For much of my adult life, Israel has occupied an important place in my Jewish identity. I lived and studied there, returned many times, led congregational trips and spent years studying with some of Israel’s most distinguished Jewish thinkers. My relationship with Israel has been one of love, admiration, disappointment, anger and, increasingly, grief.
This week, a United Nations commission issued another devastating report on Israel’s treatment of Palestinians. The commission concluded that Israel continues to commit genocidal acts in Gaza, even after last year’s ceasefire. It also documented what it describes as crimes against humanity in the occupied West Bank, including unlawful killings, torture, sexual violence and the forced displacement of civilians.
Israel rejects these findings. But the United Nations commission is hardly alone. Amnesty International, the respected Israeli human rights organization B’Tselem, and Physicians for Human Rights–Israel have also concluded that Israel’s actions in Gaza constitute genocide.
I have come to believe they are right. I do not arrive at that conclusion lightly. The word genocide carries particular weight for Jews. Our historical experience makes us understandably reluctant to use it casually. International law requires more than widespread killing or even war crimes. It requires evidence of an intention to destroy a national, ethnic, racial or religious group, in whole
or in part.
The evidence, taken together, has become overwhelming to me: the scale of the killing, the destruction of entire communities, the deprivation of food, water and medical care, and the statements of Israeli political and military leaders. These are not simply the tragic consequences of a war against Hamas. They reveal an intention to destroy Palestinian life in Gaza.
Behind the report is unimaginable human suffering. Palestinian families have lost children, parents, homes and communities — nearly everything that makes life possible. Confronting this suffering has forced me to ask how my own attachment to Israel has shaped what I have been willing to see. I keep returning to two of my teachers, Rabbi David Hartman and the Israeli philosopher Yeshayahu Leibowitz, who understood the place of Israel in Jewish life very differently.
David Hartman loved Israel deeply. He believed Jewish sovereignty offered extraordinary possibilities for Jewish moral and religious renewal. He also believed passionately that Judaism must remain open to criticism and moral accountability.
Yet I sometimes felt that his love for Israel made it difficult for him to follow his own moral principles to their most uncomfortable conclusions. Leibowitz approached the matter differently. For him, the state was a political instrument, not a sacred object. To elevate the state above moral judgment was to risk turning it into an idol.
I learned a great deal from both men. Increasingly, however, I find myself drawn to Leibowitz’s uncompromising insistence that no state, including the Jewish state, deserves our unconditional loyalty. Hamas committed terrible atrocities on Oct. 7. Israel had both the right and the responsibility to protect its citizens. Neither fact, however, grants Israel immunity from moral judgment for what followed.
For American Jews, the challenge is particularly painful. Criticism of Israel can become entangled with genuine antisemitism. I have witnessed that firsthand, here in Sonoma County. But the existence of antisemitism cannot become an excuse for ignoring the suffering of Palestinians or denying Israel’s responsibility. I have spent most of my adult life trying to teach that Judaism demands something more of us than loyalty to our own people. It calls us to recognize the humanity of others, especially when doing so is difficult.
If our attachment to Israel prevents us from recognizing the suffering of Palestinians, or from honestly confronting what Israel has done, then something has gone terribly
wrong. The question is no longer simply what Israel has become. It is also what our unwillingness to confront Israel’s actions is doing to us, and to Judaism itself.
Rabbi George Gittleman is the Rabbi Emeritus of Congregation Shomrei Torah, a Senior Rabbinic Fellow at the prestigious Shalom Hartman Institute, and a graduate of both the Rabbinic Leadership Program and the Jewish Mindfulness Meditation Certificate Program at the Institute for Jewish Spirituality.
You can email letters to the editor to letters@pressdemocrat.com. Don’t miss The Press Democrat’s new weekly opinion newsletter, Second Thoughts. Sign up here.