According to the report, Israel has committed a “mediacide” and calls for the International Criminal Court (ICC) to investigate and prosecute “direct and public incitement to commit genocide by government officials and media figures”.
Truth Under The Rubble: Media In The Time Of Genocide found that Israel used “three interconnected patterns” that have “facilitated [genocide] and obstructed accountability”.
Francesca Albanese’s report is set to be formally presented to the UN Human Rights Council on October 26.
READ MORE: Zionism is racism debate ‘unhelpful’, says Scottish Green co-leader
According to Albanese, the three patterns are: the systematic killing of Palestinian journalists; an information regime of propaganda and censorship within Israel; and international media amplifying Israeli narratives while silencing Palestinian voices.
‘An apocalyptic time for journalists’
PROFESSOR Des Freedman told the Sunday National: “This [report] is really important because it connects all these different dimensions through which a genocide is executed.”
Freedman said: “[This is] such an apocalyptic time for journalists. We have never seen these levels [of journalists killed] before in Iraq, in Vietnam, in the Second World War.”
The UN report found that Gaza is the “deadliest conflict ever recorded for journalists”, and since October 2023, “Israeli forces have killed nearly 300 journalists and wounded more than 400”, including 70 media workers who were “killed as reprisal for their work”.
“Many were wearing press vests and helmets,” Albanese found, but instead of “enabling the Israeli army to identify and protect media workers”, their press identification “facilitated their targeting”.
(Image: Brian Lawless/PA Wire)
Israeli soldiers themselves were among more than 300 “primary and public sources” cited, with one soldier saying: “Whoever writes an article or works on a laptop is like someone carrying a Kalashnikov and attacking us.”
Media workers in Gaza “know” they have “become a target”, the report found, quoting journalist Youmna El-Sayed: “Wearing our press vests seems like putting ourselves in danger.”
Journalists’ homes have been targeted by Israel to such an extent that they “struggle to rent homes or offices in Gaza due to landlords’ fear that they would be targeted”.
Families of media workers have also been killed, “around 710 relatives [of journalists have been killed] since October 2023, 436 in the first four months alone”.
The report cites “an emblematic case” of Al-Jazeera Arabic’s Gaza bureau chief, Wael Al-Dahdouh.
On October 25, 2023, an Israeli air strike on Nuseirat camp killed Al-Dahdouh’s wife, his 15-year-old son, his seven-year-old daughter and his one-year-old grandson.
“I was aware of being a target,” Al-Dahdouh said, “but I would not think they would have targeted my family.”
Albanese found that Israel has “systematically recast Gaza-based journalists as Hamas operatives” and that “the systemic justification of these attacks evidences an intent to target protected media workers”.
One example given in the report was the targeted killing of prominent Gaza-based journalist Anas al-Sharif, who was killed in a drone strike in August 2025 alongside four colleagues.
Leading up to the attack, an Israeli IDF spokesperson, Avichai Adraee, had accused al-Sharif of being a member of Hamas, a claim he refuted: “They accuse me of being a terrorist because the occupation wants to assassinate me morally.”
In the aftermath of al-Sharif’s killing, the Committee to Protect Journalists (CPJ) regional director Sara Qudah said: “Israel’s pattern of labelling journalists as militants without providing credible evidence raises serious questions about its intent and respect for press freedom.”
‘Destroy, kill, and obliterate’
A SUBSTANTIAL section of the UN report is centred on Israel’s strategy of information warfare, something the country’s prime minister has called the “battle for truth”.
Albanese, the UN Special Rapporteur on the occupied Palestinian territories, argues that the Israeli Government’s tactics include “constraining domestic and foreign media” while “spreading hateful rhetoric” to “[normalise] anti-Palestinian hatred and, at times, genocidal incitement”.
Censorship in Israel peaked in the 2024-25 period, “with 1635 articles banned and 6265 redacted in 2024 (21 interventions per day)”, while a 2023 amendment to the Counter-Terrorism Law “allows for arrests of journalists ‘for consumption’ of content deemed supportive of ‘terrorism’”.
Freedman told the Sunday National that Israeli media created “the ideological ground on which the tanks and the bombers went in”.
He said: “What’s staggering is the evidence around genocidal Israeli media. These aren’t niche online outlets; these are major news outlets like the public service broadcaster publishing some of the most vile stereotypes of Palestinians and calling for an ‘all-out assault on Gaza’ and talking about the residents of Gaza in genocidal terms.”
In March this year, steps were taken by the Israeli government to gain further influence over the public broadcaster by giving ministers “the authority to set and potentially cut the budget of the station which regularly features reporting critical of those in power”.
READ MORE: Humza Yousaf blasts ‘uninformed’ critics of plan for third party to broker indyref2
While dissenting voices are being shut down, the report argues, the Israeli government’s “communication strategy has significantly manipulated media discourse, building on a long-standing pattern of dehumanisation of Palestinians”.
The report documents numerous examples of news outlets uncritically broadcasting rhetoric by Israeli politicians and media figures.
Among them are calls for Gaza to be “wiped off the face of the earth”, to “erase Gaza”, and reporting statements referring to Palestinians as “monsters”, “a cancerous growth” and that “there are no civilians [in Gaza]” just “two and a half million terrorists”.
Israel’s Channel 14 aired statements including: “erase Gaza, don’t leave a single person there”, as well as calls for a “Holocaust”, including “gas chambers” and to “destroy, kill, and obliterate”. Albanese argues that some of the statements aired on Israeli television “meet the threshold” for “direct and public incitement to genocide”.
Western media gave ‘green light’ to Israel’s military
“THE genocide has exposed long-standing ideological biases in media coverage,” the report argues, “including across Western traditional media and major digital platforms”.
The UN Special Rapporteur reserves significant criticism for the UK’s BBC and US-based outlets CNN and The New York Times, saying “the media outlets examined here were selected for their presumed authoritativeness and objectivity”.
The report argues that these major media organisations helped “obscure” Palestinian suffering by repeating unverified Israeli claims, minimising historical context and privileging Israeli official sources.
Faisal Hanif, from the Centre for Media Monitoring (CfMM), told the Sunday National: “The issue is not simply whether Gaza is covered, but how stories are framed, whose voices are prioritised and whether claims made by powerful actors are adequately scrutinised.”
The senior analyst said: “Systematic omissions and unequal framing have obscured Palestinian suffering and weakened public understanding,” while the phrase “Israeli victims” was used “11 times more frequently than language describing Palestinian victims”.
CfMM’s 188-page 2025 report, BBC On Gaza-Israel: One Story, Double Standards, found a “pattern of bias, double standards and silencing of Palestinian voices”.
Hanif said: “These findings raise serious questions about impartiality and whether audiences are receiving a complete picture of events.”
The UN report has also scrutinised BBC reporting on Gaza, saying that “internal editorial guidelines show how such influence translates into practice”.
READ MORE: John Swinney brings back misogyny bill with pledge for new criminal offence
As her prime and first example, Albanese uses the BBC style guide to illustrate Israeli influence on Western media.
The report describes how the BBC’s editorial guidance shapes how the conflict is reported, noting that its style guide “omits Gaza from the occupied territory” and refers to the West Bank and Gaza as “disputed” territories despite established international law.
It further criticises BBC guidance distinguishing settlement outposts from settlements, arguing that Israeli governments have frequently “protected and retroactively legalised illegal outposts” despite their initial lack of authorisation.
Similarly, leaked New York Times guidance cautioned against using terms like “genocide”, “ethnic cleansing” and “occupied territory”, and only “in very rare cases” to use the word “Palestine”.
Freedman told the Sunday National: “We’re so often told that ‘our fearless media are all about holding truth to power’ and what they should have been doing is challenging those official Israeli narratives.
“[Western media gave] a green light, a nod and a wink to Netanyahu and military leaders [when they implied with their coverage] that ‘while we may not like some of what you’re doing, we understand why you have to do it’. That is not an acceptable position for Western media to have adopted.”
For Albanese, the lack of “historical context and legal frameworks” was also a key omission by Western media outlets.
“Media references to the Nakbah, to decades of occupation and related brutalities, to the illegality and continued settlement expansion and to the 19-year blockade of Gaza are absent or minimised,” Albanese says, “with October 7, 2023 presented as the origin of hostilities”.
The report cites US-based outlet CNN as directing its journalists to “remind our audiences” that “Hamas attacks on Israeli civilians caused the conflict”.
While media outlets have also “repeatedly amplified unverified or false Israeli claims”, despite the concerns from the organisation’s own staff members, staff at CNN have accused the organisation of “journalistic malpractice” over Gaza coverage.
The misinformation Albanese cites includes Israel’s description of “attribution of civilian deaths to Hamas’s tactics rather than to Israeli military actions”.
Between October 2023 and August 2025, Albanese said: “The New York Times referred to ‘human shields’ used by Hamas 176 times and [the] BBC 81 times.”
While in “more than 100 documented incidents”, BBC presenters “dismissed assertions that Israel was committing genocide” while not reporting Israeli leaders’ “genocidal statements”.
The report also argues that repeated references to “Hamas-run hospitals” and “hospital shields”, alongside unverified claims that Hamas operates from hospitals and other civilian sites, have helped lend credibility to narratives used to justify attacks on protected medical facilities.
These claims are particularly important, Albanese argues, because it “is one of the Israeli government’s principal legal justifications for its genocidal campaign in Gaza, including [as a legal defence] before the International Court of Justice”.
Albanese found that Western media “camouflaged” Israeli responsibility in headlines, with the BBC most criticised for this, having been found to do so in 83% of its headlines, according to media analysis.
The “striking example” provided in the report was of Hind Rajab.
Five-year-old Hind Rajab was killed alongside her family while attempting to flee Gaza City two years ago. The car they were in was found riddled with 335 bullet holes from rounds fired by Israeli military personnel.
The BBC headline still reads: “Hind Rajab,5, found dead in Gaza days after phone calls for help.”
READ MORE: Hind Rajab was killed two years ago today. Will her voice ever spark empathy?
Where there is a “serious risk of genocide”, Albanese says, “states have a legal requirement to ‘at a minimum’ not ‘permit their own institutions to obscure that risk’”.
The patterns documented here, the special rapporteur argues, persisted “despite repeated warnings from journalists, courts and United Nations bodies”, raising “serious questions” as to the state’s “compliance with those obligations”.
Investigate and prosecute
IN the closing pages of her report, Albanese says: “The evidence examined in this report describes a single, integrated phenomenon that, in many respects, constitutes mediacide.”
The report defines mediacide with reference to Gaza as “the destruction of the media’s essential function in the information environment surrounding the occupied Palestinian territory”, and calls the process “intrinsic to the ongoing genocide”.
Albanese says: “Genocide depends not only on the destruction of human beings, but also on the destruction of the political, moral and evidentiary conditions that make that destruction visible, intelligible and contestable.”
Among its recommendations, the report urges the UN General Assembly to establish an independent international mechanism to “consolidate and preserve” all evidence of “crimes against journalists and the information environment in the occupied Palestinian territory”.
It also calls for support for Palestinian journalists and media organisations to be released from unlawful detainment and to receive protection, resources and assistance.
The report urges states to investigate and prosecute attacks on journalists under international law and to impose consequences on those responsible.
Albanese finally calls on the prosecutor of the ICC to investigate “direct and public incitement to commit genocide by government officials and media figures as part of the ongoing Palestine investigation”.
Freedman said: “I hope that the media will look at this report in more sober terms, but I expect that they will fall back on their tried and tested tropes of dehumanising Palestinians and attacking those who seek to humanise them and to put their points of view forward.
“And I think we deserve journalism that is much better than that.”