As the global fresh apple market shrinks, some countries inevitably lose ground. I previously wrote about the winners and the very different reasons behind their success here. Today, I turn to four countries that have lost the competition: China, Chile, France and Poland. The outcome may be similar, but each country has a very different story behind its decline. I’d like to highlight that lower apple exports are not necessarily bad news. In some cases, they reflect a shift towards more profitable crops.

To distinguish structural changes from individual harvest fluctuations, I compared average annual exports during 2016–2018 with those recorded in 2023–2025. Four countries in focus account for the largest absolute reductions: China lost approximately 346,000 tonnes, Chile 222,000 tonnes, France 180,000 tonnes and Poland 148,000 tonnes of their fresh apple exports. Together, these four countries exported 896,000 tonnes less per year, comparing the two three-year periods.

These countries share one outcome, but the reasons behind their losses are fundamentally different. China faces increasing pressure from production costs, changing international market requirements and its enormous domestic market. Chilean growers have been moving capital away from apples towards more profitable fruit crops. France has experienced a prolonged deterioration in price competitiveness and market access. Poland has struggled to adapt its export-oriented production structure following major disruptions to traditional destinations.

China: rising costs, changing market requirements and an increasingly difficult export business

China remains the world’s dominant apple producer, harvesting approximately 47-49 million tonnes annually according to their own estimates, and accounting for more than half of global production. So, the fresh exports are a tiny part of that gigantic production.

Fresh apple exports from China declined from approximately 1.26 million tonnes in 2016–2018 to 913,000 tonnes in 2023–2025 – a loss of 346,000 tonnes, or 27.5%. Share of China in the global fresh apple exports declined consequently from 14.2% to 12.3%.

“When China walks into the room, profits walk out” – this well-known phrase ironically is no longer the case for fresh produce sector, most of it anyhow. I’d just that Egypt has taken that place now. Moreover, the Chinese fresh apple industry discovered that it was not very easy to compete on the global market, as its own labor market has tightened.

Production costs have been rising, particularly in traditional apple-growing regions due to labor shortages, an ageing farming population and lower orchard productivity comparing to the EU and South Africa. At the same time, relatively low profitability has encouraged the removal of less productive orchards, while agricultural land-use policies have restricted new plantings in certain areas. Increasing productivity can offset part of these costs, and China has made considerable progress in replacing older orchards with new and more productive but higher yields alone do not guarantee export competitiveness.

International apple markets have also become more demanding and wants newer varieties besides consistent appearance, colour, size, firmness, shelf life and reliable deliveries. Buyers have more choices with emerging new exporters entering the market and thus, which put pressure on China.  

When higher production and marketing costs are combined with increasingly demanding quality requirements and almost no real price growth, the profitability of supplying foreign markets comes under pressure. Some producers may find the domestic market more attractive, particularly when the additional investment required to meet export specifications is not adequately rewarded, which is often the case in China due to its enormous domestic market makes.

So, the loss of 346,000 tonnes of annual exports represents approximately 0.7% of a 48-million-tonne domestic Chinese crop – very close to a standard statistical error. Also, China could boost exports any time and, in any year, when global prices recover due to period shortages.

Chile: when cherries become more profitable than apples

Chile’s export decline is more directly connected to decisions about land use and alternative opportunities. Average annual fresh apple exports fell from approximately 753,000 to 532,000 tonnes, a reduction of 222,000 tonnes, or 29.4%. Its share of world exports declined from around 8.5% to 7.2%.

Unlike China, Chile depends heavily on export markets to sell its fruit. A sustained decline in apple exports therefore has more direct implications for the structure and profitability of the domestic industry. The clearest evidence is the reduction in orchard area. Chile had approximately 36,200 hectares planted with apples in 2015/16. According to USDA, that area had fallen to around 25,000 hectares in 2024/25, a reduction of approximately 31%.

Chilean growers have increasingly redirected land and capital towards crops offering higher expected returns, particularly cherries. Over the past decade, Chile has experienced rapid expansion in cherry production, supported by strong export opportunities in China and other Asian markets, specifically in China, where cherries from Chile for Chinese New Year become a certain symbol.

For a grower facing the decision of whether to renew an ageing apple orchard, the comparison matters. Replanting requires substantial investment and several years before full commercial production. If the expected return from cherries exceeds that from apples, maintaining the existing apple orchard becomes increasingly difficult to justify.

Apple growers have also faced rising labour costs and competition from other Southern Hemisphere suppliers. I think that South Africa’s success in this market was the main reason for lower exports from Chile.  While Chile lost approximately 222,000 tonnes of average annual apple exports, South Africa gained around 149,000 tonnes and both countries compete during the Southern Hemisphere supply season with South Africa having an edge in logistics to many premium destinations.

France: high costs and a twenty-year loss of export competitiveness

I love seeing French apples at the stores in Italy selling a double or triple price over Italian apples. These are these specialty French Reinette varieties used usually for cooking. Yet, competing with Italy on the fresh market is becoming increasingly difficult for anyone, including France, which is importing three times as many apples from Italy as exporting to this country. 

France has suffered one of the most prolonged declines among established apple exporters. Average annual shipments fell from approximately 514,000 tonnes in 2016–2018 to 334,000 tonnes in 2023–2025, a reduction of 180,000 tonnes, or 35%. Its share of world exports declined from 5.8% to 4.5%. The longer historical record is even more striking. According to FranceAgriMer, French apple exports fell from approximately 800,000 tonnes in 2003 to around 314,000 tonnes in 2023, a decline of approximately 61%.

France has lost ground in many of its traditional destinations. Over that twenty-year period, exports to the United Kingdom fell by approximately 58%, shipments to Spain by 56%, and exports to Germany by 63%.

One of the strongest explanations is France’s persistent cost disadvantage compared with other European suppliers. Labour costs was the main source of this disadvantage, especially striking compared to growers from Poland. France has also faced constraints associated with agricultural regulation and the total area devoted to apple production has declined as less profitable farms leave the industry.

Market access has compounded these difficulties. The Russian embargo introduced in 2014 and restrictions affecting Algeria disrupted important export destinations. Fruit previously intended for these markets had to be redirected elsewhere, increasing competition in European and the Middle Eastern markets. The French parliamentary investigation documented losses of approximately 80,000 tonnes in African markets and another 60,000 tonnes in Middle Eastern destinations. Italy, Poland, Türkiye and other competitors have increasingly contested the markets where France once held stronger positions. Ukraine, although a smaller competitor, has often been mentioned by French growers as the country creating additional competition in the markets of the UAE and Saudi Arabia.

France’s domestic market has not provided a strong counterbalance. French household purchases of apples declined from approximately 20 kilograms annually in 2005 to 13 kilograms in 2023, a reduction of 35%. Apples also lost their position as the country’s most purchased fruit to bananas. This combination of declining domestic purchases, high production costs and weakening international competitiveness has made the economic environment for French apple growers very difficult.

Italy provides a particularly useful benchmark because the two countries operate in broadly comparable climatic and commercial conditions, producing many of the same varieties for overlapping European and overseas markets. Yet Italy increased its average export volume by 3.6% and gained approximately 2.5 percentage points of world market share during our study period. France lost 35% of its export volume and around 1.3 percentage points of share. The difference cannot be attributed to labour costs alone. Italy also faces relatively high European production costs, but its industry has invested heavily in producer organisations, coordinated storage and packing, quality management, varietal renewal and long-term relationships with international retailers.

French apples often command relatively high prices, but premium positioning must provide sufficient differentiation to justify those prices. Where competing countries can offer comparable quality at lower cost, maintaining market share becomes increasingly difficult. France’s decline therefore reflects a combination of shrinking production capacity, a documented cost disadvantage, lost export destinations and weaker domestic demand. Unlike a temporary harvest shock, these structural problems cannot be solved simply by producing a larger crop in one favourable year.

Poland: the long consequences of losing Russia and the limits of a processing-oriented apple industry

Poland recorded the fourth-largest absolute decline in our ranking. Average annual exports fell from approximately 915,000 to 767,000 tonnes, a reduction of 148,000 tonnes, or 16.2%. However, Poland differs from China, Chile and France in one critical respect: its share of global apple exports remained close to 10.3%. In other words, the country lost physical volume but maintained approximately the same relative position in international trade.

Poland’s biggest problem was its apple industry’s dependence on Russia – situation similar to that described in a recent EastFruit article on cherries. In 2013, Poland exported approximately 600,000 tonnes of apples to Russia, accounting for roughly half of its fresh apple exports. According to traders, Russia’s actual share was probably closer to 65–70%, as Belarus, Poland’s second-largest buyer, served mainly as a transit route to reduce import taxes. Including other destinations in Eastern Europe and Central Asia reveals a clear pattern: Poland’s production system was geared towards markets with very low-quality requirements and varietal preferences that differed sharply from those in Western Europe and the Middle East.

Losing such a large destination forced Polish exporters to redirect substantial volumes towards other markets. However, this disruption occurred before our 2016–2018 baseline, so it cannot by itself explain the subsequent reduction of 148,000 tonnes although traders report that Poland continued to export to Russia even until the recent years via Moldova, Belarus and even countries of Central Asia. However, the more important issue is how Poland’s apple industry adjusted after losing its traditional market. Country had to find markets which would accept the quality which is not on par with the EU’s requirements.

Consequently, Egypt became one of Poland’s most important overseas destinations, yet shipments to the country fell from approximately 154,000 tonnes in 2021/22 to 74,000 tonnes in 2022/23. This reduction of around 80,000 tonnes reflected, among other factors, foreign-currency shortages and restrictions on import financing in Egypt, another unreliable market.  

Consequently, today approximately 60–70% of the Poland’s apple crop is used for processing, depending on the season, reflecting the quality challenges as fresh market usually offers 5-10 times higher price per kg of apples.

Four countries, four different economic problems

The most important conclusion is that the global decline in fresh apple trade is not simply a problem of insufficient demand. It also reflects changes in where apples are produced, the relative profitability of alternative crops, production and marketing costs, the quality requirements of importing countries and the ability of exporters to adapt to new commercial realities.

In a market where average real export unit values increased by only 3.9% over nine years, maintaining competitiveness requires continual improvements in efficiency and product value. Countries that cannot generate sufficient returns from such investments risk losing market share or seeing growers move into other crops.

The greatest competitive advantage is no longer simply the ability to produce large quantities of apples. It is the ability to produce the apples international buyers want, deliver them consistently, and do so at a cost that leaves growers and exporters with a sustainable profit.

This helps explain why growers in Italy – the most successful apple-exporting country over the past decade, often replace orchards even at peak productivity, switching to newer varieties that offer higher value, greater yields or stronger competitiveness. Polish growers, by contrast, tend to keep existing orchards in production for as long as possible, selling some apples on the fresh market and most to processors. Italy’s fresh apple exports are growing, while Poland’s export volumes are declining despite its much lower prices.

Fresh produce is one of the toughest businesses on Earth: high risks, rising costs, demanding retailers and very little political influence. The double standards are striking: cookies wrapped in two layers of plastic are perfectly acceptable, while a plastic punnet protecting highly perishable raspberries suddenly becomes an environmental problem.

And all this while real international apple prices have increased by just 3.9% over nine years. In an industry where costs and requirements keep rising but real prices barely move, standing still means falling behind. The winners are not necessarily those who grow the most fruit, but those who adapt faster than everyone else.

EastFruit

The use of the site materials is free if there is a direct and open for search engines hyperlink to a specific publication of the East-Fruit.com website.