Iuliia Mendel, Zelenskiy’s former press secretary, was due to speak in Berlin on November 4, a day after Ukraine accused her of treason and seven weeks after the European Parliament barred her.
It was her second attempt to speak in Europe. Zelenskiy sanctioned her on September 13 and three days later she was stopped at the door of the parliament in Strasbourg, delivering her speech by video instead. This time the Security Service of Ukraine (SBU) and the Prosecutor General’s Office named her a treason suspect in absentia on November 3, while Zelenskiy was in Berlin. She went ahead at a discussion on a neutral Ukraine hosted by the far-right AfD’s parliamentary group in the Bundestag’s Jakob-Kaiser-Haus, dpa reported.
Twice now the Ukrainian state has moved against a former presidential aide days before she was due to address a European audience. Zelenskiy signed the first measure himself and the second came from agencies whose heads he nominates. Whatever one makes of Mendel or her hosts, using administrative resources to silence a critic is the antithesis of the democratic values Ukraine has to adopt to join the EU.
The same thing just happened inside the EU a few weeek earlier. IntelliNews columnist Leonid Ragozin, a Russian journalist who has lived in Riga since 2014, was expelled from Latvia in October for what he says are his views on the war. Mendel has also written for IntelliNews.
“The same thing happened a month and a half ago, when Zelenskyy personally imposed sanctions on me as soon as he learned that I was going to address the European Parliament,” Mendel said on X on November 4. “This is a clear sign of Zelenskyy’s weakness and his fear of words. He is afraid of his own former press secretary.”
Kyiv tells it differently. Prosecutors allege she used her standing to spread “narratives that help Russia,” citing her interview with Tucker Carlson, Facebook posts, forensic examinations that found signs of “destructive informational and psychological influence”, and the use Russian state media made of her words. The SBU says she justifies the Kremlin’s war.
Treason under martial law carries 15 years or life. The investigation opened on May 13, The Public reported in May, long before any Berlin date, so the link she draws to Zelenskiy’s trip is her own. Prosecutors also note in their statement that she is presumed innocent until a court rules otherwise.
But the published statements is remarkably thin on evidence: it cites no payments, no instructions and no contact with Russian officials, only what she said online and who repeated it. Mendel denies working with Russia. Her own record is contested: presidential adviser Dmytro Lytvyn rejected her claim that Zelenskiy was ready to give up the Donbas in 2022, saying she took no part in the talks, and the Kyiv Independent says some of her claims are unconfirmed or misleading, again without giving any specifics. Ukraine’s ambassador to Germany, Oleksii Makeiev, declined the AfD’s invitation and said on X that Ukraine remains neither neutral towards war crimes nor defenceless.
Under the bonnet
Ukraine sells itself as a European state, and its EU accession bid depends on that. Look under the bonnet and its handling of critics has more in common with Russia than with Belgium.
The European Commission’s 2026 report on Ukraine, published on November 4, covers the period to September 1, so it says nothing about Mendel. What is does say is a very politely dressed up barrage of disappointment and criticism.
“The application of Ukraine’s domestic sanctions regime should remain within the boundaries set by the European Convention of Human Rights”, and that “aspects related to in absentia proceedings should be improved”. Its broader verdict is that the ten priority rule of law reforms agreed last December “remain mostly outstanding”, but immediately qualifies that with “limited progress” on the courts and “continued resistance” to international experts vetting judges. On freedom of expression it is milder, finding “adequate legal guarantees” and “some” progress.
Its 2025 predecessor was blunter on one point: anti-corruption bodies and civil society reported “growing pressure from state institutions, including through criminal investigations by law enforcement and security agencies”. Those developments, it said, cast “doubts on Ukraine’s commitment to its anti-corruption agenda”.
The European Parliament went further in a resolution on July 8, urging Kyiv to refrain from “politically motivated judicial proceedings” and in a backhanded reference to Mendel and former President Petro Poroshenko, who has also been sanctioned, from “introducing personal sanctions against opposition representatives and leaders of civil society organisations”. Ten weeks later the same parliament turned Mendel away. Its press service said it does not comment on individual cases and pointed to its rules on access to its premises, Radio Svoboda reported. Mendel blames the sanctions.
The EC rebuked Bankova for backsliding on anti-corruption and civil liberty chapters Kyiv is neglecting. The National Anti-Corruption Bureau (NABU) said on November 4 it had finished its pre-trial investigation in the Midas case, in which cash of more than $111mn and €12mn allegedly reached a laundering office from kickbacks at nuclear operator Energoatom, Interfax-Ukraine reported. The Commission credits the bureau for delivering, but says “no laws were adopted to significantly advance the anti-corruption legal framework”. Half of those polled in September named corruption among their top worries, ahead of Russian missile strikes. No accession chapter can close until the rule of law benchmarks are met, which the Commission’s roadmap pencils in for the first half of 2027. Going after a critic at this point is a very bad sign, from a president already sounding increasingly desperate.
No “surrender”
In her country, “telling the truth is no longer fashionable”, Mendel told the Berliner Zeitung. “Ukraine is being destroyed by both of them: by Putin’s massive war and by Zelenskyy’s authoritarian regime.” Poverty has risen to more than 41% from 25%, she said, citing the World Bank, and there are four deaths for every birth. The official figure was 3.55 in 1H26.
She has also been misquoted. The Times headlined a September 17 profile “The former Zelensky loyalist who now wants Ukraine to surrender”, and the Telegraph ran “Zelensky’s ex-aide argues she’s not a Russian spy – but Ukraine should surrender” in October. Neither is her wording, and she denies the claim. “I have repeatedly made clear that I oppose Ukraine’s surrender,” she wrote on X on October 18. “At the same time, I believe that if the war continues under the current approach, Ukraine will eventually be forced to surrender.”
What she wants is a negotiated end because too many people are dying, and she stops there. “My country is dying … if we choose a bad peace over a bad war, we can try to preserve our independence and restore our economy and democracy,” she told the Times, which reported that she would not say what territory Ukraine should give up, citing the threat of treason charges. A deal would be very hard to reach: Moscow demands the whole of four regions, and a Kyiv International Institute of Sociology poll in September found 77% of Ukrainians would refuse to surrender even if attacks cut off power and heat this winter, the paper reported. Her position is arguable, and arguing it is not a crime in a democracy.
Expelled from Riga
Interior Minister Janis Dombrava publicly demanded Ragozin’s removal on September 30, also for making uncomfortabel and unpopular citicisms: he cited Ragozin’s criticism of Western sanctions and accusing him of discrediting Ukraine, Novaya Gazeta Europe reported.
Foreign Minister Baiba Braze began the persona non grata process on October 6, citing “the competent authorities”, and he was notified on October 13. Prime Minister Andris Kulbergs backed the move, saying independent Russian journalism “has to be treated with great precaution and triple checking”, Meduza reported.
Ragozin also was clear that he condemns Russia’s invasion and supports Ukraine’s sovereignty over the occupied territories, and he appears to be the first independent journalist opposed to the war on a list of more than 150 Russians that includes Kremlin propagandists. He says the ministry has now told him in writing that the reasons cannot be disclosed because they are a “state secret.” The decision to PNG Ragozin, rather than strip him of his residency, means he has been barred by an administrative action against which there is no legal recourse, whereas recinding residency would have required a decision that can be challenged in court. In addition the reasons for barring him have now been classified.
“I regard it as an admission that there were no reasons at all, apart from petty revenge for the investigation”, he said on X. The investigation is a December 2019 piece for Re:Baltica, written with Sanita Jemberga, on links between officials of Dombrava’s nationalist National Alliance, which Ragozin calls far right, and Ukraine’s Azov movement, which is well known to be far right.
In his account the circle includes Kyiv-based Russian neo-Nazis from the Wotanjugend platform, who circulated the Christchurch shooter’s manifesto. The party told Re:Baltica at the time that its officials acted in a private capacity. Re:Baltica stands by the work but has not worked with him since 2019 and calls some of his social media remarks unacceptable, Novaya Gazeta Europe reported.
The state secret, according to Ragozin, is that “it is the case of political persecution carried out via an extrajudicial procedure that has been designed for diplomats enjoying political immunity, not for ordinary people with EU’s permanent residence permit who had been screened by Latvian security bodies annually for over a decade”. The Mapping Media Freedom watchdog has logged the case. He fears that deportation would mean Russia, and prison.
No day in court
Ragozin says the persona non grata designation is administrative and cannot itself be appealed in a Latvian court. National Alliance MEP Rihards Kols wrote that revoking his residence permit could be challenged and Latvia would lose, Novaya Gazeta Europe reported.
Mendel’s sanctions were imposed in the same spirit, by decree and without a trial, for ten years on her account. She calls them unconstitutional, and so do others: Mykhailo Zhernakov of the DEJURE think-tank called the sanctions on former president Petro Poroshenko “clearly unconstitutional”, the Kyiv Independent reported. Kyiv disagrees. Sanctions commissioner Vladyslav Vlasiuk says the law covers individuals regardless of citizenship, and the Supreme Court rejected Poroshenko’s challenge on July 10. Poroshenko says he will go to its Grand Chamber and the European Court of Human Rights. So a Ukrainian decree can be challenged, unlike a Latvian listing, but the most prominent challenge has so far failed.
The treason case is different, because it can be fought in court and Mendel will probably fight it. The grounds as published are vague on the central question of what she did for Russia. Her reply is a comparison:
“Now, take a closer look: the traitor is not Yermak, who faces allegations of laundering $10 million. Not Mindich or Halushchenko, who are suspected of laundering more than $100 million. The traitor is Mendel, who has not stolen a single penny.”
Former presidential chief of staff Andriy Yermak was charged in May over UAH460mn ($10.1mn) of alleged laundering and denies it. He was freed on May 18 after UAH140mn ($3.1mn) in bail was paid. Former energy minister Herman Halushchenko is out on bail of UAH150mn ($3.3mn), a sum NABU has since charged others with laundering to pay it. Businessman Timur Mindich, Zelenskiy’s former business partner, left for Israel before the raids and is under three-year sanctions. Nobody has been convicted, and none of the three has been charged with treason on the public record.
Corruption and treason sit under different articles and different agencies, so the comparison is political rather than legal. It is the comparison Ukrainians will make all the same: “Three years for more than $100 million – and ten years, plus accusations of treason, for someone against whom there is not a single allegation of corruption,” Mendel told the Berliner Zeitung.
Mendel’s case goes to a Ukrainian court if prosecutors indict, and Brussels will be assessing the rule of law benchmarks at the same time. Ragozin has appealed to the Council of Europe, the European Commission and press freedom groups from abroad. “Please don’t allow EU member countries to destroy rule of law and media freedom the way it happened in Putin’s Russia over last decades,” he wrote.