“I just don’t think anybody realises how unbelievably hurtful this is for our family.”
In February 2025, Justice Neil Campbell jailed Mulford, then 20, for five years and seven months when she appeared in the High Court at Hamilton.
Mulford challenged her sentence, with the case eventually reaching the Supreme Court after an unsuccessful appeal in the Court of Appeal.
In a reserved decision released on Thursday, the Supreme Court found that Mulford’s age – 17 at the time of the earlier strangulation offence – and youth-related issues reduced her culpability.
The court quashed her original sentence, finding a starting point of four years and nine months’ imprisonment was more appropriate than the seven years set by the sentencing judge.
One Supreme Court justice indicated he would have gone even lower.
Mulford was then resentenced to four years’ imprisonment.
‘No accountability’
For Niven and her family, the decision has reopened the pain of losing Harlee-Rose.
“Two of my four daughters went to the trial and followed it all the way through.”
Niven believed Mulford should have been given a longer prison sentence, not a shorter one.
“This is why we’ve got a high crime rate, because no one gives a f***.
“There are no consequences.”
She said the pain of losing Harlee-Rose was something her family would never get over.
“People say it changes with time. Well, no, it doesn’t because it just gets rehashed constantly.”
Niven also felt Mulford had failed to take accountability for her actions.
Fights, job loss and ‘hazy’ memory
The now 22-year-old has become eligible for parole and appeared before the Parole Board for the first time in August.
At the hearing, the family shared the same view – they felt Mulford lacked accountability, and they opposed her release.
Despite being classified as low security, Mulford has been involved in several incidents behind bars.
According to the board’s decision, she has lost a prison job for signing an invoice without authority, been involved in fights and been found in possession of unspecified “items”.
Mulford told the board her memory of Harlee-Rose’s death was “hazy”, which she attributed to trauma and drug abuse.
“Ms Mulford maintains that she does not remember the offending although her counsel emphasised this is not a denial,” the decision stated.
Overall, she was considered at medium risk of general and violent reoffending.
While Mulford did not seek parole, the board found she remained an undue risk without completing further rehabilitation, which she was keen to undertake, and declined an early release.
She is next due before the board in May.
Harlee-Rose’s death and Mulford’s appeals
Harlee-Rose died from her catastrophic injuries on April 9, 2022, while living in Hamilton with her father Dylan Berry and his partner, Mulford.
The earlier strangulation occurred while they were living in Tauranga on November 9, 2021.
At sentencing, Justice Campbell convicted and discharged her on the strangulation charge.
He said that, while the cause of Harlee-Rose’s death had been determined, the mechanism remained unknown.
“But it is consistent with stomping, kicking or punching” with such force that it split her pancreas in two, lacerated her liver and would have left her unconscious within minutes.
In September last year, Mulford’s counsel, Nick Dutch, failed in a Court of Appeal bid to have her prison term halved, arguing that her age, background factors and the starting point warranted a greater reduction.
The Court of Appeal judges said that, while another judge may have given a slightly greater discount for her young age and mental health at the time, they would not.
“We are not persuaded that an allowance of 15% amounts to error warranting appellate intervention in a case involving, as this one did, such extreme violence against a defenceless toddler.”
Dutch and co-counsel Rebekah Webby then took the case to the Supreme Court, challenging the Court of Appeal’s decision to dismiss the appeal.
In the Supreme Court, the defence submitted that the uplift for the strangulation meant Mulford was effectively serving a prison sentence for that charge.
They argued that, had Mulford been charged at the time for the strangulation, she would have been dealt with in the Youth Court and would probably have been discharged without notation.
“It was inherently unfair that Ms Mulford was sentenced to a higher term of imprisonment only because the prosecution was not promptly commenced,” the decision stated.
Justice Stephen Kos, writing for the Supreme Court, acknowledged that the earlier violence increased the seriousness of the manslaughter because the fatal assault was not an isolated act.
It should have made Mulford aware of her “capacity to lose control”.
“At the same time, however, it would be appropriate to take into account that the earlier violence occurred when the offender was a child, subject to very similar agency-reducing circumstances as applied at the time of the index offending, which in turn reduces its significance in terms of culpability.”
Her youth-related factors, isolation, inexperience, impulsivity and inability to cope with stress, alongside associated mental health issues such as depression and mental distress, also reduced Mulford’s culpability.
While considering the earlier offending, the court said it would have adopted a six-year starting point for the manslaughter if she had been an adult.
However, after considering other case law and legal factors relating to her age at the time of the strangulation, the court concluded that a sentence of four years and nine months was appropriate.
They allowed a 5% discount for Mulford’s previous trauma and mental health, and a further 10% for her “good rehabilitation prospects”.
“The end sentence, therefore, is one of four years’ imprisonment.”
Belinda Feek is an Open Justice reporter based in Waikato. She has worked at NZME for 11 years and has been a journalist for 22.