously making sure that they are leaders, critics, and creators of it as well.”
That includes seeing how AI could help staff focus more on instruction and students and less on tasks and resources, Larson said.
Nationwide, 37 states and their departments of education have now official AI guidance that schools can use as a blueprint, the Associated Press reported in August. Minnesota is one of them.
Principles in state guidelines
Among the guiding principles offered by the state for school districts, and available on the Minnesota Department of Education’s website:
• Have an agreed-upon vision and set of values in determining how to use AI.
• Make it people-centered. “People, not machines, should be at the center of decision-making,” the department says.
• It should help advance equity. It’s use should ensure “fair access to technology and acknowledging the potential presence of biased data within AI systems.”
• Safety, ethics and effectiveness. “Data privacy, security and content appropriateness should be primary considerations,” according to the department.
• Continuous improvement. “Decision-makers need to understand how AI models work so they can anticipate limitations, problems, and risks,” the department says.
Shortcuts
Gundale said he is not naive to how AI tools can lure students in with a promise of shortcuts.
Grades are a big motivator, he acknowledges, and AI presents an easy fix for procrastinators. So, conversations continue in individual advisories and classrooms within Open World Learning. The principal said he was “surprised about how grounded our students were” and how critically they thought about the topic.
To further encourage critical thinking when it comes to AI tools, Totushek started last school year off with an activity: He gave his students an open-ended problem to grapple with. After the class came up with solutions, he put the problem into the AI chatbot ChatGPT to show his students, in real time, its limited ability in answering the prompt.
The exercise demonstrated that they had come up with some better solutions and taught them how to re-prompt the chatbot to improve its answers, he said.
“Getting them to critically engage with the generative AI, understand what it’s good at, what it’s not good at is important,” Totushek said. He plans to repeat that exercise this school year.
Student access to AI
District-wide, AI use is not allowed for students in pre-kindergarten through eighth grade.
SPPS is a one-to-one district – meaning all students receive a district-provided computer or tablet. On those devices, AI search tools like Google Gemini, Chat GPT and Claude are blocked. And, while AI may be embedded into standards-based learning apps, students cannot access AI independently, Larson said.
“I think what we want is for our parents and students to trust that while we engage with students, and the use of these emerging technologies, that safety and data privacy are the first priority for us and that that is our responsibility to protect that,” Larson said. “And so with that, parents get to choose the use of open AI at home. But while they’re with us at school, we connect it to the learning standards and the digital citizenship skills that we want our students to learn.”
Ninth- through twelfth-grade students can use Google Gemini with the direction of a teacher, but all other AI search options continue to be blocked. And, since students cannot access their personal Google accounts, all Google Gemini use goes through their school accounts, which have their own safety parameters, according to Larson.
That allows control of the quality and access to what AI provides, she said.
“We want (parents) to trust that students are safe and that we’re teaching them how to be safe leaders, critics and creators of it and not passive consumers,” Larson added.
Digital citizenship
In compliance with the Children’s Internet Protection Act, the district provides all pre-kindergarten through 12th-grade students with lessons on digital citizenship, online safety and privacy, and appropriate online behavior.
District staff are offered digital learning coursework, which focuses on best practices for both staff and students using AI.
Larson said one district partner is the nonprofit Common Sense Education, at commonsensemedia.org, which provides schools and teachers with K-12 resources on digital and AI use.
“So we’re shifting from looking at what AI is, and we already have the safety parameters in place, but how do we also make sure that we intentionally build in the skillset of AI, so that our students are empowered to use it ethically and responsibly in their lives?” Larson said.
That includes preparing them for AI use they will encounter in the workforce.
“And we look forward to conversations about what does that continued intentionality look like,” Larson said. “Because we want to make sure we’re not prohibiting the learning of how students engage critically and creatively and become leaders with AI because they’re needing that workforce readiness and preparation to live in the world of emerging technology.”
‘New tools’
In their individual roles, both Gundale and Totushek avoid the binary categorization of AI as “bad” or “good,” intent on teaching students a nuanced understanding of what they call “new tools.”
Methods of learning have never been stagnant, Totushek said. In his quarter-century at Open World Learning, he’s had a front-row seat to technological evolution within the classroom.
“When I was in school, it was the calculator,” he recalled. “How is the calculator going to change math education? And so as generative AI has come around, the perspective of seeing multiple technological paradigm shifts is really important. You have to get the kids to understand that it is just another tool. Using it so that they’re not outsourcing the thinking is what’s really important.”
Educators should embrace this evolution and finding new ways to encourage honest creativity, Totushek said.
One way this has been done at Open World Learning, Gundale pointed out, is that teachers now ask to see multiple drafts of written work from students.
“That’s not good or bad,” Gundale said. “It’s just naturally what we always have to do in order to keep student thinking and development at the forefront.”