The Tribunal heard from three neurosurgeons, along with extensive records from GPs, radiologists, a chiropractor, a physiotherapist, and a pain management physician. It found the worker had suffered an injury – a mechanical lower back strain – arising in the course of his employment on January 4, 2021. It preferred the evidence of one neurosurgeon who characterised the injury as a disc tear, finding that another expert’s view attributing the condition to genetics alone was “an oversimplification of a complex condition.”
The Tribunal accepted Australia Post remained liable under the SRC Act. But rather than calculating exactly what the worker was owed in medical expenses and lost wages, it sent those questions back to Australia Post to work out – noting that while the evidence indicated the worker had capacity to return to his pre-injury duties, it did not have enough information about his actual pre-injury working hours, overtime, or the specifics of treatment obtained after April 2022 to do the maths itself.
That decision to send the compensation questions back became the centrepiece of the appeal.
Australia Post framed its appeal around four questions of law. First, it argued that sending the compensation question back to the employer was “legally unreasonable or irrational” – if the Tribunal itself noted the worker could return to his pre-injury duties, why was there anything left to assess?
The court drew a distinction. Being physically able to perform specified lifting tasks was not the same thing as being able to work at the same level as before the injury – including the same hours, overtime, and full range of duties. Reading the Tribunal’s observation as a final determination that the worker had no incapacity at all “would make the paragraph internally contradictory, when a more coherent construction is available on a fair reading of the reasons.”