PATI MyanmarMyanmar refugees boarding a ship to return home at the naval base in Lumut, Perak, under an earlier phase of the repatriation programme. (KDN pic)
KUALA LUMPUR: The Malaysian Bar is seeking the High Court’s permission to challenge the government’s plan to repatriate about 5,000 Myanmar refugees and asylum seekers.

The Bar is also seeking a temporary halt to the repatriation pending the court’s decision on its application.

The attorney-general is opposing both the Bar’s application for leave to commence judicial review and its bid for a stay.

The Bar said allowing the repatriation to proceed could render its judicial review nugatory, as the return of the individuals to Myanmar would be irreversible.

In its judicial review application filed on Sept 28, it said those facing repatriation included Rohingya and children recognised by the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) as refugees or asylum seekers.

It contends that those returned could face discrimination, persecution or other harm, and said Malaysia is bound by the customary international law principle of non-refoulement, which prohibits the return of individuals to a country where they face persecution.

The Bar also argues that returning children would be inconsistent with principles under the Convention on the Rights of the Child, read together with the Child Act 2001, including the requirement to act in the best interests of the child.

However, its immediate application before the court is narrower – to preserve the status quo while Justice Norliza Othman decides whether to grant leave for the judicial review.

Lawyer M Ramachelvam, representing the Bar, submitted today that the balance of convenience favoured a stay, as any harm caused by the repatriation could not be undone.

However, senior federal counsel Nurhafizza Azizan, appearing for the attorney-general, argued that the stay application was premature.

Relying on a recent Court of Appeal decision, she submitted that the court could only consider a stay application after leave for judicial review had been granted.

As leave had yet to be granted in this case, she said, the High Court had no basis to consider the stay application at this stage.

Norliza will deliver her ruling on Oct 22.

Collin Arvind Andrew, Moganasundari Mahalingam, Ameerul Radzi Azlan and Shahlini Sree Kumar also appeared for the Bar.

Federal counsel Afiq Zainal Abidin also represented the attorney-general, while Marcus Lee and Samantha Koh appeared for the Human Rights Commission of Malaysia as amicus curiae, or friend of the court.