An employee of Henry Mechanical installs an air handler for a heat pump at a home in Windsor in 2023. Heat pumps will become much more common if Bay Area air regulators approve a new rule banning the installation of gas water heaters, though about half of homeowners may be able to seek exemptions.
Brian Feulner/Special to The Chronicle
Bay Area Air District staff now estimate that half of Bay Area households could be exempt from the controversial natural gas water heater ban that will require many other households to purchase more expensive and environmentally-friendly alternatives.
The ban is currently set to go into effect in January, though air district board members will vote Wednesday on whether to delay the start date by a year — to January 2028. The ban prohibits the installation of appliances that emit smog-forming nitrogen oxides. It is expected to push homeowners toward heat pump water heaters, which staff estimate cost an average of $3,500 more than natural gas models.
The vote Wednesday could also approve carveouts for low-income residents and projects that face space or electrical constraints. The percentage of residents likely to be eligible for these exemptions just rose significantly after air board staff changed the definition of who would qualify as low-income.
Article continues below this ad
Greg Nudd, the district’s deputy executive of policy, told journalists on Monday that he expects approximately 50% of current water heaters in the Bay Area to fall under the proposed exemptions, up from roughly 38% the district previously estimated. That’s because low-income will now be defined as 80% of “area median income,” as opposed to 50% under the previously proposed change.
In San Francisco, that cut off would be $90,750 for a one-person household and $129,700 for a four-person home, according to a 2026 analysis by the city of San Francisco. If the Air District uses those figures for its proposed low-income exemption, people above that cutoff would still need to buy heat pumps when their gas water heaters break, unless they qualify for another exemption.
However, the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development 2026 income-limit table lists higher 80% limits for San Francisco: $117,700 for one person and $168,100 for four. The Air District did not say which income measure would determine eligibility or provide the applicable limits for each of the nine Bay Area counties.
Those who are enrolled in public assistance programs such as Cal Fresh or spend more than 28% of their household income on housing costs will also qualify for the income exemption.
But even homeowners above the income limit can qualify for a different type of exemption — one for lack of space — if their existing water heater space is less than 700 cubic feet and lacks proper ventilation. People can self-attest online when applying for this exemption. For a home to be eligible for yet another type of exemption — for electrical service constraints — a contractor must attest that an installment meets qualifying criteria, including if an electrical panel has no available breaker space, a panel has fewer than 100 amps or the wiring is outdated.
Article continues below this ad
The air district’s jurisdiction covers Alameda, Contra Costa, Marin, Napa, San Francisco, San Mateo, Santa Clara, southwestern Solano and southern Sonoma counties.
The water heater rule, first passed in 2023 as one of the most aggressive clean-appliance mandates in the nation, has drawn strong support from environmental advocates and public health professionals. Air district staff said the switch to cleaner heat pumps and furnaces will prevent up to 85 premature deaths.
“The NOx emissions from natural gas combustion in buildings is comparable to all the passenger vehicles in the Bay Area, comparable to all the fuel refining facilities in the Bay Area,” Nudd said. “So this is a big source of pollution, and that’s why the board set these aggressive standards back in 2023.”
At the same time, many property owners have expressed strong concern that the ban heaps on added expenses during what many describe as an affordability crisis in the nation. Some board members have said in recent months that they favor a voluntary program.
Article continues below this ad
Board members will also vote on additional amendments, including exempting small water heaters with fewer than 30 gallons along with delaying compliance for multi-family residential buildings and deed-restricted affordable housing.
Staff is also asking that the board create an emergency replacement program, where homeowners can pay contractors to install a natural gas water heater while they wait for their home to be ready to accommodate a heat pump model.
A separate rule from the air district will require households to replace broken natural gas furnaces — i.e. air heating units, not water heaters — with cleaner alternatives like heat pumps starting in January 2029.