Bernstein downgraded ConocoPhillips (COP), Diamondback Energy (FANG) and Devon Energy (DVN) to Market-Perform from Outperform on Thursday, arguing that oil equities face a tougher path even though crude prices remain well above the level at which producers thrive.
Analysts led by Bob Brackett wrote that after the U.S. midterm elections, “de-escalation between the U.S. and Iran is more probable than escalation.” Crude should settle back toward normal levels, they said, “but to higher levels than pre-conflict.” Brent was trading near $90 a barrel, and the firm forecasts an average above $90 for the year.
At more than $75 a barrel, the underlying business still looks attractive, according to the analysts, “but oil equities may struggle to appreciate.” Two forces could weigh on share prices: investors locking in gains before year-end, and money rotating into sectors that have lagged. The team put the trade-off bluntly: “An $80/bbl world next year makes for great returns for oil companies but not great returns for oil equity investors.”
Price targets came down alongside the ratings.
CompanyTickerNew ratingNew targetPrior targetConocoPhillipsCOPMarket-Perform$122$129Diamondback EnergyFANGMarket-Perform$192$221Devon EnergyDVNMarket-Perform$44$49Exxon MobilXOMOutperform$186$193
Note: Targets in U.S. dollars per share.
Oil and gas had ranked among the strongest corners of the S&P 500 heading into the midterms and has since surrendered part of that advance. The analysts cautioned that multi-year stretches of sector outperformance are uncommon and that equity pullbacks tend to arrive fast. They described the current setup as offering “even worse odds than average,” pointing to voters’ broad rejection of the Trump administration, especially its war in the Middle East.
Valuations offer little protection either. Multiples across the firm’s coverage sit close to five-year averages, leaving scant cushion should earnings slide in tandem with crude.
Rather than abandon the sector, Bernstein is recommending a “defensive barbell.” On one end sits Exxon Mobil (XOM), the largest integrated oil company, which the analysts expect to benefit from refined product prices that tend to be “stickier than oil” and hold up better than crude. On the other end are natural gas producers Expand Energy (EXE) and EQT (EQT), both rated Outperform. The two companies draw most of their revenue and valuation from Henry Hub gas prices, and the analysts see $3 per thousand cubic feet as below mid-cycle, making for an attractive entry point on a longer-term gas thesis even with near-term metrics mixed.
The downgrades land as investors weigh whether this year’s energy rally has run its course. Integrated majors and gas-focused producers with steadier cash flow profiles may hold up better than pure-play shale drillers if crude retreats toward $80, the firm’s framing suggests.