Retired from his role as the head of NASA for more than 18 months, former U.S. Sen. Bill Nelson still champions the agency’s accomplishments — but warns that the world’s access to space is threatened by choices by the likes of Russia and China.
“I have for years, as senator, as NASA administrator, warned people and the Department of Defense that the next major war may begin in space,” Nelson told an audience at The Economist’s Space Economy Summit, held at UCF’s Additional Financial Arena on Thursday as part of the university’s Space Week events.
He noted our society is becoming increasingly reliant on orbital infrastructure such as GPS, communications, banking transactions and missile warning systems.
“If those systems were ever targeted, the consequences would ricochet across every sector of American life,” he said.
He weighed in on China’s plans to pursue a lunar base on the moon’s south pole, and the land claims that could ensue, but of more immediate concern to Nelson was his worries about China’s “space dominance” goals.
“It’s a pillar of their national power. In the same breath as Chinese diplomats talk about peaceful exploration, public reports suggest that engineers are developing anti-satellite weapons, testing robotic servicing craft that could just as easily disable as repair, and deploying satellites that can dogfight our satellites.” he warned.
He fears the potential for escalation could rise quickly, and raised the specter of nuclear weapons entering the fray in space.
“I remain firmly opposed to deploying any nuclear weapons in space. I hold this position not only because I happen to be an optimist who views space as a great unifier, but just think what nuclear weapons can do,” he said.
He cited published reports that Russia was preparing to send six nuclear weapons to space.
“They represent a categorically different kind of threat, one capable of unraveling the space environment,” Nelson warned.
A nuclear detonation in orbit would send out a radiation pulse at the speed of light “frying satellites, corrupting electronics, and damaging any spacecraft unlucky to be in its path.”
“The explosion would pulverize nearby objects into shrapnel traveling at tens of thousands of miles per hour, and those fragments wouldn’t fall to the ground; they’d stay in orbit, spreading like an expanding minefield that could take centuries or perhaps even longer to clear,” he said.
This in turn could bring on the “nightmare scenario” called Kessler Syndrome.
“It’s a runaway chain reaction in which debris destroys satellites, creating more debris, destroying more satellites, and so on, until entire regions of orbit become unusable.” he said. “Compromise safe access to Earth orbit, and you sacrifice all the things that you’re familiar with: Earth observation, climate monitoring, and most communications.”
This would be a worse-case scenario, but yet Nelson touts his optimism, and his raising warning flags now he hopes will stave off such a future.
“Our dream of space has always been bigger than any one president, policy debate, or moment in time,” he said. “The missions NASA launches, the questions we ask, and the discoveries we make are not partisan pursuits. They are national and international ones, reflecting on a sustained commitment that must transcend administrations.”
He said he hopes the cooperation that remains in place today with the likes of the International Space Station, where Russia and the U.S. and its partner nations work alongside without conflict.
“This is a story—as one of astronauts and cosmonauts, of engineers and diplomats, together proving that we can choose a different path, to understand why cooperation, not confrontation, must remain a pillar of our long-term strategy in space,” he said.
While Russia and the U.S. have had something to build on dating back to the Apollo-Soyuz mission of the 1970s, Nelson said China so far has not shown the desire to reach that level of cooperation.
“That is going to be the challenge with the Chinese space program,” he said. “I’ve tried. I’ve tried as senator to open the door to China, and what I would get is vacuous stares in return.”
He recalled a time he spoke to the then Chinese ambassador to the U.S. after having run into him at a Sunday morning brunch, thinking maybe there could be a breakthrough.
“He said, ‘Why—why can’t we cooperate?’ I said, ‘We can. Let me give you an example of how we can start,’” Nelson said, who detailed how the U.S. shared its moon samples with the international community. China had returned with its own samples collected from the far side of the moon, but had yet to share up their samples for scientific study. “Make that available.”
That ambassador was promoted to foreign minister, and Nelson said he thought, “Man, this is good. We’re really going to have a chance to start this dialogue.”
But then, he vanished, discovered three years later working in a Beijing bookstore.
“In other words, he had fallen out of favor with the leader,” he said. “This is the challenge that we’re up against. And yet I am that optimist … that we can use this unique environment of space to continue to try to bring us together.”
