In 1961, President John F. Kennedy proposed a goal: “before this decade is out, of landing a man on the moon and returning him safely to the Earth.” NASA then spent the first year focused on figuring out how to do it. Politicians listened to the rocket scientists who recommended the concept of a lunar orbit rendezvous because that concept minimized total launch mass. That lunar orbit rendezvous concept became Apollo’s fact-based vision, a picture of how to achieve the goal. That vision confirmed that 1969 was feasible, which opened the funding floodgates and kicked off the planning process, and the rest is history.
So, what is Maryland’s climate goal?
In contrast to NASA, Maryland has been attacking climate change with all the discipline of children building tree houses. After 20 years, goals keep changing, and there is still no clear vision of what a world without fossil fuels will look like.
Every disciplined engineering project has a purpose. Kennedy’s Apollo goal was crystal clear. But Maryland’s climate goals have been ambiguous and inconsistent. Gov. Wes Moore certified Maryland’s current set in a June 2024 executive order: “Net zero emissions by 2045,” “reduce greenhouse gas emissions by 60% below 2006 levels by 2031” and “100% clean energy by 2035.”
The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) provided us with the elements of a decent high-level goal: global net-zero. Net-zero means balancing the amount of greenhouse gases released into the atmosphere with an equivalent amount removed. It allows for biofuels such as wood pellet stoves. Translating the IPCC goal into a practical goal for a political entity such as Maryland involves two important nuances.
The first nuance is dates.
A 2018 IPCC report concluded that net-zero by 2050 would limit global warming to less than 1.5 degrees Celsius above pre-industrial levels. Many political entities adopted “net-zero by 2050” as a climate goal. What is important here is to achieve net-zero as quickly as practical. The 2050 date is aspirational up to the point where we have created a vision of what net-zero looks like. After selecting a fact-based vision, politicians can choose a date by balancing affordability, development speed and risk. It is unlikely to be as soon as 2050.
The second nuance is energy system boundaries.
Unlike the whole Earth or islanded grids, which have natural boundaries, Maryland is highly dependent on the regional PJM electricity system. Today, Maryland imports roughly 40% of its electricity. On an hourly basis, power flows range from net exports to double the average imports. Wholesale prices, while averaging $40/MWh, range from negative to positive thousands of dollars per MWh. Modeling this electric power interface between Maryland and PJM to create a vision is simply impractical. Assuming PJM will buy/sell electricity at average prices is unrealistic.
It is time to simplify and refine Maryland’s goal to consist of independent and net-zero systems(no date yet).
There are two electric power systems of interest. PJM and an independent, stand-alone state of Maryland. A sound concept design analysis would provide policymakers with options for both systems. Engineers would use full-system levelized cost of electricity to compare the architecture of least-cost systems with alternatives. The judgment of which system to develop and how the relationship between PJM and Maryland changes with time is a political decision.
Modeling an independent net-zero PJM is a good start because PJM imports/exports are proportionally small and can reasonably be approximated as a closed boundary. PJM has published hourly data that can be reasonably scaled.
But Maryland has no control over out-of-state generation. Modeling Maryland with no imports/exports is an accurate way to account for all intermittency costs. It is compatible with global net zero. And transitioning to a real independent net-zero Maryland is a real risk-mitigation option.
But the big trouble begins at the top.
Setting goals is a leadership responsibility, the governor’s job. Any disciplined engineering project begins with a clear statement of purpose: clear, unambiguous, technology neutral and achievable. It specifies what to achieve, not how to achieve it. A goal such as “20% renewables by 2020” is not sound; it’s a policy gamble that can commit the public to expensive dead ends and stranded investments before anyone has evaluated the complete system.
Consider how we approach building a novel skyscraper. Architects and engineers first develop conceptual designs, evaluate structural alternatives, estimate costs and explain the tradeoffs. The owner then decides what to build. Plans follow, and construction begins. No sensible developer would pour the foundation and erect 20 stories before deciding what the finished building should look like. Yet that is remarkably close to how Maryland is planning its energy future.
Kennedy had a goal, engineers developed a vision, and Apollo reached the moon.
Maryland has many goals, deadlines, programs and spending — but no vision.
Alex Pavlak is a professional engineer, Severna Park resident and the chair of the Future of Energy Initiative, whose mission is to facilitate the development of sustainable, affordable, clean energy systems.