“Fucking pricks! See you in court!” They insulate themselves, these lawyers we’ve met in War on HBO. Ensconced in their power centers, whether surrounded by the smell of burgundy leather at Cathcarts or the light-filled modernist spaces of Taylor & Byrne, they manage the moves of legal cases and the very lives of their clients with an elitism that projects assurance. Which is funny for us, because during the entire first season of this series — already renewed for Season 2 — we’ve witnessed how willing and excited these people get over the dirtiest of tricks. Remember how in Episode 1, the centrality of entrapment and payoffs to the Duval-Henderson divorce was like an afterthought? This is why it’s hilarious when Episode 8 of War, the Season 1 finale, begins with Nick Taylor and Serena Byrne hurling schoolyard insults at Beatrice Ubosi and St. John Smallwood, and vice versa. These competing sets of lawyers can’t figure out who dirty tricked who by leaking footage of Flora Monroe’s hotel hookup with Morgan Henderson to the media.   

The Flora stuff breaks as the rival firms were about to sign documents that compensated for the Johnny Warren situation. It destroys that agreement, and injects unpredictability into the second and final day of divorce court, where Carla will take the stand. Carla has also instructed her side to ask for shares, not cash, per her meet with Zephyr CFO Gillian Pope. And she is made aware of yet another facet of this dirty trick game. Outside court, Smallwood taunts her with spy photos that reveal her romantic meetups with Johnny. For his part, Morgan is freaking out to Cathcarts about the Flora leak. But Archie Panjabi gets one of the best lawyer lines of War Season 1 with this bit of projected assurance. Flora is irrelevant, she tells the client. With Carla as their focus, “I will break her.” 

What’s Johnny the Spy doing during all of this? Ransacking Smallwood’s office, obviously. Caught out by his lies and deceit, Johnny doubles down, manages a sneak into the partner’s chambers, and searches for something he can use. Which he finds in Morgan’s handwritten letter to Carla. It’s his heartfelt “this has all gone too far” missive from Episode 4, which Smallwood intercepted and tore in half. Johnny steals it and calls Flora.

Smirking Dominic West in 'War' Episode 8 Photo: HBO

“All you can do is do life your way. Live by your standards, not theirs.” Johnny and Flora’s talk in a quiet coffeeshop is interesting, because after reading the letter that was never sent, they align themselves with Morgan and Carla as victims of how Cathcarts and Taylor & Byrne do lawyering. On the verge of tears, Johnny says he’s learned you can’t be an attorney and a good person at the same time. And Flora sees herself as a pawn, ignored by Carla after the incident and shunned by Morgan, who she still claims she actually liked. Together, they come up with a plan, and Johnny phones Smallwood. “Flora wants to take the stand. Proof of the honeypot.”         

“I would like to call Flora Monroe.” Pru’s announcement in court elicits audible gasps from the gallery and icy looks between competing counsel. It’s an example of how all season, even as it has accelerated and slickly subverted the form, War has also ably hit the hard beats of a TV legal drama. 

But Flora on the stand is not the breaking blow Cathcarts expected. She reads from Morgan’s letter. How his indiscretions are real, but so is their lasting love for one another. How Carla deserves her fair share of what they built — Zephyr — and its future, “all without these lawyers coming between us.” And Flora clarifies that her Taylor & Byrne NDA was engineered by Johnny, a double agent in the lawyering ointment. More gasps. The victims have taken the power back from the lawyers.

'War' Episode 8 Photo: HBO

“50 percent of shares, monthly payments until he retires, and joint access to Gabriel.” Each firm is startled to learn all their elitist jockeying and street-level ratfucks really meant nothing. The power of the cottage in Normandy vibes came through in the end. The power of the letter, of real human emotions. Morgan and Carla resolved their divorce proceedings personally, as partners, and for their respective camps of high-priced attorneys? Actually, never mind.

Beatrice and Smallwood and Nick and Serena take their bows before the media. War intercuts their statements, the talked-up “massive win” for each of their clients. Even though, behind the scenes, all both of these sides did was muck it all up. Johnny appears at Taylor & Byrne — he’s back to pitching Serena for a job with his “Give me one month/day/second” speech. But Serena puts a pin in his groveling. She’s gone into labor, and orders her wayward (reformed?) junior associate to call an ambulance. She takes Nick’s hand as they head for the elevator. What happens now? They don’t know, and that’s OK. Their power center will shift to the birth of their son. And if either Nick and Serena or Beatrice and Smallwood have learned anything in all of this, well, we might not ever know. Season 2 of War will shift to other firms, other clients, and other forms of the legal profession’s projected assurances.

Discovery for War Season 1 Episode 8 (“Partners”):

An appropriate jammer to end a fabulous season of music supervision on War: “Walk of Life” from Dire Straits’ 1985 banger Brothers in Arms. “Here comes Johnny and he’ll tell you the story…” 

Johnny left a letter for Bella, and his keys to the flat. It seems he was inspired by Morgan’s words in more ways than one. We don’t see its contents, but Johnny seems content as he departs. We don’t see Bella, either, but War suggests she’s upstairs, waiting for him to leave her life.

War ends on that beach in Normandy, outside the cottage, with Carla and Morgan amicably separated on their own terms. Shares in Zephyr, corporate chicanery, buyouts? All of it can wait. For now, for the two of them, it’s tea time with Gabe.

Johnny Loftus (@johnnyloftus.bsky.social) is a Chicago-based writer. A veteran of the alternative weekly trenches, his work has also appeared in Entertainment Weekly, Pitchfork, The All Music Guide, and The Village Voice.