Last week, President Trump acknowledged in an interview with 60 Minutes that his immigration policy has been “too tough.” He said a “large part of the country” wants illegal immigrants deported, while others think immigrants should be allowed to stay if they are “good people” who work and pay taxes. He concluded that he would like to “do something on immigration” with the Democrats and “work a deal” for these immigrants.
Trump’s words could be read as a trial balloon for legalizing peaceful immigrants (often referred to as “amnesty”). But chances are it won’t happen under Trump’s leadership.
The day after the 60 Minutes interview, Trump backtracked: He told reporters at the White House that “there won’t be amnesty” and that his immigration policy hasn’t changed. This walkback is unsurprising: Trump has repeatedly reversed himself. For example, during his 2024 campaign, Trump said international students should get a green card “automatically” as “part of [their] diplomas” so they can stay in the country. The next day, campaign press secretary Karoline Leavitt narrowed Trump’s promise, saying that only the “most skilled graduates who can make significant contributions to America” would qualify, departing from Trump’s broader idea. The proposal never materialized. Instead, the Trump administration has cracked down on international students who are here legally and is seeking to make it much harder for them to stay in the country.
In June 2025, Trump posted that farmers and people in the hotel and leisure business were losing “very good, long time workers” because of his “very aggressive policy on immigration,” then added, “we must protect our Farmers, but get the CRIMINALS OUT OF THE USA.” Subsequently, immigration officials paused arrests at farms and hospitality businesses. Within days, the administration reversed course: then-DHS spokeswoman Tricia McLaughlin said that worksite enforcement remained a “cornerstone” of the administration’s immigration efforts, and raids resumed in full force.
Why does Trump keep floating the possibility of changing his immigration policy, and then not following through?
Part of the answer is that, despite his nationalist platform and his many insults against immigrants, Trump does not seem driven by a deep-seated anti-immigrant ideology. He’s hardly pro-immigrant given his nationalistic impulses, but the issue of immigration doesn’t animate him the way that, for example, tariffs and vanity projects do.
At the very least, Trump understands the importance of immigrants for the economy. Note his language during the 60 Minutes interview: he acknowledged that part of the country wants illegal immigrants to stay if they are “good people.” He also said that “when you go into a hotel and you have a woman that’s worked there as … a maid … as a waitress, a lotta good things, great jobs, and all of a sudden, they’re being taken outta the country, it’s tough.” He made the same point about foreign graduates (“you need brilliant people,” he said about them) and farmworkers, highlighting both the work immigrants do and their contributions. Those remarks suggest that Trump’s view of immigrants is not uniformly hostile: He seems more driven by shifting impulses than by an anti-immigrant ideology.
Trump is inconsistent on immigration because he lacks a guiding principle— he responds instead to impulses and polls (he admitted during the interview that immigration enforcement hurt him in the midterms). So he ends up being swayed by his advisors who do have a consistent principle, however despicable, chief among them Stephen Miller.
Miller is the architect behind the most draconian immigration policies and enforcement in the Trump administration. He is driven by an ideology and knows how to use government tools to curtail immigration. Whatever precarious and unprincipled positive view Trump has of immigrants is driven out by Miller’s guidance. Trump stands for little, and is therefore susceptible to advice from those who stand consistently for something, however un-American. Trump’s attempt at sympathy for the “good people” cleaning hotel rooms is fleeting; Miller’s nativism is a deeply held ideology.
Trump has now promoted Miller to chief of staff, giving him more power and influence. His elevation “seems likely to reinforce the president’s worst instincts,” writes Jacob Sullum at Reason. As long as Miller remains in the administration, there won’t be a realistic legalization effort for illegal immigrants.
But Democrats will soon control both chambers of Congress, so can’t a legalization bill pass? Probably not, because Trump can still veto, and Miller sets the price of Trump’s signature. In 2018, Trump’s limited legalization proposal, designed by Miller, came at the high cost of dramatically curtailing legal immigration.
The late Sen. Lindsey Graham, R-South Carolina, said at the time that “every time we have a proposal it is only yanked back by staff members … as long as Stephen Miller is in charge of negotiating immigration, we’re going nowhere.” The same is true eight years later— and Miller now runs the West Wing. If some legalization “deal” comes from this administration, it will carry a steep price and aim to dramatically restrict immigration in the long term.
Agustina Vergara Cid is a columnist for the Southern California News Group