After Brazilian President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva won re-election, global commodities markets are reassessing the export trajectory of this resource-rich South American nation. Analysts say Lula’s new term will sustain the strong momentum of Brazil’s soybean exports to China while introducing new variables for rare earth development and biofuel policy.

China is Brazil’s largest trading partner. Last year, China imported $100 billion worth of goods from Brazil, compared with $38 billion for the United States — a stark gap. According to media reports, 75% of the soybeans China imported in the first nine months of this year came from Brazil. Meanwhile, Chinese electric vehicles have performed strongly in the Brazilian market and have become popular models locally.

“Lula supports soybean exports to China, and if Brazil can meet more of China’s demand, that’s bearish for US soybeans,” said Joe Davis, director of commodity sales at US futures brokerage Futures International.

Exchange-rate factors have further amplified the competitive advantage of Brazilian agricultural products. The day after Lula’s election victory, the Brazilian real plunged more than 11% intraday against the dollar, with some reports putting the drop at as much as 13%. Ole Hansen, head of commodity strategy at Danish investment bank Saxo Bank, noted that a weaker real raises the local-currency value of dollar-denominated export revenue and could prompt Brazilian producers to accelerate sales.

This week, Brazilian coffee growers, sugar mills and grain exporters sold futures to actively hedge overseas sales. Analysts believe the weaker currency has enhanced the export competitiveness of Brazilian agricultural products, with cotton and beef exports expected to benefit.

Rare Earths Development: Open but With Conditions

Brazil ranks second globally in rare earth oxide reserves, behind only China. Earlier this year, access to develop Brazil’s rare earth reserves was one of the issues in Brazil-US trade negotiations. Analysts had previously argued that if Lula’s opponent had won, the US government’s path to securing these resources would have been smoother.

Ronaldo Felix, operations director at Brazilian foreign trade consultancy Saygo Group and a mining consultant, told local media that Lula will still seek to develop the rare earths industry but will likely open development opportunities to all countries and investors, and require a higher degree of processing within Brazil rather than exporting only raw ore.

US companies have already established a presence in Brazil’s rare earths sector. Serra Verde, Brazil’s only large-scale rare earth project to achieve commercial production to date, has been acquired by US rare earth developer USA Rare Earth, with the deal completed last month. USA Rare Earth had previously secured $1.6 billion in financing from the US Department of Commerce, through which the US government holds a 10% stake in the company.

Lula has previously expressed a position of openness to all countries. During a visit to the White House in May this year, critical minerals were among the topics discussed, and Lula said at the time that related exploration investment was open to the United States and any other country.

Ethanol Policy and Fiscal Pressure

In the energy sector, in order to reduce gasoline demand and control fuel prices, Lula’s government this year raised the ethanol blend ratio in gasoline to a record 32%. Brazilian agricultural consultancy Datagro estimates that domestic gasoline prices in Brazil are currently about 35% below international levels.

However, ethanol and gasoline compete in the market, and Datagro noted that relatively low gasoline prices have depressed ethanol prices. Brazil’s fuel ethanol is mainly made from sugarcane, and local sugar mills typically produce both sugar and ethanol and can adjust the output ratio of the two within a certain range. When ethanol prices fall, mills may divert more sugarcane to sugar production.

Ethanol industry figures believe the government could further support biofuels by cutting fossil fuel subsidies, thereby improving their market access, but they do not expect such subsidies to be removed in the near term.

Although currency depreciation is expected to boost agricultural exports, the difficulties in Brazil’s agricultural sector may worsen further. Agricultural industry figures worry that if Brazil’s economic policies of high public spending continue, they could push up inflation and interest rates.

Pressure on public finances has already become apparent. In August this year, Brazil’s government debt rose to 82.9% of GDP, up from 82.6% in July and the highest level since March 2021, as spending on fuel subsidies and social programs continued to increase. Lula has also pledged to ease small-business debt, which could further inflate public debt.

High interest rates directly add to the agricultural burden. Brazil’s benchmark interest rate currently stands at 13.75%, among the highest in the world, sharply raising the cost of servicing agricultural debt. The production side is also under pressure: against the backdrop of conflict in the Middle East, fertilizer and diesel prices remain high, and Brazilian soybean and corn growers are facing both weak agricultural prices and rising production costs.

Market Impact

For the global soybean market, the stability of Brazil’s supply to China means US soybean exporters will face stiffer competition. In rare earths, Lula’s re-election reduces the likelihood of the United States quickly locking up Brazil’s rare earth resources, but the policy orientation of opening up to all investors also leaves room for capital including China’s. Maintaining a high ethanol blend ratio will continue to depress Brazil’s domestic ethanol prices and indirectly affect sugar mills’ crushing-season decisions. For investors, the macroeconomic risks posed by Brazil’s high interest rates and widening fiscal deficit may partially offset the export dividend from currency depreciation.