In this week’s business roundup: The former Olde Tymer’s Cafe building gets a makeover in preparation for a new restaurant, while Durango-based Higher Purpose Homes is recognized as the Economic Development Council of Colorado’s Company of the Year for its work building affordable housing in the Four Corners.
New restaurant coming to former Olde Tymer’s site
The former Olde Tymer’s building at 1000 Main Ave. in Durango is undergoing massive renovation in preparation to become a new restaurant. (Tyler Brown/Durango Herald)
The former Olde Tymer’s Cafe building, a well-known downtown Durango landmark at 1000 Main Ave., is undergoing renovations to make way for a new restaurant.
Owner Sean Dugan purchased the building in 2024 in hopes that he would be able to renovate it and lease it to a new tenant. However, after seeing some of the structural issues with the building, he decided its interior and infrastructure needed a complete overhaul, pushing back the timeline for the project.
“I spent time in the property and looking at all the long-term issues,” he said. “It became abundantly clear that it really needed to get a full face-lift, and so it took time.”
He said the project is likely to be completed by the end of the year and confirmed that a new restaurant will be moving into the space. While he declined to share details about the restaurant, he confirmed he will not be reopening Olde Tymer’s Cafe, despite rumors suggesting otherwise.
Instead, Dugan hinted at the possibility of opening a restaurant that pays homage to Olde Tymer’s, though he said nothing has been finalized.
He will also be taking on a partial ownership role of the restaurant when it opens.
“I put so much heart and love into this rehab. I didn’t want to just stick it with someone. We’re forming a partnership, and we’re going to work together on putting the restaurant in,” Dugan said.
Poor infrastructure had long plagued Olde Tymer’s Cafe and its previous owners. In 2023, former owner Mark Cavelli told The Durango Herald that the cost of renovating the building was one of the reasons he decided to close the restaurant.
“It’s got some big problems inside this week that need to get taken care of, like the floors need to be remodeled,” Cavelli said in a 2023 story published by the Herald. “The floors are rotting a little bit, the hood vents are too small, and the swamp coolers are too small to keep it cool in the summer.”
Dugan, who runs Dugan Production Corp., a natural oil and gas company based in Farmington, said he is excited about the building’s future once renovations are complete. As someone who frequented Olde Tymer’s when he was younger, the project has become a passion project for him.
Dugan hired FCI Constructors, Inc. and SEH, Inc. to complete the remodel.
Higher Purpose Homes named Company of the Year
Higher Purpose Homes started in 2022 to create affordable housing solutions for residents in The Four Corners. (Durango Herald file)
Durango-based Higher Purpose Homes was awarded the Economic Development Council of Colorado’s Company of the Year award for its work building affordable housing units in the Four Corners.
The company specializes in building 2,000-square-foot panelized homes and recently began operating out of its new facility in Bayfield. The facility is expected to allow the company to produce approximately 40 units per year.
Higher Purpose Homes was recognized for its off-site construction approach, which aims to address the region’s housing shortage while creating a new manufacturing industry in Southwest Colorado. The company constructs floors, walls and roofs inside a controlled facility while site work takes place simultaneously, allowing homes to reach the dry-in stage in days rather than weeks. The process also reduces construction waste and helps crews work within the region’s shorter building seasons.
“Higher Purpose Homes is tackling a real barrier to economic growth: the shortage of attainable housing,” said Kim Woodworth, EDCC Executive Director in a news release. “Its model brings together local entrepreneurship, manufacturing jobs and a faster way to build homes.”
In February 2025, the Colorado Office of Economic Development and International Trade selected Higher Purpose Homes for the state’s Innovative Housing Incentive Program. The company is eligible for up to $590,000 in performance-based reimbursements tied to the development of 95 housing units over three years, including about 30 deed-restricted affordable homes.
Higher Purpose Homes co-founder Nick Lemmer said it was an honor to receive the award and be recognized alongside larger companies, including Lockheed Martin and Ball Corp., which have received the award in previous years.
“It kind of took me by surprise, and I don’t know if it’s fully sunk in,” he said.
Lemmer, an automation engineer, founded Higher Purpose in 2022 with co-founder Ethan Deffenbaugh, who oversees the business side of the company. The pair set out to help address housing challenges in the Four Corners.
Lemmer said he is excited about the company’s involvement in a 15-unit housing development planned for 2027.
“We’re starting to really break ground on these partnerships with developers and builders, which is super exciting,” he said. “Now that we have the capacity to do it, we can really start ramping up.”