The humbling of Donald Trump’s Republican Party in the midterm elections offers a rare moment of hope in a grim year for the many migrants and refugees who’ve sought a safe home in the USA.

A slew of progressive politicians promising fairer treatment of migrants and refugees have won seats. Polls suggest Latinx and Asian American voters swung sharply towards the Democrats compared to 2024, with violent raids to capture migrants by militarised Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) officers likely a factor. After his party’s defeat, Trump conceded his deportation policy ‘might be too tough’ and said he was prepared to strike a deal with Democrats to allow more undocumented migrants to stay.

This acknowledgement offers an opportunity to push for changes to an intentionally cruel anti-migrant regime and bring justice for the many victims of abuses, among them the eight-year-old Haitian boy in San Diego, California, whom armed officials snatched from his uncle at an immigration appointment earlier this month, reportedly putting him in restraints before detaining him for 11 days. But whether Trump, more unpredictable than ever, will moderate his anti-migrant policies in practice remains to be seen. His decision to promote Stephen Miller, the architect of the policies, to White House Chief of Staff casts doubt on his post-election comments.

Intentional cruelty

In two separate incidents in July, ICE agents shot dead Colombian man Johan Sebastián Durán Guerrero in Biddeford, Maine, and Mexican man Lorenzo Salgado Araujo in Houston, Texas. In October in New York, ICE agents shot and wounded Oscar Bengal as he sat in his car with his five-year-old child. A few days later in Texas, an ICE vehicle ran over Miguel Parra-Hernández, causing serious injuries.

These weren’t isolated incidents. Immigration raids are routinely violent and form part of a broader pattern of abuse. Authorities have detained record numbers of people in crowded and dangerous conditions. Detainees face fast-track proceedings designed to thwart immigration lawyers and speed up deportations, including of severely ill people and children who came to the USA without parents or guardians.

Courts are a key line of defence, but the Trump administration is rigging the system, firing many immigration judges and replacing them with others more likely to deny asylum and order deportations. In April, for example, it fired two immigration judges after they ruled in favour of two university students facing deportation for protesting in solidarity with Palestine. Even when people secure their release from detention, they risk ICE immediately detaining them again.

The US government has also closed off accountability routes. In May, it shut down the Office of the Immigration Detention Ombudsman, an independent office within the Department of Homeland Security that heard complaints about treatment in detention. Civil society groups are pursuing legal action.

The Trump administration’s cruelty towards migrants is intentional and performative. It wants to look tough because, until recently, it was convinced this played well with its supporters. It also believes its harshness will have a deterrent effect, discouraging people from coming to the USA and encouraging some already there to remove themselves, an approach it calls ‘self-deportation’. Its policies have a silencing effect, making migrants less visible and more afraid to take part in public life. The result is that some will stay away from services such as education and healthcare, work informally and avoid joining protests or speaking out online.

The Trump administration makes one exception. It claims white Afrikaner people from South Africa are experiencing race-based discrimination from their government, picking up on racist claims spread by Elon Musk that a ‘white genocide’ is taking place. For the fiscal year that ended in September, the government accepted 16,292 refugees. Apart from five from Afghanistan, all were white South Africans. It plans to accept more in the current fiscal year and is considering an ad campaign to encourage more white South Africans to apply. In a world scarred by conflicts, violent state repression and accelerating climate breakdown, these are the people it chooses to prioritise. This is what white supremacism looks like in practice.

No safe return

The conservative-dominated Supreme Court continues to remove protections. In June, it ruled that the administration could strip temporary protected status from Haitians and Syrians living legally in the USA, who until then had been safe from deportation. Some 360,000 people could be returned to countries the US government considers so dangerous it warns its citizens not to travel to them. Last year the court did the same for over 300,000 Venezuelans.

A group of Afghans, including relatives of people who worked with US forces and are at risk of being killed by the Taliban, is now threatened with deportation to Afghanistan. Court documents recently unsealed due to a lawsuit reveal that the government held secret talks with Iran, a country it’s at war with, on potentially deporting Iranians via another country. Those returned to Iran would be at risk of execution.

ICE is also targeting Chinese dissidents who came to the USA to escape authoritarianism, believing they’d be safe in a democracy. In September, ICE also detained Nicaraguan journalist Luis Galeano, stripped of citizenship by his country’s authoritarian regime in 2023, holding him for 12 days before releasing him on bail. Just months before, the government had imposed sanctions on over 100 Nicaraguan officials and called the country’s leadership an ‘enemy of humanity’.

Deportation deals

Third-country deportations have become the cornerstone of the administration’s architecture of cruelty. The USA pays governments to receive people who have no connection with their countries. It has bussed some 20,000 people to Mexico and sent around 5,000 people to other countries, including people who’ve lived most of their lives in the USA. Deportees report not being told where they’re going and being sent to countries where they don’t understand the language.

Striking these deals has become a leading foreign policy goal. Leveraging its global economic and political power, the USA has reached agreements with a reported 35 governments. They include more countries the US government deems too dangerous for its citizens, such as the Central African Republic and South Sudan, and others experiencing conflict, such as the Democratic Republic of the Congo. The list includes El Salvador, whose mass incarceration programme holds people in appalling conditions. Many of the countries have scant respect for basic freedoms. Burundi, Equatorial Guinea and Eswatini all have closed civic space, which means deportees will struggle to speak out about their conditions, and there are also few safeguards against US funding fuelling corruption.

The US government claims it’s deporting people with criminal records, but many have no such history. It also claims it’s meeting its legal obligation not to return people to countries where they’re likely to face persecution. But there is no control over where people end up, as receiving countries are free to deport people onwards to countries where they face grave danger. Those deported include Iranian protesters and LGBTQI+ people from African countries where their identity is criminalised. In May, United Nations (UN) human rights experts appealed to the government of Equatorial Guinea to stop its plans to return deportees to home countries where they face state violence.

The US government has earmarked at least US$410 million for these deals. Around US$81 million of the funding is for receiving governments, and they also gain political capital, since the USA is unlikely to criticise their human rights records. Other sweeteners may come as part of the package, such as the five-year healthcare cooperation programme the US government agreed last December with Eswatini, an absolute monarchy. Having destroyed its international aid programme, the Trump administration is making clear that whatever funding it still provides is there to serve its interests.

Most of the rest of the funding is going to the International Organization for Migration and the UN High Commissioner for Refugees to support people on arrival. Under Trump, the USA has selectively withdrawn from global bodies it sees as going against its interests or that might hold it to account. Its funding for UN humanitarian agencies to receive deportees shows the other side of the coin. It seeks to instrumentalise parts of the international system to pursue its goals. In doing so, it exploits the humanitarian missions of UN institutions while putting their credibility at risk, opening them up to accusations of complicity.

Migrants’ rights groups have challenged third-country deportations in court. In March 2025, they filed a lawsuit arguing the policy was illegal because of the risk of harm to deported people. The following month, a judge issued a preliminary injunction to pause deportations, but in June 2025, the Supreme Court suspended it, allowing deportations to resume. In September 2026, a federal appeals court ruled that the policy was unlawful because people didn’t have a proper chance to raise safety risks before deportation. The Supreme Court again quickly suspended the ruling.

Resistance in the face of cruelty

Civil society is leading the resistance to this assault on rights, shaping the political debate in ways that progressive politicians have been able to capitalise on.

Immigration lawyers are working tirelessly to defend their clients, and their interventions have stopped many deportations. Human rights groups are bringing lawsuits to challenge detention conditions, such as one highlighting the risk of death or serious injury at Camp East Montana in Texas, where guards reportedly use physical and verbal violence as a matter of routine. Despite an increasingly skewed judicial system, litigation is having an impact. Following a court order obtained by a free-speech group, the government has recently agreed to drop its attempts to pressure Apple and Meta to restrict platforms that track ICE officials and operations.

In progressive-leaning cities targeted for intensive ICE operations, communities have bravely mobilised. Volunteers monitor ICE agents, alert at-risk communities, make sure people know their rights and deploy at short notice to obstruct arrests. Movements organised by migrant workers and faith-based groups are playing a leading role. Groups are mobilising legal help and collecting the evidence of violations that will one day help hold perpetrators to account. Anti-ICE protests have continued, including outside detention centres.

Detainees are coming up with creative ways to tell their stories. They write about their experiences on tiny slips of paper, put them in small bottles and throw them to campaigners across detention centre walls. They draw their experiences and mail the pictures to relatives and sing protest songs down phone lines.

Campaigning groups have found new ways to keep issues in the spotlight. Ahead of the 2026 FIFA World Cup, the No ICE in the Cup campaign shared artists’ posters for anyone to download and display in US host cities, as part of a wider push to keep immigration enforcement away from stadiums and public spaces.

In resisting, civil society faces tremendous risks at the hands of an administration whose first response is violence. In January, federal immigration agents shot dead Renee Good and Alex Pretti during Operation Metro Surge, an aggressive campaign of arrests and detentions in Minnesota. Recently, in Modesto, California, ICE officers pepper-sprayed a pregnant US citizen who was protesting outside a jail. Protesters face mass arrests, and the government has labelled them ‘domestic terrorists’.

Time for change

For the many who’ve already suffered at the administration’s hands, the damage is done. The USA’s approach has also had international repercussions. In 2025, the State Department created an Office of Remigration to help deport those deemed to be in the USA illegally. Its title uses a term, ‘remigration’, coined by European far-right parties that campaign for ethnic cleansing through the mass deportation of non-white people. By bringing the term into government, the Trump administration has legitimised white supremacism.

European right-wing parties have copied the Trump administration, calling for their own versions of ICE to conduct immigration raids. In Belgium, parliament has just approved a law to allow police to forcibly enter homes that may be housing undocumented migrants, bringing the prospect of ICE-style raids to the heart of Europe. Meanwhile, deportations to third countries are becoming normalised in Europe. Five European Union states have just announced plans to set up a deportation hub in Rwanda.

Democrats must use their new power to start reversing this tide. In Congress, they’ll still need to build bridges with Republicans to override the presidential veto and craft legislation to curb ICE’s cruellest excesses and extend protections and pathways for more undocumented migrants to regularise their status. At state and city levels, where Democrats will soon have much more power, including the governorships of the four states that border Mexico, they can limit their cooperation with ICE and extend local protections such as sanctuary city policies. Civil society has shown the way by leading resistance and keeping hope alive. Now newly elected politicians must deliver.