Poland’s Supreme Court has delivered another major legal blow to Prime Minister Donald Tusk’s attempted takeover of the Constitutional Tribunal, ruling on Wednesday, 18 November, that only judges who took their oath in the presence of the president can issue legally recognized Tribunal judgments.

The decision came as President Karol Nawrocki’s office announced significant progress in cross-party negotiations to end the constitutional crisis, with Tusk’s Civic Coalition and the Left absent from the talks.

The resolution, adopted by 43 judges from three combined Supreme Court chambers, directly challenges the status of five judges elected by Tusk’s parliamentary majority who took alternative oaths after Nawrocki refused to receive them. Those judges participated in the attempted takeover of the Tribunal on 30 October, suspending its president, Bogdan Święczkowski, and deputy Bartłomiej Sochański.

The Supreme Court also ruled that Constitutional Tribunal judgments have generally binding force even if the government refuses to publish them in the official journal. The Tusk administration has withheld publication of 85 rulings, some involving pension entitlements and other disputes affecting ordinary Poles.

Justice Minister Waldemar Żurek immediately rejected the resolution as a ‘pseudo-resolution’ by so-called ‘neo-judges’, claiming it had no legal effect. His response came as the disputed Tribunal leadership lifted Święczkowski’s and Sochański’s judicial immunity, allowing prosecutors to pursue criminal allegations, although it refused to authorize Święczkowski’s detention.

The coup judges currently hijacking the helm of the Tribunal had already defied a separate Supreme Court decision overturning their initial suspensions.

Meanwhile, parliamentary parties willing to solve the crisis met for the second time with President Nawrocki’s team to outline a possible solution. According to the president’s chief of staff, Zbigniew Bogucki, negotiations produced agreement on around 70 per cent of such a solution.

Representatives of PiS, Konfederacja, Konfederacja Korony Polskiej, Razem and other opposition groups joined two parties from Tusk’s own governing coalition, the Polish People’s Party (PSL) and Poland 2050. Civic Coalition and the Left stayed away. Tusk nevertheless said earlier that he remained open to initiatives capable of resolving the dispute, although he appears unwilling to participate in these talks.

‘Parliamentary parties willing to solve the crisis met for the second time with President Nawrocki’s team’

The most far-reaching proposal comes from PSL, which wants a constitutional reset: ending the current judges’ terms and electing a new 15-member Tribunal with a three-fifths majority in the National Assembly, subject to presidential involvement in nominations. Constitutional amendments would require a two-thirds majority in the Sejm, making broader agreement essential.

The developments came just a day after Tusk survived a parliamentary vote of no confidence initiated by former prime minister Mateusz Morawiecki’s Rozwój Plus, with the Sejm rejecting the motion by 242 votes to 200.

Further talks between Nawrocki and parliamentary groups are scheduled for Thursday, 19 November.

Related articles:

At a time when public debate is increasingly polarized and superficial, Hungarian Conservative remains committed to depth, intellectual honesty, and independent conservative thought.

Producing high-quality journalism requires resources. Your contribution helps us expand our coverage, reach new audiences, and keep our content accessible.

Please consider supporting our mission.


Donate Now