Kathmandu. It is the compulsion of Nepali youth to shed sweat in foreign lands due to the lack of sufficient employment opportunities in Nepal.

While the Gulf countries were once the primary and sole choice for Nepali workers, labor destinations have started to change recently. Due to security and low wages, European countries are increasingly becoming new destinations as alternatives to Gulf countries.

Various European countries are becoming the choice of Nepalis due to good salaries, attractive benefits, social security, and perceived safety from a human rights perspective.

Immigration experts say that although Nepalis are rushing to go to Europe by paying more than to Malaysia and the Gulf, the government’s preparation and regulation to manage this growing attraction towards Europe appear very weak.

They state that due to various problems arising in traditional labor destinations like the Gulf countries and Malaysia, Nepali workers’ attraction has recently increased towards European countries.

Experts say the government has completely failed to search for new and safe labor destinations and to formally manage them. As the government makes no diplomatic efforts to find new destinations, workers are forced to take risks and go through informal channels, relying on agents and the private sector.

According to immigration expert Meena Poudel, old destinations like the Gulf and Malaysia are currently in disarray. She says that workers who gained skills working in the Gulf are looking for better jobs and alternatives, making Europe a center of attraction. However, the government’s presence in opening up new destinations like Europe is almost nil.

“Currently, the most chaotic, jobless, and disorganized ministry is the Ministry of Labor. Neither have old agreements been renewed, nor have formal agreements been made to open pathways to Eastern European countries like Greece, Malta, and Cyprus,” Poudel said. “In the name of formal initiatives, there has been no meaningful diplomatic effort beyond inviting ambassadors for tea.”

Another immigration expert, Dr. Ganesh Gurung, also states that the government, and especially the Foreign Employment Board, has completely failed in searching for new markets. He pointed out that there has been no study on which countries in the global market need what kind of manpower and what kind of manpower Nepal possesses.

“Nepal is currently sending people wherever there is demand, which has branded Nepal as a country sending unskilled labor to the global market,” said Dr. Gurung. “The state has not focused on how to make our unskilled manpower earn more money by providing short-term training.”

Expert Gurung believes that Nepali embassies abroad should strategically search for markets to see in which sectors and how their citizens can be utilized, but this has not happened.

Experts conclude that foreign employment will always remain chaotic and risky until the state adopts a policy of training workers according to the demand of destination countries through diplomatic initiatives and sending them through formal channels.

Over 4.3 Million Nepalis Emigrated in 6 Years

The government has opened 111 countries for foreign employment. Nepalis are working in more than 178 countries through personal initiative and other means.

Looking at the statistics of the last six years, the trend of Nepalis going abroad is alarming. During this period, 2,673,419 people went for foreign employment after obtaining their first work permit. In the same period, 1,653,229 people obtained re-work permits. In the last six years alone, 4,326,648 Nepalis have gone for foreign employment.

In the fiscal year 2082/083 alone, 792,187 people went for foreign employment after obtaining work permits from the Department of Foreign Employment. Among them, 697,096 are male and 95,091 are female.

Compared to 839,266 people who obtained work permits in the fiscal year 2081/82, 47,079 fewer Nepali workers went abroad last year.

Europe is Becoming a New Hub for Nepalis

Many Nepalis still go to the six Gulf Cooperation Council countries – Bahrain, Kuwait, Oman, Qatar, Saudi Arabia, and UAE – and Malaysia, which are considered traditional labor markets.

According to the Department of Foreign Employment, 55.4 percent of workers still go to the Gulf region and 15.9 percent to Malaysia. However, amidst the tension and employment crisis in West Asia, Europe has emerged as a strong alternative.

Last year’s statistics show a surge in Nepalis going to Europe. Last year, more than 80,000 Nepali workers went to Europe in search of employment.

In the last six years, 101,656 Nepalis have gone to work in European countries. The graph of those going to Europe is rising every year. While 5,134 people went to Europe in fiscal year 2077/078, the number increased to 21,896 in 2078/079, 21,984 in 2079/080, 24,067 in 2080/081, and in 2081/082, more than 80,000 Nepalis went to 29 out of 44 European countries.

According to the department’s total statistics, in the first three months of the current fiscal year, a total of 792,187 people, including new and re-work permits, have received approval for foreign employment. Among them, 697,096 are male and 95,091 are female.

Europe’s share of the total work permits has increased from 10.5 percent to 14.7 percent. According to the department, from Saun 2082 to Jeth 2083, 367,000 people have obtained new work permits for 160 countries.

Which European Countries Have How Many Gone?

According to the department’s data, among European countries, Romania is the first choice for Nepalis, and Cyprus is the second. Demand for Nepalis has increased in agriculture, construction, hospitality, and manufacturing sectors in Eastern and Central European countries.

Last year alone, Romania accounted for the largest share (about 46 percent) of Nepalis going to Europe. 33,920 Nepali men and 4,111 women went there. Romania had allocated a quota of 100,000 for non-European workers, among whom Nepalis are the largest number among the 51,000 foreigners registered around Bucharest.

Other major destinations include Cyprus with 11,069 people (3,972 men, 7,097 women), Croatia with 7,662 people (6,284 men, 1,378 women), Malta with 6,110 people (4,589 men, 1,521 women).

Similarly, 3,800 went to Portugal, 3,788 to Serbia, 3,679 to Bulgaria, 3,126 to Greece, 2,650 to Poland, and 2,639 to Austria. Additionally, 1,724 went to Slovakia, 1,348 to the UK, 1,355 to Moldova, and 1,191 to Slovenia for employment.

The statistics for Cyprus are quite interesting. While the number of men is higher in other countries, the number of women in Cyprus is almost double that of men. The department stated that 7,097 women went to Cyprus due to high demand as caregivers and domestic workers.

According to government data, more than half of the total 792,000 workers who went for foreign employment last year are skilled workers. According to the department, there are 482,643 skilled workers, 190,264 unskilled, 114,614 semi-skilled, 3,570 professionals, and 1,096 highly skilled workers. While unskilled workers mostly go to the Gulf, a large number of those going to Europe have acquired skills.

Nepalis Going to Europe in the Last Five Years

cfly

Role of the Private Sector and Risks of Individual Work Permits

Currently, the government does not have a system for institutional work permits through manpower companies to European countries. However, the private sector is sending workers to European countries through informal channels.

Due to the absence of an institutional system, workers obtain individual work permits or go to Europe on visit visas through manpower company arrangements. The department’s data shows a decrease in the number of people going through manpower agencies. While manpower agencies sent 359,675 people the previous year, they sent only 268,990 last year, a decrease of 90,685.

On the other hand, 128,520 people went on individual work permits last year, while 8,197 went through G2G.

Due to the closure of institutional channels, manpower companies are charging workers between 1 to 1.5 million rupees in the name of sending them to Europe. Due to weak regulation, workers are facing severe financial exploitation and risks.

The president of the Nepal Association of Foreign Employment Agencies, Dik Bahadur Khatri, said that the government must immediately resolve the policy issue of demand letter attestation to send workers to new labor destinations like Europe as an alternative to West Asia and Malaysia.

He stated that employment opportunities in traditional labor destinations are shrinking due to war and monopolies, and demanded that the government open pathways to emerging destinations like European countries. He also mentioned that the private sector has played an important role in finding new labor destinations so far.

According to President Khatri, concentrating the labor market in only one region, West Asia and Malaysia, has led to serious impacts on foreign employment due to occasional legal complications, wars, and natural disasters.

“Currently, due to the ongoing war in West Asia, the demand for workers from there has decreased by about 27 percent. Malaysia is also disturbed due to syndicates,” said President Khatri. “Therefore, we need to expand the labor market. We should not delay in expanding and attesting new destinations like Schengen, non-Schengen, Balkan corridors, and Japan’s SSW.”

Khatri said that although Nepali entrepreneurs are ready to send workers to new destinations like Europe, obstacles are being created due to government policies.

This problem started in 2075 BS when Section 15 (Cha) of the Foreign Employment Act, 2064, was amended to make it mandatory to get demand letters attested by the Nepali embassy in the respective country. “In the past, embassies in Europe like Germany, Austria, France, and the UK used to attest demand letters. But this has been completely stopped for the last 3 years,” he said.

Khatri informed that he is also a member of the committee formed by the Ministry of Labor to amend the flawed sections of the Act, and this issue has been prioritized there. However, he emphasized that the Ministry of Foreign Affairs holds the key to demand letter attestation and that the Ministry of Foreign Affairs should show promptness in this matter.

Khatri stated that the issue of demand letter attestation has been given high priority in the 15-point demands recently raised by entrepreneurs, and the government has been well-informed about it.

“Unless the knot of demand letter attestation is untied, we cannot expand to other labor markets. The government must take immediate steps in this regard,” he said.

Government Preparation and Diplomatic Obstacles in Finding New Destinations

The government has taken policy initiatives to find new labor destinations as an alternative to Gulf countries, but the implementation aspect is weak. The government has put forward a policy in its 2081/082 program to search for more destination countries, make labor audits mandatory, and provide pre-departure orientation training for free.

Nepal has currently signed labor agreements with Qatar, UAE, South Korea, Bahrain, Japan, Israel, Jordan, Malaysia, and Mauritius.

The government has been preparing for agreements with Maldives, France, Seychelles, and Qatar for a long time. The process of sending workers through government-to-government (G2G) channels to countries like the UK, similar to South Korea and Israel, is underway.

However, government facilitation for Europe is not effective. Due to the inability to get demand letters from Europe attested, workers cannot be legally sent through manpower agencies.

The then Minister of Labor, Sharad Singh Bhandari, had introduced a procedure whereby if the mission did not attest within 15 days, the department itself would do so. However, this matter has been left unresolved due to the conflict between the Ministry of Labor and the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and the change of government.

According to immigration expert Poudel, finding new destinations should be done at the diplomatic and political level, but instead, the government is only intimidating and taking action against manpower companies.

This has demoralized the private sector. Poudel states that since immigration policies are becoming stricter in Europe and Nepalis have to compete with unemployed citizens there, the private sector alone cannot manage the European market without government initiative.

Similarly, according to another expert, Dr. Gurung, although the Foreign Employment Board sent two teams abroad led by joint secretaries and other representatives to find new destinations, these teams only went on tours and returned without finding any specific markets.

He said that Nepalis are currently going to countries like Romania through the initiative of the private sector.

Dr. Gurung said, “It would be good if we could find out what kind of skills are needed in Romania – tractor driving or construction work? – and provide training in Nepal and send them through the government. That work has not been done.”

Although Nepal has signed labor agreements with some European countries including the UK and Germany, the expected benefits have not been realized. According to the agreement with the UK, only 45 nurses went for employment last year.

According to labor and immigration expert Rameshwar Nepal, the number of Nepalis going to Europe has been continuously increasing since 2023. Although employment in Europe is secure and the remuneration is good, workers have not been able to benefit due to the government’s weak labor diplomacy.

Experts say that the limited UK agreement in the nursing sector has not been effective, and although agreements have been made with Germany and some Eastern European countries, their concrete impact has not been seen. They state that with agreements with the UAE, Qatar, and Malaysia also limited to paper, the growing attraction towards Europe, if not managed in time, will certainly lead to more complex problems.

What is the Government’s Effort?

The government is making efforts to manage the growing foreign employment in Europe. However, it has not been successful. Currently, sending workers through institutional (manpower) channels to Europe is not allowed. Arbitrary fees are being collected from workers going through individual work permits.

To manage this, the government has been trying to send workers through manpower agencies for foreign employment, but demand letters from manpower agencies have not been attested so far.

The Ministry of Youth, Labor, and Employment had issued a procedure for attestation of demand letters. However, the procedure has not been implemented yet.

Ministry of Labor spokesperson Mira Acharya said that although the ministry is ready to find new labor destinations, some matters need to be handled by the Ministry of Foreign Affairs. She stated that coordination is being done with the Ministry of Foreign Affairs for the attestation of demand letters from Europe.

According to her, the government has opened 178 countries for individual and 111 for institutional employment. Spokesperson Acharya said that the main responsibility for finding and promoting new markets lies with the private sector (manpower entrepreneurs).

She clarified that the government will play the role of a regulator and facilitator, only attesting the demands brought by them within the legal framework. Currently, about 70 percent of workers going for foreign employment are unskilled.

Since it is difficult to find employment without skills in developed countries, the Gulf and Malaysia remain the main destinations for unskilled workers. The ministry has now adopted a policy of focusing on quality rather than quantity in foreign employment, according to spokesperson Acharya.

“The return from sending 10 highly skilled workers is greater than the remittance from sending 100 unskilled workers,” said Acharya. The ministry’s conclusion is that skilled manpower can earn in 2 years what unskilled workers cannot earn in 5 years.

The ministry stated that it will take some time to sign labor agreements with new destination countries as the legal provisions of both countries and guarantees for worker safety are required. Discussions are currently underway for bilateral labor agreements with Mauritius, Seychelles, Maldives, and Sri Lanka, where potential is seen in the hospitality and tourism sectors.

The government is focusing its diplomatic efforts on transforming the compulsion of foreign employment into safe opportunities by urging entrepreneurs to find new markets and by ensuring workers are skilled before going abroad.

As the destination for Nepali workers shifts from the Gulf to Europe, it is evident that the government needs to take immediate diplomatic and policy steps to open institutional work permit channels, facilitate demand letter attestation, and control fraud.