NEW DELHI: The Department of Telecommunications’ (DoT) SIM-binding directive could disrupt consumers’ access to essential communication services, according to the findings of an Esya Centre study released on Monday.

It also warns that the mandate could raise operating costs for MSMEs and offer limited gains in cybersecurity. The study, titled “Rethinking India’s SIM Binding Mandate: An Empirical Assessment,” surveyed 2,033 consumers across 18 Indian cities and 353 businesses across 17 cities.

It finds that the directive could impose widespread costs and inconvenience on legitimate users. This could occur without adequately addressing major sources of contemporary cyberfraud, including phishing and credential theft.

SIM binding could significantly disrupt consumers’ access to essential communication services, particularly during international travel. Only 33 per cent of surveyed international travellers use an Indian SIM with an active roaming plan.

The remaining 67.1 per cent rely on alternatives such as local SIM cards or Wi-Fi-only access. Nearly 98.88 per cent of surveyed consumers stated that losing messaging access due to an inactive primary SIM would cause moderate to extreme inconvenience. A similarly high proportion expressed concern about losing access to internet-based calling during emergencies.

The study also highlights concerns about forced logouts and periodic re-authentication. While 97.7 per cent of surveyed companion-device users found forced logouts inconvenient, 97 per cent of consumers reported periodic re-authentication through an Indian SIM while travelling would be inconvenient. This inconvenience stems from interrupted conversations, frequent logins, and additional time needed to reconnect.

Indian businesses increasingly depend on internet-based messaging services for customer interactions and employee coordination. Among surveyed businesses, 92 per cent rely on companion-device access, and 86 per cent use the same business number across multiple devices. Restrictions on these arrangements could significantly disrupt business operations.

Approximately 78 per cent of surveyed businesses anticipate that restricting access to a single handset would be extremely or moderately disruptive. Furthermore, 83.5 per cent expect delays and operational errors. These disruptions could impose substantial financial burdens on MSMEs, with 76.3 per cent anticipating a significant financial impact.

Specifically, 60.6 per cent expect increased workplace-related expenses, 58.6 per cent anticipate additional expenditure on devices, and 55 per cent foresee increased staffing requirements.

The study questions whether SIM binding can effectively address contemporary cyberfraud. Fraud increasingly exploits vulnerabilities beyond SIM-based identity verification, such as social engineering and compromised credentials. Survey findings reveal widespread scepticism regarding the directive’s effectiveness.

Although 87.2 per cent of surveyed businesses expressed concern about SIM-related fraud, 81 per cent do not believe SIM binding will meaningfully improve security. Similarly, 59 per cent of surveyed consumers do not believe the directive would make messaging platforms safer. The study recommends a more proportionate, risk-based approach to preventing cyberfraud. This approach should focus on strengthening upstream controls within the broader fraud ecosystem, such as improving KYC processes and fraud-detection systems.

Published On Oct 27, 2026 at 12:23 PM IST

Join the community of 2M+ industry professionals.
Subscribe to Newsletter to get latest insights & analysis in your inbox.

All about ETTelecom industry right on your smartphone!