War

Sing

Season 1

Episode 4

Editor’s Rating

4 stars

****

Nick and St. John spar during arbitration — revealing the weak links inside both firms.
Photo: Justin Downing/Sky/HBO

After last week’s melodrama, I appreciated this week’s focus on lawyers. War is at its most interesting when distanced from the familiar beats of a divorce story — the kid, the shouting, the regrets — and focused on its original characters. A trial, and all the work that leads up to it, is an inherently dramatic event; there’s a reason why it’s portrayed in fiction so often. When the lawyers have more than professional merit at stake, the litigation becomes a mirror to reflect their personal crises. This is about where we’re at halfway through the season. As the prospect of the courtroom becomes ever more inescapable, our characters are revisiting the question of what kind of lawyer they want to be.

Do they want to be nice, cozy, and bearded, the kind of guy who helps others? Or do they want to be mean, cunning, and icy, the kind of guy who knocks ice-cream cones from children’s hands? In my last recap, I mentioned that Nick, the protagonist of this week’s episode, was too conspicuously good. I imagined some dark side of him would be revealed soon enough. But with “Sing,” War doubles down on Nick’s nice-guy characterization. He is so nice that Cathcarts, and particularly Smallwood, see him as Taylor & Byrne’s weak link. It’s not just them; Nick himself is riddled with insecurity, and even Serena doubts his ability to hold his own against Smallwood. I’m relieved that we’re spared any explanatory flashbacks — the “this is why he’s like this” sequence that has become so ubiquitous in contemporary film and TV — and instead rely on character behavior. James McArdle is excellent at channeling Nick’s integrity and doubt.

Nick and St. John go head to head in the final stage of arbitration. Taylor & Byrne arrive at the Cathcarts offices still high off breaking the prenup. The firm expects to be able to ask for as much as half a billion pounds for the settlement. But as soon as he sits down in front of Smallwood, Nick is destabilized. Smallwood greets him with a nickname, Singer, then presents him with a renewed settlement offer — 50 percent of Morgan’s net worth, which, given the movement of his Zephyr shares, comes down to “only” £45 million. Nick is so stumped he can barely speak. He manages to stutter a refusal, but it’s a struggle he can’t shake off for the rest of the day. At lunch with an angry Carla, he can’t defend himself. He can barely defend himself to Serena, who wants to know what the hell came over him.

Sitting in one of Cathcarts’ regal chairs, surrounded by all that dark wood and swirling a dose of Scotch, St. John is only missing a cat to fully transform into a Bond villain. He tells Beatrice and Schill that he worked with Nick when he was just out of college. When Nick went to present his first big case to clients and the board, he was paralyzed by stuttering, and the firm hired a vocal coach who taught him to sing through the stammer, hence the moniker. To Beatrice, who has already shown some dissatisfaction with Cathcarts’ dirty work, Smallwood is acting like a bully. Like Nick, Beatrice wants Morgan and Carla to settle, presumably so everyone can go back to living their regular lives. Beatrice is Nick’s reflection at Cathcarts, while Smallwood’s counterpart is Serena. The latter pair wants to go to court, where an unambiguous winner will be declared.

But litigation could be financially ruinous to Taylor & Byrne, as Nick learns from a disgruntled Bernard (Steve Furst), the firm’s finance guy. Because they need all hands on deck to fight Cathcarts, the firm hasn’t taken on any cases other than Carla’s, and it has no money coming in. It’s true that Morgan will look bad in court, but it’s also true that Cathcarts’ pockets are deep enough to drag out the case for as long as it needs to. Still, Serena won’t settle just to settle. Even after Nick has been up all night taking the measure of all they stand to lose, Serena doesn’t see why they should throw in the towel. “Be stronger,” she reprimands him. “Take control of this — get past whatever school-reunion bullshit you and St. John have going on.” Their only option is to win and to win fast.

A universally acknowledged truth about bullies is that they bully because they have their own shit going on. Smallwood has the tone and manner of someone who is mean to others before they can be mean to him, and that’s how he goes about doing his job. He shows no sign of easing up on the bullying tactics when arbitration resumes. After double-checking their numbers, Nick counters the £45 million with £315 million, which Cathcarts rejects outright. Smallwood argues that Morgan doesn’t have that much money right now and they can’t make a deal based on future predictions. Even Rachel Grann points out the “paucity” of Cathcarts’ opening figure, but it’s not enough to help Nick out of his rut. Smallwood keeps digging: He singles out Nick’s stuttering, brings up the vocal coach, and makes such acerbic comments that Serena and Grann have to interject. Serena takes over the argument on Taylor & Byrne’s side, and Grann instructs everyone to come up with a percentage of Morgan’s shares of Zephyr they can all agree on so they can move forward. On their way out, and in so many words, Beatrice essentially apologizes for Smallwood’s behavior to Serena (and even congratulates her on the baby). She doesn’t actually say the words “I’m sorry,” but she does say it’s not personal — Smallwood is finding the weak spot and holding on to it, just as Beatrice taught Serena to do.

Beatrice is not the only person reconsidering the nastiness of the proceedings; a series of small incidents leads Morgan to question Cathcarts’ cruelty. At their old apartment, looking for some documents needed for the “restructuring” of Zephyr stock, Morgan is stopped in his tracks by an old picture of himself with Carla. He hangs around to watch Carla light a cigarette outside their former home and even texts her, asking if she wants to grab a drink in the neighborhood (Carla lies, with some sadness, that she’s on the other side of town). The next morning, as they ride up the elevator to arbitration together, she asks him how he could be so cruel to serve her the papers at her premiere. Coming back down that same elevator after arbitration has stalled again, she reminds him of how they talked about Zephyr during their walks in Normandy. This Normandy cottage is referred to so often it’s more of a character than Bella Croft.

All this reminiscing convinces Morgan he should be playing “straighter, fairer.” He writes a letter to Carla and intends to settle for £300 million. But Smallwood is like a dog with a bone, and desperate to retain control of his client, he tells Morgan about Carla’s honey trap, how she was in on it with Flora. Amazingly, Morgan doesn’t question how Smallwood found out about this or how he can be sure. He is possessed by the spirit of Carla when he simply acquiesces to the version of events presented to him by his lawyer, whose own determination to go to court is becoming more suspicious. Correct me if I’m wrong, but it seems like lawyers should do their best to stop their clients from having to suffer through trial, rather than push them toward it.

Something is roiling under the surface of Smallwood’s harshness. Until this episode, I was convinced his life revolved around appearing at Morgan’s hotel room at the exact moment he was needed, like a summoned spirit. But he has his own life too; Saeed spots him looking distressed at a club, arguing with a young man who leaves him in a huff. Saeed himself is coaxed into ditching his partner to join Molly’s lawyers’ night out after she tells him that one of Michael Ancker’s executive assistants — or EAs, as they say — will be there. Smallwood’s personal tiff, however momentous it may seem to us, is just a blip in Saeed’s night. His real coup is the information he gets from hooking up with Noah, Ancker’s executive assistant’s executive assistant.

Earlier, Johnny noticed that Ancker likes all of Morgan’s posts on Zephyr, but Morgan never interacts back. Instead, Gillian — who, as it turns out, is Zephyr’s CFO — is all over Ancker’s likes. At first, Nora and Michael wonder if this means Morgan is considering selling to Ancker, but if he did, half would go to Carla; besides, Saeed’s intelligence-gathering digs up a much more menacing plot. Noah tells him Ancker wants to buy Zephyr but received a message to “hold fire” on an offer until Zephyr has “cleaned house.” As Saeed puts it, just because Morgan doesn’t want to sell doesn’t mean no one at Zephyr wants to sell. Morgan is transferring his shares to Gillian under the impression they will be retransferred once the divorce has been settled, but with majority control of the company, Gillian can sell to Ancker if she wants to — and if her Zephyr activity is any indication, she loves Michael Ancker. This is all great news to a discouraged Nick, who suggests Saeed “get wrecked more often.” In a last burst of courage, Saeed asks Nick to give him more credit: He’s not just some “graduate”; he’s good at his job.

Nick meets up with Budgie to plan their next move. They can file a Mareva injunction, which would stop Morgan from moving his assets, that same afternoon. But that will almost certainly lead them to court, which, Budgie reminds Nick, Taylor & Byrne can’t afford. However, Serena’s stern talking-to got to him, and next we see Nick: He’s letting Smallwood know they’re filing the injunction, risks be damned. They briefly revisit negotiation, but Smallwood’s best and final offer is “only” £110 million, a disgusting amount of money that is still a far cry from the half-billion Taylor & Byrne promised Carla. (Remember mediation, when that number was enough to make everyone happy?) Smallwood attacks Nick’s virility, saying he’ll be publicly humiliated when his wife has to bail him out again in court. But little does St. John know that Nick is a wife guy. He is glad to be married to a woman who rocks. And mimicking Saeed’s still-a-bit-drunk speech, he tells St. John he’s not “the graduate” he once knew, either. He’s a real lawyer with a real wife and a real case! When he gets home and tells Serena he didn’t back down — that he filed the injunction, told Smallwood to shove the hundred million, and said they’re going to court — she is proud of him. Let the war commence in earnest, and let the good guys win!

The episode could have ended there, and it would have done so satisfyingly. I, for one, am hyped to see Nick come around full circle and wipe the floor with St. John’s smirk. But War suddenly remembers that Johnny is supposed to be a mole of some consequence. So far, his scheming hasn’t been all that productive, and with Saeed inching into the case, Johnny is more likely to get benched with Molly, who’s mostly there to say lines of expository dialogue, bless her. So Johnny gets proactive. He scopes out Bernard, who asks him to get a signature from Carla on a litigation form. When he goes to pick up the paper in the printer, he notices a statement detailing the firm’s profits and losses, which he promptly copies, photographs, and sends along to Schill. Carla vents to Johnny about not recognizing Morgan as the man she married, and Johnny encourages her to keep up her fight. They make out finally but stop before things get any more serious. Then she signs the form.

• Carla continues to be a frustrating character. She is so mad at Nick and Serena for choking when Cathcarts offered a low figure, but when she sees Johnny — who works for Nick and Serena and is supposed to be back at the office, busting his ass in her interest — all her moodiness suddenly dissipates. Is he really that dreamy? That charming?

• Speaking of Carla’s lunch meeting with Nick and Serena, that’s one of two instances this week when we see our divorcés getting papped. People take photos of Carla in the restaurant as she storms off, and later, at least one standby photographer catches Morgan leaving the apartment he used to share with Carla.

• St. John tells Morgan that Carla paid Flora to have sex with Morgan, but that’s not true — at least not explicitly so. Taylor & Byrne gave her some money so she would sign the NDA and stay quiet about the whole thing, but Carla herself never gave Flora money. Flora has been absent for a couple of episodes now; as the plot escalates, I imagine she will reappear soon.

Sign Up for the Vulture Newsletter

Entertainment news, for the pop-culture obsessed.

Vox Media, LLC Terms and Privacy Notice