Kentucky and West Virginia have spent a decade proving rare earths can come from coal and mine drainage. New federal prizes add workforce, but buyers still need specs and contracts.
Last month, the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) named the University of Kentucky and West Virginia University among 16 schools sharing $16 million in workforce prizes, a fresh bet on the two states that have spent a decade showing rare earths can be pulled from coal and polluted mine water. The research has cleared the lab, and the harder test now belongs to buyers, who need a qualified product that arrives the same way every month at a cost that holds.
Funding and a working pilot show that the chemistry can be done. Only a signed purchase agreement shows that someone will pay for the output, and most coal-based rare earth efforts in Appalachia have not reached that point.
Kentucky’s Pilot Results Came Early
The University of Kentucky’s work has a long record. By the end of a second project phase, its pilot plant produced mixed rare earth oxide concentrates of up to 98% purity, the National Energy Technology Laboratory (NETL) reported in February 2021. A mixed concentrate is an intermediate product, though, and a magnet maker needs individual elements separated to its own specifications, with known impurities and the same composition from one batch to the next.
The university’s next step started with a $5 million federal award announced Jan. 3, 2025. The project targets rare earths and graphite from a type of coal that naturally carries high concentrations of both, naming dysprosium, neodymium and praseodymium among its elements. A pilot plant is meant to test processes that could cut the cost of producing rare earth oxides by 20%, while the step that turns purified oxides into metal is still at bench scale.
Pilot data will feed the design of a commercial plant producing 1 to 3 metric tons of purified rare earth oxides a day, the university said. Project lead Rick Honaker, a professor of mining engineering, described the separation step as “an innovative process called microbubble-assisted solvent extraction.” The University of Alabama and Virginia Tech are partners.
West Virginia Starts With Polluted Water
West Virginia University starts from a different feedstock. Its A34 facility at Mount Storm, opened in 2022 with the state Department of Environmental Protection, recovers rare earths from acid mine drainage, the metal-laden water that seeps from old coal workings. The university calls it the first integrated pilot-scale facility of its kind in the country.
“For a decade, we’ve been proving we can extract rare earths from acid mine drainage at coal sites,” Vice Provost Mark Gavin said when the university launched a Rare Earth Elements Initiative in May. Its current federal project, Rare Earth Metal Production from Acid Mine Drainage, carries $5 million in federal money and $1.3 million in cost share and runs from October 2024 through September 2027, with a goal of producing salable rare earth metals.
Commercialization sits with Mission Critical Materials, a startup formed in December 2025 to license the university’s process. In January it signed a non-binding memorandum of understanding naming REalloys, a company building separation, metal and magnet operations, as its preferred downstream and offtake partner. The startup said it has produced concentrates above 95% rare earth oxide and expects to supply “several hundred tonnes” of heavy rare earths to REalloys over the coming years, and the two companies said they would negotiate a definitive multi-year offtake agreement during 2026.
Mark Jensen, chairman and chief executive of Indiana-based American Resources, said his company began pulling metals out of mine water in 2015 to offset environmental costs at its Appalachian coal operations. It concentrated them “from parts per billion to 2% to 8%, and then realized we could do nothing with it,” he said. Conventional solvent extraction would have used more chemicals than the metals were then worth, which pushed the company to develop its own refining process.
The water-treatment angle can help the economics where treatment is already required. Whether mineral sales offset that cost depends on recovery expenses, product value and who carries the treatment obligation, and mine cleanup obligations can shift after approval, as Montana’s Butte site has shown.
Federal Money Arrives in Stages
Washington is funding several stages at once. On July 1, the Energy Department selected five coal-based projects for about $75 million under its Mines and Metals Capacity Expansion program, including Peabody Energy, American Resources and CONSOL Innovations’ Pennsylvania pilot. “American industrial facilities have the potential to produce valuable critical materials from coal and coal byproducts,” said Audrey Robertson, the department’s assistant secretary.
The department also stated that “selection for award negotiations is not a commitment by DOE to issue an award or provide funding.” Jensen, whose company is one of the five, said in September that “the money hasn’t technically been unlocked yet.”
His description of the feedstock shows where the cost sits. American Resources says it holds more than 20,000 acres in the region, where rare earths sit in coal refuse piles and in the clay above and below the seams, already mined and lying at the surface. Jensen called the material “very low concentrate” and said the work now is figuring out “how do you concentrate that material economically and safely.” He said coal refuse is not yet the company’s primary feed but could become “a true domestic source” within a couple of years, because the material has already been mined.
Federal workforce money is moving in parallel. The PROSPECT program that funded the Kentucky and West Virginia prizes opened an implementation round on Oct. 30 that closes Nov. 25, and the department estimates the country will need about 6,000 new mining engineers over the next decade.
Cost Curves Decide Which Waste Streams Win
Some producers already plan for a market without price supports. “Price floors will go away. They will not be in existence forever,” Jensen said. “You have to be able to compete globally on cost curves.”
Coal is not the only waste stream courting rare earth and critical mineral buyers. Researchers are also testing ways to turn arsenic-laden mine waste into high-purity metal, and the competition for qualification slots at magnet and alloy makers will favor producers that can show sustained operating data first.
For Kentucky and West Virginia, the next proof points are concrete. A definitive offtake agreement between Mission Critical Materials and REalloys would be the first binding commercial contract tied to the West Virginia process, and Kentucky’s pilot results will show whether the promised 20% cost cut survives scale. Until then, buyers can request samples for testing, but they still cannot count these sources as production volume.