he United States mid-term elections have spoken. The Democrats won both House and Senate in a sweeping rebuttal of US President Donald Trump’s erratic management of US domestic and foreign affairs. 

Despite this, the trajectory of US-China geopolitical rivalry will remain unchanged for decades to come with every chance of escalation. The prestigious journal Foreign Affairs, is introspectively reexamining “The Delusions of American Power” in its latest issue.  In the lead article, “Limits of American Power”, the author concluded that even with the strongest military, technology and financial prowess, American power will be limited by the will of her enemies, her hesitancy to put troops on the ground, by time and the quality of her leadership, political and military. 

Will technology be the deciding factor? Empire historian Niall Ferguson and tech mogul Eric Schmidt argue in “Empires of AI” that ”AI is by its nature an imperial technology”, but “an empire is only as durable as its capacity to pay for itself.”  

“AI is the most capital-intensive imperial project in history, undertaken by two super-powers that are already weighed down by debt”. They think that conflict and decline are both already baked in the game.

I would argue that framing the contest of the century as who will win or lose is too narrow a question, because we are dealing with complex systems competing against each other within even more multi-player complex systems, as such climate warming and global demographics, in which random or unknown factors can affect the long-term outcome.

The question of which imperial system would emerge during the Industrial Revolution was first critically examined by Karl Marx and later Vladimir Lenin. They broke with the 19th century classical economists who framed wealth and power based on the factors of land, labor and capital.

The Jakarta Post - Newsletter Icon

Every Thursday

Whether you’re looking to broaden your horizons or stay informed on the latest developments, “Viewpoint” is the perfect source for anyone seeking to engage with the issues that matter most.

for signing up our newsletter!

Please check your email for your newsletter subscription.


View More Newsletter

In the feudal economy, the landed gentry controlled the land and agriculture using serfs, whereas industrialists controlled wealth, capital and the working classes through energy and technology. Capital was the embodiment of human knowledge and technology that enabled the urban industrial class to replace the feudal powers.